---
title: "One judge now holds Meta's privacy bill, and the bids are $3.45 billion and $40 billion"
description: "New Mexico asked a Santa Fe judge for $35 billion to $40 billion after a jury found 43.9 million privacy violations. Judge Francis Mathew rules by late October, and the bill lands on a stock just off its best month since 2022."
publisher: "The Inference"
section: "Policy & Labor"
published: 2026-10-03T07:15:17.728Z
modified: 2026-10-03T07:15:17.728Z
canonical: https://theinference.org/article/one-judge-now-holds-meta-s-privacy-bill-and-the-bids-are-3-45-billion-and-40-billion
language: en
keywords: "Meta, Privacy, Litigation, New Mexico, Facebook"
---

# One judge now holds Meta's privacy bill, and the bids are $3.45 billion and $40 billion

> New Mexico asked a Santa Fe judge for $35 billion to $40 billion after a jury found 43.9 million privacy violations. Judge Francis Mathew rules by late October, and the bill lands on a stock just off its best month since 2022.

## The charge, and dice already thrown

On Thursday New Mexico asked Judge Francis Mathew of Santa Fe's First Judicial District Court to order [Meta](https://theinference.org/markets/companies/meta) to pay $35 billion to $40 billion for misleading Facebook users about their data, a bill that lands within weeks on a stock just off [its best month since November 2022](https://finance.yahoo.com/markets/stocks/articles/meta-stock-rises-27-september-115455631.html) [1][2]. Meta's lawyer urged a cap of $345 million to $3.45 billion [3]. Mathew will rule by late October [3].

His question to both sides [at Thursday's hearing](https://www.reuters.com/world/us/new-mexico-wants-meta-pay-up-40-billion-penalties-after-data-privacy-trial-2026-10-01/) carries the whole story: "When the parties go to trial, they roll the dice. They have to accept the consequences of their decision to go to trial, do they not?" [1]

## 43.9 million violations, one statute's ceiling

The suit, filed in 2021, grew out of Cambridge Analytica's harvesting of data from as many as 87 million Facebook users [1]. On 25 September [a jury found 26 of 29 statements by Meta's leadership](https://www.yahoo.com/news/us/articles/mexico-jury-finds-facebook-liable-190640167.html), among them [Mark Zuckerberg](https://theinference.org/markets/people/mark-zuckerberg) and Sheryl Sandberg, false or deceptive [1][3]. Counted against Facebook's 1.4 million New Mexico users in 2020, that is 43,899,725 violations of the state's Unfair Practices Act [3][4].

The statute lets Mathew set the fine anywhere from $1 to $5,000 per violation, [a theoretical ceiling of about $219.5 billion on the verdict](https://www.yahoo.com/news/us/articles/mexico-seeks-judgment-40-billion-030500085.html) [3][4]. The state bid roughly a fifth of that arithmetic; Meta bid under 2 percent of it [1][3].

*Chart: **New Mexico asks more than ten times Meta's cap; the paper ceiling dwarfs both bids** Bar chart comparing Meta's proposed $345 million to $3.45 billion penalty cap, BP's $21 billion Deepwater Horizon judgment, New Mexico's $35 billion to $40 billion request, and the roughly $219.5 billion theoretical statutory ceiling.*

*Filed penalty positions, a comparison judgment and the theoretical statutory ceiling, in billions of US dollars. The ceiling applies the $5,000 maximum to 43,899,725 violations. Sources: Reuters; Albuquerque Journal; Yahoo News, 25 September to 1 October 2026. [1][3][4]*

## The fine is priced off the stock, not the harm

State lawyer Randi McGinn told the court the penalty should "speak to Meta in the only language it understands, which is money, and the value of its stock price," sized at about 20 percent of the possible awards, enough to dent the stock while surviving due process [1].

Meta's Matt Nicholson called the request an "astronomical penalty" that would top any civil judgment in US history, dwarfing the $21 billion BP paid for Deepwater Horizon and built, he said, on statements over "more than a decade" with "no evidence that any statement harmed any New Mexicans" [1][3].

New Mexico is not asking what the lies cost. It is asking what Meta can feel.

## Holders wear the number before anyone pays it

Holders wear it either way: the top ask nearly matches [the $42.6 billion Meta earned in the first half of 2026](https://www.sec.gov/cgi-bin/browse-edgar?action=getcompany&CIK=0001326801) [7]. The cash itself is years off. McGinn says Meta is likely to appeal any judgment, and New Mexico is unlikely to collect for years [3].

