---
title: "CPUC proposal would cut PG&E's 5,000-mile undergrounding plan to about 1,100 miles"
description: "A judge has moved $1.7 billion of wildfire costs onto California ratepayers, and on November 19 the commission votes on a cost test PG&E says would strike 3,900 miles from the capital it earns on. The utility has already cut $2 billion from its own 2027 plan."
publisher: "The Inference"
section: "Power"
published: 2026-11-16T16:22:38.537Z
modified: 2026-11-16T16:22:38.537Z
canonical: https://theinference.org/article/cpuc-proposal-would-cut-pg-e-s-5-000-mile-undergrounding-plan-to-about-1-100-miles
language: en
keywords: "PG&E, California, Wildfire Safety, Utilities, Regulation"
---

# CPUC proposal would cut PG&E's 5,000-mile undergrounding plan to about 1,100 miles

> A judge has moved $1.7 billion of wildfire costs onto California ratepayers, and on November 19 the commission votes on a cost test PG&E says would strike 3,900 miles from the capital it earns on. The utility has already cut $2 billion from its own 2027 plan.

## Forty-three miles go first

Twelve miles of planned underground line in Fresno County and 31 in Madera County would all become ineligible under [a proposed decision the California Public Utilities Commission issued on October 16](https://theinference.org/article/california-may-cut-pg-e-s-5-000-mile-fire-safety-plan-to-1-100-miles-and-with-it-the-growth-engine) [1]. The decision writes the cost rules for Senate Bill 884, [the 2022 law that created the pathway for ten-year burial plans](https://www.msn.com/en-us/money/general/cpuc-proposal-could-sharply-limit-pg-e-s-10-year-power-line-undergrounding-plan/ar-AA2hpac9) [2]. PG&E says its standardized cost-benefit test would leave about 1,100 of the 5,000 miles in its 2028-2037 plan standing [1].

"So 80% of what we had planned to underground would no longer be eligible," said Matt Pender, [PG&E](https://theinference.org/markets/companies/pg-e-corporation)'s vice president of undergrounding and system hardening [2]. The commission votes on November 19 [2]. The filed plan carries roughly $16 billion, about $9 a month on the average bill, for lines PG&E says cut ignition risk about 98% [3]. It has buried 1,500 miles since 2021, 325 of them this year [4].

*Chart: **The CPUC cost test would leave a fifth of PG&E's 10-year undergrounding plan standing** Bar chart of PG&E undergrounding mileage: 1,500 miles buried by November 2026, 5,000 miles filed for 2028-2037, and about 1,100 miles PG&E says remain eligible under the CPUC's proposed cost test*

*Miles of distribution line. Eligibility is PG&E's estimate if the October 16 proposed decision is adopted as written. Sources: PG&E release (9 Nov 2026); KMPH; KRCR. [1][2][4]*

## One docket pays PG&E, the other cuts it

On November 13 a commission judge found ratepayers should pay the $1.7 billion still owed from the 2019 Kincade and 2021 Dixie fires, [the first such decision under Assembly Bill 1054](https://www.nbcbayarea.com/investigations/ratepayers-on-the-hook-pge/4175998/); upheld, it clears PG&E to raise rates for the remainder [5]. The Inference reported that ruling on November 14 [5]. Six days later, the same commission votes on striking most of the capital PG&E earns on.

## Twelve point eight billion spent, two billion pulled back

The utility spent about $12.8 billion on capital across the four quarters to September [6]. On September 2, [after the state Assembly let a wildfire liability bill die](https://www.morningstar.com/news/dow-jones/202609024182/pge-initiates-strategic-review-after-california-wildfire-bill-fails), [it deferred $2 billion of 2027 spending](https://theinference.org/article/pg-e-s-2-billion-deferral-looks-like-leverage-and-the-ai-power-queue-is-what-it-protects) and kept $11.4 billion [7]. Guidance beyond 2027 is suspended while a board review spanning ring fencing to sales and separations reports by summer 2027 [8].

*Chart: **PG&E's capital spending has topped operating cash flow in 10 of the last 12 quarters** Column chart comparing PG&E's quarterly capital spending with its operating cash flow from the fourth quarter of 2023 through the third quarter of 2026; capital spending runs above operating cash flow in ten of the twelve quarters, and the gap has widened as spending rose above $3 billion a quarter.*

*Capital spending and cash from operations, $ billions, by calendar quarter. Capital spending is reported as positive. Sources: PG&E quarterly figures from its SEC filings, retrieved 16 November 2026. [6]*

Debt stood at $65.5 billion at the end of September, and the below-investment-grade financing issued since 2017 will cost about $4 billion in extra interest [8]. One docket hands PG&E $1.7 billion it can bill customers for; the other takes away the wires it bills on [8].

