---
title: "Internal emails show Newsom's office reviewed PG&E's $21 billion wildfire safety certificate"
description: "The 2019 safety certificate is what lets PG&E bill a $21 billion state fund instead of shareholders when its equipment starts fires. The week internal emails placed the governor's office inside that decision, his appointees approved $456 million more from ratepayers, and Einhorn's Greenlight raised its bet to 10 million shares."
publisher: "The Inference"
section: "Policy & Labor"
published: 2026-11-21T15:20:35.504Z
modified: 2026-11-21T15:20:35.504Z
canonical: https://theinference.org/article/internal-emails-show-newsom-s-office-reviewed-pg-e-s-21-billion-wildfire-safety-certificate
language: en
keywords: "PG&E, Gavin Newsom, California, Wildfire, Regulation"
---

# Internal emails show Newsom's office reviewed PG&E's $21 billion wildfire safety certificate

> The 2019 safety certificate is what lets PG&E bill a $21 billion state fund instead of shareholders when its equipment starts fires. The week internal emails placed the governor's office inside that decision, his appointees approved $456 million more from ratepayers, and Einhorn's Greenlight raised its bet to 10 million shares.

## The governor's office wanted to see the draft

In August 2019, weeks after Governor Gavin Newsom signed AB 1054, Pacific Gas and Electric asked the California Public Utilities Commission for the new law's central prize: a safety certificate [1]. [Internal commission emails published by City Journal on November 18](https://www.city-journal.org/article/pge-newsom-wildfire-safety-certificate) show the draft did not stay inside the regulator [1].

Commission president Marybel Batjer wrote, "I think the GO would most certainly want to see again," the GO apparently being the governor's office [1]. Alice Stebbins, then the commission's executive director, says she was told, "Sign it. You have to sign this," signed in August 2019, and was fired in September 2020 [1][2].

This was a utility that had pleaded guilty to 84 counts of manslaughter for the 2018 Camp Fire, which killed 85 people in Paradise [1]. The certificate decides who pays: under AB 1054, a certified utility is rebuttably presumed to have acted reasonably, so wildfire claims draw on a $21 billion state fund rather than shareholders [1]. The certificate is the hinge the whole structure swings on.

![A brick chimney standing alone among the ruins of a burned house in Paradise, California, with charred trees behind it](https://storage.googleapis.com/theinference-public/img/47eed3ba267f374a.jpg)

*A fireplace chimney stands amid the ruins of a home in Paradise, California, eight months after the 2018 Camp Fire, which killed 85 people. (Frank Schulenburg)*

## A million dollars moved first

City Journal counts at least $1 million from PG&E and its foundation, over nearly 30 years, to entities tied to Newsom, his wife and his causes: $58,400 to his 2018 run for governor, $150,000 to a Newsom-aligned committee, more than $350,000 to the Representation Project, the nonprofit run by Jennifer Siebel Newsom, and $250,000 each behind two ballot measures he endorsed [1].

*Chart: **At least $1 million from PG&E and its foundation reached Newsom-tied causes** Bar chart of contributions counted by City Journal from PG&E and its foundation to Newsom-tied entities over nearly 30 years: $58.4K to his 2018 run for governor, $150K to a Newsom-aligned committee, $250K each to two endorsed ballot measures and a floor of $350K to the Representation Project.*

*Contributions counted by City Journal over nearly 30 years, US$ thousands. The Representation Project figure is a floor, more than $350,000, and the two ballot measures received $250,000 each. Source: City Journal, November 18, 2026. [1]*

No document in the record establishes a trade, and neither the governor's office nor PG&E answered the outlet's requests for comment [1]. The direction shows on the bills: up nearly 70 percent since 2020, with six rate increases in 2024 alone, while [PG&E Corporation](https://theinference.org/markets/companies/pg-e-corporation) chief executive Patti Poppe calls Newsom "probably the leading governor in the nation" on wildfire risk [1].

## Then $456 million more, on the way out

On November 19, Newsom's appointees on the commission unanimously approved up to $456 million in interim rate recovery, collectible from customers starting January 1, 2027, while PG&E's general rate case stays open [3][7][8]. The commission's own Public Advocates Office had [warned on October 23 that PG&E's plan to defer about $2 billion of 2027 grid investment](https://consumerwatchdog.org/energy/newsoms-cpuc-appointees-approve-456-million-pge-rate-hike-before-becerra-takes-office-despite-unanswered-questions-about-2-billion-in-spending-cuts/), including connections for some 25,000 customers, leaves its revenue request overstated [3][4]. Anything collected above the final authorization, expected in May 2027, must be refunded with interest [7]. Governor-elect Xavier Becerra, who has called for a rate freeze, takes office within weeks [3][4].

## Einhorn is betting the shield holds

[Greenlight's 13F, the quarterly filing that shows what US stock funds hold](https://finance.yahoo.com/markets/stocks/articles/inside-david-einhorn-portfolio-every-200518948.html), was filed November 16: [David Einhorn](https://theinference.org/markets/people/david-einhorn)'s firm ended September with 10 million PG&E shares worth $122 million, 51 percent more than in June and its sixth-largest position, even after he wrote that PG&E "did not obtain legislative relief from its wildfire risk" [5]. The case for it is a 20.2 percent operating margin, a ten-year high [6]. Against it: free cash flow of minus $4.98 billion over twelve months, and debt up four straight quarters to $65.5 billion, more than twice the $30.7 billion market value [6][9].

