Adobe will let rival AI agents into Photoshop only on terms that keep Adobe paid

Adobe will host outside agents inside its apps while rival usage is billed on someone else's account, and its own research says 58% of the companies it talks to are stuck in an AI pilot or unable to deploy at scale. The December 9 report, the first under new CEO Anil Chakravarthy, tests which of the two explanations for Adobe's falling net-new ARR holds.

Vincent JiangVincent Jiangthree-minute read
Share
Shantanu Narayen, Adobe's chief executive, on stage in a grey sweater in front of an orange Adobe backdrop, gesturing mid-speech
1 / 6Slide 1 of 6
Shantanu Narayen, Adobe's chief executive until December 1, delivers the opening keynote at Adobe MAX 2026, where the company opened Photoshop, Illustrator, Premiere and After Effects project files to outside AI agents.

Adobe's+1.56% — Adobe, up 1.56 percent today chief technology officer put a commercial limit on the company's own openness this week. The company will let outside AI agents work in Photoshop, Premiere, Illustrator and After Effects, but only on terms that keep Adobe paid. "For us to put our content there, like, it has to be something that we can actually still, you know, put food on the table with," Ely Greenfield, Adobe's CTO for Digital Media, told Digital Trends at the MAX conference 1.

Investors get the first answer on December 9, when Adobe reports fiscal fourth-quarter results under incoming chief executive Anil Chakravarthy, who takes over from Shantanu Narayen on December 1, with Citi−2.66% — Citi, down 2.66 percent as of its last quote already at Sell and a $207 price target against a $266.91 analyst consensus 5.

Adobe's revenue is up 25% in two years; operating profit is up 18%

  • Revenue
  • Operating income
$0B$2B$4B$6B$8BQ3 '24Q1 '25Q3 '25Q1 '26Q3 '26Operating margin peaks at 37.8%
Data
RevenueOperating income
Q2 '24$5.31B$1.89B
Q3 '24$5.41B$1.99B
Q4 '24$5.61B$1.96B
Q1 '25$5.71B$2.16B
Q2 '25$5.87B$2.11B
Q3 '25$5.99B$2.17B
Q4 '25$6.19B$2.26B
Q1 '26$6.4B$2.42B
Q2 '26$6.62B$2.24B
Q3 '26$6.76B$2.35B
Adobe quarterly revenue and operating income, fiscal Q2 2024 through Q3 2026, in US dollars billions. Operating margin peaked at 37.8% in Q1 2026 and was 34.8% in Q3 2026, the quarter that carried the 38% net-new ARR decline. Source: Adobe, quarterly figures from its SEC filings, retrieved 16 November 2026 [8].8

Adobe hosts rival agents, and the rivals bill the user

The protocol Adobe is opening, the Model Context Protocol, lets agents from OpenAI$1.18T — OpenAI, private, latest valuation $1.18T, Google and Anthropic$350B — Anthropic, private, latest valuation $350B edit native project files on the user's own computer; local MCP integrations are due in private beta in early 2027 6. Adobe has not said how much of its tools those agents will reach. It says what an agent can do depends on what an integration exposes and what the user authorizes 1.

Rivals have not waited. fal~$1B — fal, private, latest valuation ~$1B, a generative-media platform, shipped a free Photoshop plugin on November 10 whose model runs bill to the user's fal account on plans of $50, $200 and $1,000 a month, sitting in the same panel where Adobe's own Creative Agent is still in beta 4. Acrobat's $24.99-a-month AI Assistant already has a free local-model substitute documented in an open-source reader 3. Adobe keeps the subscription; the usage meter can belong to someone else.

Adobe's own data says the buyers cannot deploy

Sam Garfield, Adobe's head of digital strategy, said on November 15 that 58% of the companies Adobe talks to sit in what Adobe calls the frozen middle, stuck in an AI pilot or unable to deploy at scale 2. A Winterberry Group study he cited found only 6% of companies use creative-effectiveness data at every point in the process 2.

That number reframes the reset: net-new ARR, the new subscription sales added in a period, fell 37% to 38% last quarter 7, and Citi analyst Tyler Radke warned Adobe's user-growth push will pressure recurring revenue through fiscal 2027 and 2028 5. If most customers cannot deploy AI, the shortfall is a deployment problem, not only a competition problem, and no agent door fixes it.

Adobe's AI ARR grows 150% but net-new ARR fell 38%

  • Estimate
-50%0%50%100%150%AI-first ARR growth (floor)150%GenStudio ARR growth (floor)20%Net-new ARR change-38%
Data
Value
AI-first ARR growth (floor) (estimate)150%
GenStudio ARR growth (floor) (estimate)20%
Net-new ARR change-38%
Year-over-year change in each Adobe ARR line, fiscal Q3 2026 ended August 28, 2026, as reported; the AI-first and GenStudio bars are floors, reported as 'more than' figures. Sources: TheStreet via Yahoo Finance [5]; The Inference [7].7,5

What December 9 decides

The bear case is Citi's: agents commoditise the click, seat prices stop rising, and Adobe becomes plumbing 5. The bull case is Greenfield's own: value moves to context, files and creative judgment, the parts general agents lack 1. The print on December 9, days into Chakravarthy's tenure 5, shows which one owns the customer. Watch net-new ARR, not the partnership headlines.

Deep dive into the numbers below before the market does.

Get Applications by email, free

How AI is changing the software people and companies use. In our daily email, every weekday.

Loading ADBE

Reader comments

0 comments

    Subscribe to TheInference for free