## The load still grows, and so does the resistance

Demand is not the problem. PG&E told investors that newly connected data-center capacity reached 174 megawatts by the third quarter, nearly double the 88 at mid-year [9]. The sector is leaning in: [Duke Energy](https://theinference.org/markets/companies/duke-energy) reaffirmed a $103 billion five-year capital plan this month, and [Xcel Energy](https://theinference.org/markets/companies/xcel-energy) rolled out $70 billion [10]. PG&E's 2027 core earnings guidance of $1.78 to $1.82 a share still stands [8].

The commission's case is that the test prioritizes the highest fire-threat areas by risk reduction, reliability and cost efficiency, and forces comparison with cheaper options such as covered conductor [2]. Consumer Watchdog, an advocacy group, calls the $2 billion deferral "bailout blackmail," and the commission's ratepayer arm [moved on October 23 to reopen PG&E's 2027 revenue request](https://finance.yahoo.com/energy/articles/no-bailout-blackmail-pg-e-193700185.html) so customers do not pay for work no longer planned [11]. Three dates decide the next leg: the vote on November 19, capital guidance with February's results, and the review's answer by summer [2][8].

## Takeaway

A judge handed PG&E $1.7 billion of ratepayer-funded wildfire costs on November 13; six days later the same commission votes on a cost test PG&E says would strike 3,900 miles from the ten-year undergrounding plan it earns on.

## Sources

1. [KMPH Fox 26, Proposed CPUC ruling could scrap PG&E undergrounding projects in Fresno, Madera counties, 15 November 2026](https://kmph.com/news/local/proposed-cpuc-ruling-could-scrap-pge-undergrounding-projects-in-fresno-madera-counties)
2. [KRCR News Channel 7, CPUC proposal could sharply limit PG&E's 10-year power line undergrounding plan, 13 November 2026](https://www.msn.com/en-us/money/general/cpuc-proposal-could-sharply-limit-pg-e-s-10-year-power-line-undergrounding-plan/ar-AA2hpac9)
3. [CBS Sacramento, Proposed SB 884 implementation would reduce undergrounding of powerlines, PG&E says, 6 November 2026](https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/other/proposed-sb-884-implementation-would-reduce-undergrounding-of-powerlines-pg-e-says/ar-AA2gVGm9)
4. [PG&E press release via PR Newswire, PG&E Achieves 1,500-Mile Milestone in Major Wildfire Safety Undergrounding Effort, 9 November 2026](https://finance.yahoo.com/energy/articles/pg-e-achieves-1-500-200000649.html)
5. [NBC Bay Area, Ratepayers on the hook for $1.7 billion unpaid bill for Kincade, Dixie fires, regulatory judge decides, 13 November 2026](https://www.nbcbayarea.com/investigations/ratepayers-on-the-hook-pge/4175998/)
6. [PG&E Corporation, quarterly figures from its SEC filings, retrieved 16 November 2026](https://www.sec.gov/cgi-bin/browse-edgar?action=getcompany&CIK=0001004980)
7. [Morningstar / Dow Jones Newswires, PG&E Initiates Strategic Review After California Wildfire Bill Fails, 2 September 2026](https://www.morningstar.com/news/dow-jones/202609024182/pge-initiates-strategic-review-after-california-wildfire-bill-fails)
8. [Trefis via Yahoo Finance, What Changed In PG&E's Story?, 12 November 2026](https://finance.yahoo.com/markets/stocks/articles/changed-pg-es-story-165607052.html)
9. [Trader-Zeitung Agentic, PG&E Corporation bestätigt Jahresziele für 2026, kürzt Investitionsplan um 2 Milliarden US-Dollar, 16 November 2026](https://traderzeitung.de/newsticker/traderzeitung-agentic/pge-corporation-bestaetigt-jahresziele-fuer-2026-kuerzt-investitionsplan-um-2-milliarden-us-dollar-und-leitet-strategische-ueberpruefung-ein-51296.html)
10. [ElectricalRoles.com, Duke's $103B Plan, Fortis' Record Budget and the Utility Boom, 15 November 2026](https://electricalroles.com/blog/duke-103b-fortis-32b-emera-southern-utility-capital-plans-nov-2026)
11. [Consumer Watchdog via PR Newswire, No Bailout Blackmail: PG&E Is Crying Wolf Over $2 Billion in Spending Delays, 2 November 2026](https://finance.yahoo.com/energy/articles/no-bailout-blackmail-pg-e-193700185.html)


---

CPUC proposal would cut PG&E's 5,000-mile undergrounding plan to about 1,100 miles — The Inference. Canonical: https://theinference.org/article/cpuc-proposal-would-cut-pg-e-s-5-000-mile-undergrounding-plan-to-about-1-100-miles
