---
title: "Judge delays ruling on Visa and Mastercard's $38 billion swipe-fee deal; rejection means a 2027 trial"
description: "Final approval would lock in eight years of capped pricing and give 12 million merchants the right to refuse the networks' priciest cards. Rejection means a 2027 antitrust trial, and with the Federal Reserve's debit cap already vacated, every leg of the US card toll is under revision at once."
publisher: "The Inference"
section: "Economy"
published: 2026-11-17T18:00:50.077Z
modified: 2026-11-17T18:00:50.077Z
canonical: https://theinference.org/article/judge-delays-ruling-on-visa-and-mastercard-s-38-billion-swipe-fee-deal-rejection-means-a-2027-trial
language: en
keywords: "Antitrust, Payments, Visa, Mastercard, Interchange Fees"
---

# Judge delays ruling on Visa and Mastercard's $38 billion swipe-fee deal; rejection means a 2027 trial

> Final approval would lock in eight years of capped pricing and give 12 million merchants the right to refuse the networks' priciest cards. Rejection means a 2027 antitrust trial, and with the Federal Reserve's debit cap already vacated, every leg of the US card toll is under revision at once.

## One Brooklyn judge now holds 21 years of litigation

[Visa](https://theinference.org/markets/companies/visa) and [Mastercard](https://theinference.org/markets/companies/mastercard) asked US District Judge Brian Cogan on November 16 to [grant final approval to a $38 billion settlement](https://www.msn.com/en-us/money/other/visa-mastercard-urge-approval-of-38-billion-swipe-fee-settlement/ar-AA2hzHyZ) ending 21 years of antitrust litigation over swipe fees, the interchange charges merchants pay to accept cards [1]. After a 90-minute hearing in Brooklyn, Cogan deferred, promising a ruling "as soon as possible" [2]. Reject the deal, he warned, and there is no more "head-banging" toward a settlement: the case goes to trial in 2027 [2].

## The term sheet: a five-year haircut and an eight-year cap

The deal trims credit interchange by 10 basis points for five years and caps standard consumer card fees at 1.25% for eight years [1][3]. It retires the honor-all-cards rule, so a merchant can refuse commercial and premium rewards cards while still taking standard Visa or Mastercard plastic, though merchants still cannot pick among the banks that issue those cards [1]. More than 12 million merchants are covered; opponents count over 20 million affected businesses [1]. Approval starts a 90-day clock to rewrite network acceptance rules, with [steering pilots capped at 180 days a year](https://www.pymnts.com/credit-cards/2026/visa-and-mastercard-hearing-puts-premium-card-pilots-on-the-line/) [4].

## The fee quadrupled while the case aged

Visa and Mastercard collected $25.6 billion of US swipe fees in 2009, $111.2 billion in 2024 and $118.8 billion in 2025, an average rate of 2.36%, by Merchants Payments Coalition figures [1][5]. All networks combined took a record $198.25 billion in 2025 [5]. The plaintiffs' economists, Nobel laureate Joseph Stiglitz and University of Washington professor Keith Leffler, put merchant savings at $38 billion by 2031 and overall benefits at $224 billion [1][3]. That is roughly $7 billion a year against $118.8 billion collected, and 10 basis points is about 4% off the average fee [1][3].

*Chart: **Swipe fees quadrupled while the case aged** Column chart of US swipe fees collected by Visa and Mastercard: $25.6 billion in 2009, $111.2 billion in 2024 and $118.8 billion in 2025*

*US swipe fees collected by Visa and Mastercard, by Merchants Payments Coalition figures. The deal on offer trims credit interchange by 10 basis points, about 4% off the 2.36% average rate. [1][5]*

## Twenty-one years have paid merchants 11 cents on the dollar

The only cash this case has moved is [the separate $5.5 billion damages settlement reached in 2018](https://finance.yahoo.com/markets/stocks/articles/visa-mastercard-payouts-top-631m-131400949.html): Epiq, the class administrator, has paid $631.7 million to 689,340 merchants, about 11 cents per promised dollar, with $5.02 billion still in the fund as of September 30 [6].