*Chart: **New Mexico's ask tops every quarter of profit Meta has booked in three years** Column chart of Meta's quarterly net income from Q3 2023 to Q2 2026, with a line for New Mexico's $40 billion request sitting above every quarter and a line for Meta's $3.45 billion proposed cap near the bottom.*

*Meta's quarterly net income, Q3 2023 through Q2 2026, in billions of US dollars. First-half 2026 net income totaled $42.6 billion, which New Mexico's $35 billion to $40 billion request nearly matches; Meta's lawyers propose capping the penalty at $345 million to $3.45 billion. Source: Sharadar quarterly fundamentals, from Meta's SEC filings, retrieved 2 October 2026. [7]*

The stock closed Thursday at $725.93 [5], after a 27 percent September built on [its Muse AI agent](https://theinference.org/article/after-muse-took-6-2-off-airbnb-chesky-promised-an-agent-and-the-hotels-he-swore-off), its strongest month since November 2022 [2]. New Mexico has already drawn [a $375 million jury penalty and a $567 million youth-fund order](https://www.theepochtimes.com/us/new-mexico-asks-judge-to-fine-meta-up-to-40-billion-in-facebook-privacy-case-6097710) from Meta in a child-safety case this year; Meta intends to appeal [6].

A ruling near the state's number hands every attorney general with a consumer statute a per-user, per-statement template. McGinn framed the ask as deterrence "not just for Meta but for any big company that would lie to the people of New Mexico" [3]. No state has filed a copycat claim yet; the arithmetic that produced 43.9 million violations is simply easy to reuse [4].

## A binary ruling lands inside four weeks

Mathew's number, due by late October, is a binary on a stock at $725.93 [3][5]. Near the state's ask, the fine would swallow most of a half-year's earnings; near Meta's cap, it would not reach a fifth of a single quarter's [7].

Either way Meta appeals, and McGinn herself puts collection years out [3]. The appeal, not the check, is the second entry; the copycat filings, if they come, are the tail [4].

## Takeaway

Judge Francis Mathew sets Meta's New Mexico privacy penalty by late October, from a proposed $345 million cap to the state's $40 billion ask; the top number nearly matches the $42.6 billion Meta earned in the first half of 2026, and an appeal is near certain either way.

## Sources

1. [Reuters, "New Mexico wants Meta to pay up to $40 billion in penalties after data privacy trial", 1 October 2026](https://www.reuters.com/world/us/new-mexico-wants-meta-pay-up-40-billion-penalties-after-data-privacy-trial-2026-10-01/)
2. [Yahoo Finance, "Meta stock rises 27% in September, best month since 2022", 1 October 2026](https://finance.yahoo.com/markets/stocks/articles/meta-stock-rises-27-september-115455631.html)
3. [Albuquerque Journal via Yahoo News, "New Mexico seeks a judgment up to $40 billion from Meta", 1 October 2026](https://www.yahoo.com/news/us/articles/mexico-seeks-judgment-40-billion-030500085.html)
4. [Yahoo News, "New Mexico Jury Finds Facebook Liable for 43 Million Privacy Violations", 30 September 2026](https://www.yahoo.com/news/us/articles/mexico-jury-finds-facebook-liable-190640167.html)
5. [Benzinga via Yahoo Finance, "Meta Faces Up To $40 Billion Penalty In New Mexico Privacy Case After Jury Finds Company Misled Facebook Users 43 Million Times", 1 October 2026](https://finance.yahoo.com/markets/stocks/articles/meta-faces-40-billion-penalty-030056405.html)
6. [The Epoch Times, "New Mexico Asks Judge to Fine Meta up to $40 Billion in Facebook Privacy Case", 2 October 2026](https://www.theepochtimes.com/us/new-mexico-asks-judge-to-fine-meta-up-to-40-billion-in-facebook-privacy-case-6097710)
7. [Sharadar quarterly fundamentals, from Meta's SEC filings, retrieved 2 October 2026](https://www.sec.gov/cgi-bin/browse-edgar?action=getcompany&CIK=0001326801)


---

One judge now holds Meta's privacy bill, and the bids are $3.45 billion and $40 billion — The Inference. Canonical: https://theinference.org/article/one-judge-now-holds-meta-s-privacy-bill-and-the-bids-are-3-45-billion-and-40-billion
