---
title: "S&P gives Chicago one-in-two downgrade odds, backing the ex-CFO who counted 56%"
description: "Mayor Brandon Johnson says his 2027 budget is 76% structurally balanced because $480 million of borrowing for police-misconduct settlements counts as recurring money; the CFO who quit, a former Fitch analyst, put it at 56%. S&P's downgrade watch turns on exactly that number, and its 90-day window runs past the December 31 budget deadline."
publisher: "The Inference"
section: "Economy"
published: 2026-11-20T18:09:37.453Z
modified: 2026-11-20T18:09:37.453Z
canonical: https://theinference.org/article/s-p-gives-chicago-bonds-one-in-two-downgrade-odds-siding-with-the-ex-cfo-who-counted-the-budget-56-balanced
language: en
keywords: "Chicago, Credit Ratings, Municipal Bonds, Public Finance, S&P Global"
---

# S&P gives Chicago one-in-two downgrade odds, backing the ex-CFO who counted 56%

> Mayor Brandon Johnson says his 2027 budget is 76% structurally balanced because $480 million of borrowing for police-misconduct settlements counts as recurring money; the CFO who quit, a former Fitch analyst, put it at 56%. S&P's downgrade watch turns on exactly that number, and its 90-day window runs past the December 31 budget deadline.

S&P Global Ratings, one of the handful of agencies that set the city's borrowing costs, put Chicago on CreditWatch negative on Wednesday, November 18: at least a one-in-two chance of a downgrade inside 90 days, on a BBB rating that sits two notches above junk [1]. The watch covers $9.86 billion of property-tax-backed bonds, and the city's sales-tax-backed debt went on with it [2]. What alarmed the agency was not a payment Chicago missed. It is a number the city cannot agree on.

## The fight is over whether borrowing is revenue

Mayor Brandon Johnson's 2027 budget closes an $882 million gap and, on his telling, is 76% structural, meaning funded by money that recurs year after year [3]. Ashlee Gabrysch, the third chief financial officer to leave City Hall this year and a former senior director at Fitch Ratings, counted 56%, because $480 million of the gap is closed with bonds issued to pay police-misconduct settlements [4][5].

She quit on November 13, writing that [the CFO's statements "must be complete and accurate"](https://finance.yahoo.com/economy/policy/articles/chicagos-cfo-resigns-just-3-154500003.html) and that she could not meet that duty "under the conditions in which I have been asked to serve" [4]. Borrowing for settlements, she wrote, "kicks it into the future, with interest": about $190 million of it on the 2027 bonds, "money that won't go to a single library or clinic" [4].

## The ratings agency has already picked a side

Acting CFO Michael Belsky defends the mayor's arithmetic: "you can issue bonds every year at any time to meet an obligation like settlements... you can say that's a structural match" [5]. [S&P's research update](https://chicago.suntimes.com/news/2026/11/18/first-wall-street-fallout-from-cfo-resignation-s-p-places-chicago-on-creditwatch) rejects that construction by name, listing "bonding for legal settlements" among the city's nonstructural expedients and concluding that most measures closing the gap are "either non-structural or contested" by the council [1][2]. The definitional fight is the ratings fight. Alderman Andre Vasquez put it in a holder's terms: "Taking out a credit card to pay for something isn't revenue. It is financing" [3].

## December 31 is the date everything lands

The watch window runs past the December 31 statutory deadline for passing a budget, leaving roughly six weeks of negotiation [1][3]. A council majority has already rejected more than $400 million of the mayor's revenue, led by a hike of the lease tax, which covers cloud software, to 20% [1][2].

That matters beyond Illinois: a big city trying to fund itself off a tax on cloud computing, the substrate every AI service runs on, is a template other treasurers will copy if it survives. Belsky's escape hatch is his own: promptly pass a balanced budget built on structural revenues, and the watch resolves [6].

*Chart: **The biggest rejected revenue item is Chicago's cloud-software lease tax** Bar chart of the three largest revenue items in Mayor Johnson's 2027 budget proposal that a City Council majority rejected: the lease tax covering cloud software at $234 million, the corporate head tax at $100 million, and the parking-meter upfront payment at $75 million.*

*Proposed fiscal 2027 revenue items rejected by a City Council majority, in millions of dollars. Sources: Chicago Sun-Times, WTTW News. [1][2]*

## The probe will outlast the notch

The same day S&P acted, the council voted 45 to 5 for an outside firm to test whether "material or intentional misstatements" about city finances reached investors, council members or the public [3]. This is not an audit: aldermen want [the emails, memos and draft PowerPoints behind the city's numbers](https://www.nbcchicago.com/news/local/questions-over-accuracy-and-honesty-of-chicago-finances-after-abrupt-exit-of-cfo-prompt-investigation/4018626/) [3]. A disclosure problem outlasts any one-notch cut, and a three-year document review on a year-end clock is work at the scale and speed AI tooling now handles; whichever firm Finance Committee chair Pat Dowell hires has no excuse to be slow [3].

Chicago does not have an arithmetic problem. It has an agreement problem, and bondholders pay for the difference. The watch ends when the city passes a budget a credit analyst would sign, and until then Chicago's paper is a coin flip the city is flipping itself.

## Takeaway

Chicago's budget fight is now a credit question: the mayor counts $480 million of borrowing for police-misconduct settlements as recurring revenue, his former CFO counts 56% structural rather than 76%, and S&P's 90-day watch runs past the December 31 deadline.

## Sources

1. [Chicago Sun-Times, "First Wall Street fallout from CFO resignation: S&P places Chicago on CreditWatch", 18 November 2026](https://chicago.suntimes.com/news/2026/11/18/first-wall-street-fallout-from-cfo-resignation-s-p-places-chicago-on-creditwatch)
2. [WTTW News, "Wall Street Ratings Agency Sounds Alarm About Chicago's Finances Amid Budget Stalemate", 18 November 2026](https://news.wttw.com/2026/11/18/wall-street-ratings-agency-sounds-alarm-about-chicago-s-finances-amid-budget-stalemate)
3. [NBC Chicago, "'Accuracy and honesty' of Chicago finances probed by investigation after abrupt exit of CFO", 18 November 2026](https://www.nbcchicago.com/news/local/questions-over-accuracy-and-honesty-of-chicago-finances-after-abrupt-exit-of-cfo-prompt-investigation/4018626/)
4. [Yahoo Finance (Moneywise), "Chicago's CFO resigns after just 3 months, accusing Mayor's office of misrepresenting an $882M budget shortfall", 17 November 2026](https://finance.yahoo.com/economy/policy/articles/chicagos-cfo-resigns-just-3-154500003.html)
5. [Chicago Sun-Times, "Mayor Johnson says Ashlee Gabrysch, his third CFO in the last year, 'wasn't a good fit'", 17 November 2026](https://chicago.suntimes.com/city-hall/2026/11/17/mayor-brandon-johnson-former-cfo-ashlee-gabrysch)
6. [FOX 32 Chicago, "Chicago faces possible credit downgrade amid budget turmoil", 18 November 2026](https://www.fox32chicago.com/news/chicago-faces-possible-credit-downgrade-amid-budget-turmoil)


---

S&P gives Chicago one-in-two downgrade odds, backing the ex-CFO who counted 56% — The Inference. Canonical: https://theinference.org/article/s-p-gives-chicago-bonds-one-in-two-downgrade-odds-siding-with-the-ex-cfo-who-counted-the-budget-56-balanced