That record feeds more than 1,000 objections from [Walmart](https://theinference.org/markets/companies/walmart), the National Retail Federation, Circle K and [DoorDash](https://theinference.org/markets/companies/doordash) [2]. Mithun Mansinghani, lawyer for the convenience-store camp, told Cogan that commercial and premium cards, by his count more than 90% of the market, keep their fees, and the deal is like "building a bridge that goes a quarter of the way across the Hudson" [1].

Visa's lawyer Michael Shuster answered that the relief is "potent" and the network is not "jumping with joy"; [American Express](https://theinference.org/markets/companies/american-express) and Discover sit outside the deal entirely [1].

## The fork: a written cap or an unpriced injunction

Approval writes the 1.25% cap and the steering rights into a contract for eight years [1][2]. Rejection opens a trial Cogan sized at roughly two months, an injunction phase he called a "protracted process," and an appeal to the Second Circuit [1][2]. The debit side is already live: [the Eighth Circuit vacated the Federal Reserve's 21-cent cap](https://www.jdsupra.com/legalnews/eighth-circuit-invalidates-federal-6261271/) on October 26, and the Fed has until about December 10 to seek a rehearing, [a deadline tracked on November 12](https://theinference.org/article/visa-and-mastercard-s-198-billion-swipe-fee-fight-reopens-with-a-december-10-fed-deadline) [7][8]. For the networks' investors, one path prices the cap today and the other leaves it to a court. The written ruling picks the fork.

## Takeaway

Judge Brian Cogan deferred after a 90-minute hearing, so eight years of capped fees or a 2027 antitrust trial now hangs on one written ruling.

## Sources

1. [Reuters (via MSN), "Visa, Mastercard urge approval of $38 billion swipe fee settlement," 16 November 2026](https://www.msn.com/en-us/money/other/visa-mastercard-urge-approval-of-38-billion-swipe-fee-settlement/ar-AA2hzHyZ)
2. [Payments Dive (via Yahoo Finance), "Visa, Mastercard face possible trial," 17 November 2026](https://finance.yahoo.com/markets/stocks/articles/visa-mastercard-face-possible-trial-124029337.html)
3. [Electronic Payments International (via Yahoo Finance), "US Judge defers ruling on $38bn Visa, Mastercard swipe fee settlement," 17 November 2026](https://finance.yahoo.com/economy/policy/articles/us-judge-defers-ruling-38bn-115500189.html)
4. [PYMNTS, "Visa and Mastercard Hearing Puts Premium Card Pilots on the Line," 16 November 2026](https://www.pymnts.com/credit-cards/2026/visa-and-mastercard-hearing-puts-premium-card-pilots-on-the-line/)
5. [Hoodline, "Visa, Mastercard Push $38 Billion Swipe-Fee Deal as Merchants Cry Foul," 16 November 2026](https://hoodline.com/2026/11/visa-mastercard-push-38-billion-swipe-fee-deal-as-merchants-cry-foul/)
6. [Payments Dive (via Yahoo Finance), "Visa-Mastercard payouts top $631M," 12 October 2026](https://finance.yahoo.com/markets/stocks/articles/visa-mastercard-payouts-top-631m-131400949.html)
7. [Ballard Spahr (via JD Supra), "Eighth Circuit Invalidates Federal Reserve's 21-Cent Debit Card Interchange Fee Cap," 29 October 2026](https://www.jdsupra.com/legalnews/eighth-circuit-invalidates-federal-6261271/)
8. [The Inference, "Visa and Mastercard's $198 billion swipe-fee fight reopens, with a December 10 Fed deadline," 12 November 2026](https://theinference.org/article/visa-and-mastercard-s-198-billion-swipe-fee-fight-reopens-with-a-december-10-fed-deadline)


---

Judge delays ruling on Visa and Mastercard's $38 billion swipe-fee deal; rejection means a 2027 trial — The Inference. Canonical: https://theinference.org/article/judge-delays-ruling-on-visa-and-mastercard-s-38-billion-swipe-fee-deal-rejection-means-a-2027-trial
