---
title: "Judge voids wildlife approval for the first US seabed mining sale, 31 million acres, due November 19"
description: "A federal judge vacated the Endangered Species Act basis for Thursday's $3 million-a-tract seabed auction off American Samoa, but issued no injunction and the agency still lists the sale. The exposure is private marks in seabed-mining names, not listed stocks."
publisher: "The Inference"
section: "Policy & Labor"
published: 2026-11-18T18:14:07.676Z
modified: 2026-11-18T18:14:07.676Z
canonical: https://theinference.org/article/judge-voids-wildlife-approval-for-the-first-us-seabed-mining-sale-31-million-acres-due-november-19
language: en
keywords: "Seabed Mining, Critical Minerals, Regulation, American Samoa, Courts"
---

# Judge voids wildlife approval for the first US seabed mining sale, 31 million acres, due November 19

> A federal judge vacated the Endangered Species Act basis for Thursday's $3 million-a-tract seabed auction off American Samoa, but issued no injunction and the agency still lists the sale. The exposure is private marks in seabed-mining names, not listed stocks.

## A ruling 72 hours out

Three days before the first United States deep-sea mining lease sale, a federal judge pulled its legal floor out. Judge Jill Otake of the US District Court in Honolulu ruled November 16 that the National Marine Fisheries Service violated the Endangered Species Act when it signed off on the auction in February 2026: the agency reviewed the sale and the survey work a lease allows, and "did not even attempt to consider the potential effects of post-leasing activities," the exploration and mining the leases exist to enable [1].

Her [41-page order](https://www.courthousenews.com/deep-sea-mining-sale-off-american-samoa-in-flux-after-wildlife-review-tossed/) called the review "cramped, expedited, informal" and apparently unprecedented for outer continental shelf leasing [2]. "As extinction is permanent, caution and foresight before acting are necessary," she wrote [2].

## 31 million acres at 19 cents an acre

The Interior Department's Marine Minerals Administration plans to auction two tracts off American Samoa's Manu'a Islands, about 16.3 million and 15.2 million acres, minimum bid $3 million each, for polymetallic nodules and ferromanganese crusts [1]. At the floor the two tracts would fetch $6 million, roughly 19 cents an acre: the auction tests whether America can lease its seabed at all, not who pays [1].

![A dark, lumpy polymetallic nodule from the Pacific Ocean lying on a pale surface beside a measuring ruler](https://storage.googleapis.com/theinference-public/img/9e4e401fb11d1ba0.jpg)

*A polymetallic nodule from the Pacific. The two American Samoa tracts are offered for nodules and ferromanganese crusts, which carry nickel, cobalt and manganese, and the floor bid works out to about 19 cents an acre. (Hannes Grobe / Wikimedia Commons)*

The process opened in June 2025 after an unsolicited request from [Impossible Metals](https://theinference.org/markets/companies/impossible-metals), an American mining company, less than two months after President Trump's offshore critical minerals order [1]. Interior Secretary Doug Burgum told G20 energy ministers in September that permits could come "within months" [1].

## Vacated, not stopped

The order vacated the wildlife letter but issued no injunction. The agency still listed the November 19 sale on November 17, and a spokesperson said it is "currently working to address the issues raised in [the court's opinion](https://thehill.com/homenews/6226829-judge-vacates-esa-review-underlying-offshore-mining/)" [3]. In a parallel challenge to the sale itself, Otake wrote that if the government proceeds, bidders "will be on notice that the Court has determined that NMFS violated the Endangered Species Act" [3]. [Earthjustice](https://earthjustice.org/press/2026/lawsuit-seeks-to-block-american-samoa-deep-sea-mining-lease-sale) attorney Chris [Eaton](https://theinference.org/markets/companies/eaton) called the ruling a win for the whales, sharks and turtles of American Samoa's waters [1].

## No ticker, only private marks

There is no ticker here. The exposure sits in private marks: Impossible Metals, backed by Y Combinator, closed a Series A with the family of [FedEx](https://theinference.org/markets/companies/fedex) founder Fred Smith that media reports put near $25 million at a roughly $110 million valuation, making the family its second-largest shareholder [4].

Its Eureka robot picked about 450 grams of nodules from more than 4,000 meters in a September scientific dive, announced November 9 [4]. A gram-scale sample against an auction whose legal basis was vacated 72 hours out is not a reason to pay up [5]. The International Seabed Authority has approved no commercial exploitation anywhere, and land-based nickel and cobalt producers keep selling [5].

## The other gates

[A second suit, filed October 19](https://earthjustice.org/press/2026/lawsuit-seeks-to-block-american-samoa-deep-sea-mining-lease-sale) by a council of Manu'a chiefs with the two conservation groups, argues the Outer Continental Shelf Lands Act does not authorize mineral leasing in any US territory, so a redone consultation may not be the only gate [6].

Impossible Metals' chief executive Steve Curnutte counters that "Eureka is proven, patented, and ready," scaling by adding robots one at a time rather than riser-pipe infrastructure [7]. Governor Pulaali'i Nikolao Pula called the sale "a historic moment" on the day of the ruling, while warning that tuna "supports thousands of livelihoods" [1]. Next reads: whether Thursday's auction runs, and the Marianas sale on December 16, challenged by the same lawyers [1].

## Takeaway

The legal floor under Thursday's American Samoa lease sale is gone, but the sale is not: bidders would be buying into a court finding that the wildlife review was unlawful, and that is a price on private marks, not a public ticker.

## Sources

1. [Pasquines, Federal judge throws out species approval for deep-sea mining sale off American Samoa, 17 November 2026](https://pasquines.us/2026/11/17/american-samoa-deep-sea-mining-judge-endangered-species-ruling/)
2. [Courthouse News Service, Deep-sea mining sale off American Samoa in flux after wildlife review tossed, 17 November 2026](https://www.courthousenews.com/deep-sea-mining-sale-off-american-samoa-in-flux-after-wildlife-review-tossed/)
3. [The Hill, Judge vacates ESA review underlying offshore mining, 17 November 2026](https://thehill.com/homenews/6226829-judge-vacates-esa-review-underlying-offshore-mining/)
4. [Reuters via Marine Technology News, Impossible Metals Tests AI Autonomous Deep Sea Mining Robot, 9 November 2026](https://www.marinetechnologynews.com/news/impossible-metals-tests-autonomous-667304)
5. [Quantilus Innovation, AI Takes a Deep Dive as Impossible Metals Advances Underwater Robotics, 13 November 2026](https://quantilus.com/article/ai-takes-a-deep-dive-as-impossible-metals-advances-underwater-robotics/)
6. [Earthjustice, Lawsuit Seeks to Block American Samoa Deep-sea Mining Lease Sale, 19 October 2026](https://earthjustice.org/press/2026/lawsuit-seeks-to-block-american-samoa-deep-sea-mining-lease-sale)
7. [Ocean News & Technology, Impossible Metals Eureka II AUV Achieves First Selective Nodule Recovery at 4,000 Meters, 10 November 2026](https://oceannews.com/news/science-technology/impossible-metals-eureka-ii-auv-achieves-first-selective-nodule-recovery-at-4000-meters/)


---

Judge voids wildlife approval for the first US seabed mining sale, 31 million acres, due November 19 — The Inference. Canonical: https://theinference.org/article/judge-voids-wildlife-approval-for-the-first-us-seabed-mining-sale-31-million-acres-due-november-19
