---
title: "DoorDash denies surveillance pricing and asks lawmakers to exempt its discounts"
description: "The same document concedes fees vary by address and order workload, and the exemptions DoorDash wants cover coupons, discounts and loyalty programs, the lines where its prices already differ by customer. Washington writes the pricing rules, New York the courier rules, and DASH holders own both unresolved risks at 4.0 times trailing sales."
publisher: "The Inference"
section: "Policy & Labor"
published: 2026-11-20T15:34:42.155Z
modified: 2026-11-20T15:34:42.155Z
canonical: https://theinference.org/article/doordash-denies-surveillance-pricing-and-asks-lawmakers-to-exempt-its-discounts
language: en
keywords: "DoorDash, Surveillance Pricing, FTC, New York City, Instacart"
---

# DoorDash denies surveillance pricing and asks lawmakers to exempt its discounts

> The same document concedes fees vary by address and order workload, and the exemptions DoorDash wants cover coupons, discounts and loyalty programs, the lines where its prices already differ by customer. Washington writes the pricing rules, New York the courier rules, and DASH holders own both unresolved risks at 4.0 times trailing sales.

[DoorDash](https://theinference.org/markets/companies/doordash) put a promise on paper this week: the same item, from the same store, at the same time, for every customer, with every fee shown before checkout, and no prices built on order history, phone type or protected characteristics [1][2]. The exceptions sit inside the same document. Fees still vary by delivery address and by how much work an order takes, and bad weather can add a fee, disclosed in advance [1][2].

## The FTC ordered nine companies to explain their prices

On October 28 the Federal Trade Commission ordered nine companies, DoorDash and Instacart among them, [to detail how they set prices, including any use of AI going back to January 2023 and their A/B tests](https://www.businessinsider.com/ftc-probes-data-use-in-pricing-by-uber-doordash-walmart-2026-10) [3][1]. Chair Andrew Ferguson said consumers deserve to know whether firms estimate "the highest price they can charge each consumer" [3][1].

The stock shows what is at stake: DoorDash [closed November 19 at $157.13, down 5.8% on the day and 29.7% over three months](https://finance.yahoo.com/markets/stocks/articles/sent-doordash-stock-lower-120209737.html), still priced at 4.0 times trailing sales [4]. Third-quarter revenue was a record $4.6 billion, up 34% a year, 23% excluding the Deliveroo acquisition, on 993 million orders [5].

*Chart: **DoorDash revenue hit a record $4.6B last quarter while its pricing rules sat unwritten** Line chart of DoorDash quarterly revenue from Q4 2023 to Q3 2026, rising steadily from $2.3 billion to a record $4.6 billion.*

*Quarterly revenue as reported, US$ billions, from SEC filings; Q3 2026 confirmed in the October 29, 2026, results release. [5][11]*

## The carve-out covers the discounts DoorDash already runs

DoorDash backs a surveillance-pricing ban, with a carve-out for "the deals that help people save money every day, like coupons, discounts, or loyalty programs" [1]. Those deals are the funnel. The platform discounts by order frequency and lets merchants aim offers at shoppers who bought similar products before [2]. How much order frequency those discounts buy is undisclosed.

## DashPass is the affordability case for the carve-out

[DashPass](https://theinference.org/article/doordash-s-dashos-owns-the-restaurant-s-customer-data-as-fee-cutting-rivals-circle), its paid membership, grew strongly last quarter and has helped cut US restaurant fees per order by 9% over two years [5]. Its case is affordability: "banning deals clearly would not do that" [1]. Emily Peterson-Cassin of the Consumer Federation of America says the carve-out could "absolutely" be a loophole, because a discount used to win a shopper can be withheld from a customer who already buys weekly [1].

## New York writes the labor half of the bill

Washington writes the revenue rules; New York writes the labor rules. [Amazon](https://theinference.org/markets/companies/amazon) [pushed notices to New York City shoppers on November 19](https://finance.yahoo.com/news/politics/articles/amazon-pushes-alerts-urging-yorkers-191506608.html) warning the Delivery Protection Act could add up to $5 per order, a figure Amazon has not shown its math for, and threatened to move operations out of the city [6][7].

![A delivery courier rides a bicycle through heavy snow past a Manhattan storefront, bags of food hanging from the handlebars](https://storage.googleapis.com/theinference-public/img/428eac75ad76f6a5.jpg)

*A food delivery courier on a snow-covered Manhattan sidewalk in January 2026. New York City's Delivery Protection Act would require last-mile operators to employ their couriers directly. (Tessa Bury)*

The bill would make last-mile operators employ their couriers directly; a City Council majority reportedly backs it, with no vote scheduled [7]. DoorDash [paid $131.5 million in September](https://theinference.org/article/doordash-turns-couriers-shelf-photos-into-a-paid-data-product-days-after-settling-131-5m-over-their-hours) to settle the city's finding that it underpaid or late-paid couriers, after December 2023 tipping changes cut average tips from $3.66 to 93 cents in a week [8].