*Chart: **PG&E's debt climbed to more than twice its market value** Line chart of PG&E's total debt from Q4 2023 to Q3 2026, rising from $57.7B to $65.5B, well above a reference line at its $30.7B market value.*

*Total debt at quarter end, US$ billions, from PG&E's SEC filings; market value per Yahoo Finance, November 2026. [6][9]*

## Two dates will set who eats the wildfire bill

PG&E has already cut its 2027 capital plan to $11.4 billion, promised no new shares at this price, and opened a structural review due by summer 2027 [6]. The Inference covered the [$2 billion deferral](https://theinference.org/article/pg-e-s-2-billion-deferral-looks-like-leverage-and-the-ai-power-queue-is-what-it-protects) on November 11, when [the liability law had stalled](https://theinference.org/article/pg-e-s-5-1-billion-wildfire-cap-the-bill-must-reach-newsom-by-november-15-ratepayers-pay-the-rest) [6].

And 174 megawatts of data-center projects have come online since 2024, the load this spending was meant to carry [6]. Watch two dates: the May 2027 rate decision, which sets how much of the $456 million stands, and the structural review by summer 2027 [1][6]. If the certificate's presumption is reopened, the wildfire bill lands on a balance sheet that already owes $65.5 billion [1][6].

*Chart: **Capex has topped operating cash flow in ten of the last twelve quarters** Column chart comparing PG&E's quarterly capital spending with its operating cash flow from Q4 2023 to Q3 2026; capex exceeds operating cash flow in ten of the twelve quarters, most recently $3.3B against $2.5B.*

*Quarterly capital spending and cash from operations, US$ billions, from PG&E's SEC filings. Source: PG&E Corporation quarterly filings, retrieved November 21, 2026. [9]*

## Takeaway

Emails published by City Journal put Governor Gavin Newsom's office inside the 2019 decision that lets PG&E bill a $21 billion state fund instead of shareholders when its wires start fires. The same week, his appointees approved $456 million more from ratepayers, and David Einhorn's Greenlight raised its PG&E stake to 10 million shares.

## Sources

1. [City Journal, Christopher F. Rufo, Susan Crabtree and Kenneth Schrupp, 'How PG&E Bought Gavin Newsom', 18 November 2026](https://www.city-journal.org/article/pge-newsom-wildfire-safety-certificate)
2. [RedState, Teri Christoph, 'Newsom Rocked by Explosive New Corruption Allegations Involving $1M PG&E Money Trail', 19 November 2026](https://redstate.com/terichristoph/2026/11/19/newsom-rocked-by-explosive-corruption-allegations-involving-deadly-california-wildfires-n2209590)
3. [Consumer Watchdog, 'Newsom's CPUC Appointees Approve $456 Million PG&E Rate Hike Before Becerra Takes Office', 19 November 2026](https://consumerwatchdog.org/energy/newsoms-cpuc-appointees-approve-456-million-pge-rate-hike-before-becerra-takes-office-despite-unanswered-questions-about-2-billion-in-spending-cuts/)
4. [Action News Now, Robert Sheridan, 'PG&E gets $456M California rate hike amid spending questions', 20 November 2026](https://www.actionnewsnow.com/news/top-stories/pg-e-gets-456m-california-rate-hike-amid-spending-questions/article_de449849-a78e-496f-90b3-d10c772e49dd.html)
5. [Yahoo Finance (Insider Monkey), Roxanna Maglangit, 'Inside David Einhorn's Portfolio: Every Move He Made in the Third Quarter', 19 November 2026](https://finance.yahoo.com/markets/stocks/articles/inside-david-einhorn-portfolio-every-200518948.html)
6. [Yahoo Finance (Trefis), 'What Is Going On With PG&E Stock?', 20 November 2026](https://finance.yahoo.com/markets/stocks/articles/going-pg-e-stock-183428090.html)
7. [Securities.io, 'California Regulators Approve $456 Million Interim PG&E Rate Increase', 19 November 2026](https://www.securities.io/california-regulators-approve-456-million-interim-pg-and-e-rate-increase/)
8. [NBC Bay Area (via MSN), Jaxon Van Derbeken, 'CPUC approves PG&E interim rate hike for 2027', 20 November 2026](https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/other/cpuc-approves-pg-e-interim-rate-hike-for-2027/ar-AA2hOSCc)
9. [PG&E Corporation, quarterly figures from its SEC filings, retrieved 21 November 2026](https://www.sec.gov/cgi-bin/browse-edgar?action=getcompany&CIK=0001004980)


---

Internal emails show Newsom's office reviewed PG&E's $21 billion wildfire safety certificate — The Inference. Canonical: https://theinference.org/article/internal-emails-show-newsom-s-office-reviewed-pg-e-s-21-billion-wildfire-safety-certificate