## Three open decisions set what the rules cost

DoorDash, for optics, is waiving delivery fees on an estimated 2 million holiday meals for 300-plus food banks through Christmas [9], while [Olo](https://theinference.org/article/olo-takes-a-flat-5-on-delivery-where-doordash-and-uber-eats-charge-restaurants-up-to-30) keeps pitching merchants flat-fee delivery against its commissions [2]. Three things settle what the rules cost: the exemption language in any federal ban, the Council vote, and [the Justice Department's review of the $17 billion Instacart purchase](https://theinference.org/article/doj-takes-doordash-s-17-billion-instacart-deal-while-sequoia-partners-sit-on-both-boards), which carries a $1.25 billion breakup fee [10].

Fourth-quarter [guidance is $35.4 billion to $36.4 billion in order value](https://finance.yahoo.com/markets/stocks/articles/doordash-releases-third-quarter-2026-112000047.html), and results land in February [5][4]. The ban DoorDash wants would outlaw the pricing it says it never does and protect the discounts it runs every day.

## Takeaway

DoorDash backs a surveillance-pricing ban as long as it exempts coupons, discounts and loyalty programs: the same levers that already make its prices differ by customer, and the ones Washington and New York are now writing rules about.

## Sources

1. [Inc.com, 'DoorDash Says It Won't Use Your Data to Raise Prices. Its Exceptions Could Undermine That Promise', 19 November 2026](https://www.inc.com/amaya-nichole/doordash-says-wont-use-data-raise-prices-exceptions-could-undermine-promise/91439796)
2. [Restaurant Dive, 'DoorDash denies using surveillance pricing', 18 November 2026](https://www.restaurantdive.com/news/doordash-rejects-surveillance-pricing-political-backlash/875057/)
3. [Business Insider, 'The FTC asks companies from Uber to Walmart about how they personalize the prices you pay', 28 October 2026](https://www.businessinsider.com/ftc-probes-data-use-in-pricing-by-uber-doordash-walmart-2026-10)
4. [Yahoo Finance (Trefis), 'What Sent DoorDash Stock Lower?', 20 November 2026](https://finance.yahoo.com/markets/stocks/articles/sent-doordash-stock-lower-120209737.html)
5. [DoorDash (Business Wire via Yahoo Finance), 'DoorDash Releases Third Quarter 2026 Financial Results', 29 October 2026](https://finance.yahoo.com/markets/stocks/articles/doordash-releases-third-quarter-2026-112000047.html)
6. [Business Insider, 'Amazon threatens higher NYC fees if Delivery Act passes', 19 November 2026](https://www.businessinsider.com/amazon-threatens-higher-nyc-fees-if-delivery-act-passes-2026-11)
7. [Yahoo News (Progressive), 'Amazon Pushes Alerts Urging New Yorkers to Oppose NYC's Delivery Protection Act', 19 November 2026](https://finance.yahoo.com/news/politics/articles/amazon-pushes-alerts-urging-yorkers-191506608.html)
8. [6abc (WABC), ''We screwed up.' DoorDash admits mistakes in $131.5M settlement over NYC worker pay', 22 September 2026](https://6abc.com/story/doordash-settlement-company-pay-1315m-underpaying-new-york-city-delivery-workers/19857608/)
9. [StockTitan (Business Wire), 'DoorDash Helping Families Put Food on the Table This Holiday Season', 16 November 2026](https://www.stocktitan.net/news/DASH/door-dash-helping-families-put-food-on-the-table-this-holiday-bql9wuk5wiww.html)
10. [PYMNTS, 'DoorDash's $17 Billion Instacart Deal Faces DOJ Review', 17 November 2026](https://www.pymnts.com/news/acquiring/2026/doordashs-17-billion-instacart-deal-faces-doj-review/)
11. [DoorDash, quarterly figures from its SEC filings, retrieved 20 November 2026](https://www.sec.gov/cgi-bin/browse-edgar?action=getcompany&CIK=0001792789)


---

DoorDash denies surveillance pricing and asks lawmakers to exempt its discounts — The Inference. Canonical: https://theinference.org/article/doordash-denies-surveillance-pricing-and-asks-lawmakers-to-exempt-its-discounts
