Security

CISA sat four years on a report warning US telecom networks were open to spies

Our call: the disclosure repriced nothing; the trade, if there is one, starts on January 3, 2027, when a Democratic Congress and a live FCC docket can turn this report into mandatory security standards for US phone companies.

Vincent JiangVincent Jiangfour-minute read
Share
Senator Ron Wyden of Oregon in a blue suit and light blue tie, photographed outdoors
Senator Ron Wyden of Oregon, briefed on the 2023 intrusions, calls CISA's stonewalling "totally inexcusable".

The disclosure repriced nothing

US stocks: no change, medium confidence. The S&P 500 (SPY) trades at 716.82, down 1.83% on the day and 4.73% through Wednesday's close 1; the AI 100 fell 9.34% over that stretch 2. A four-year-old report on SS7, the switchboard protocol first developed in the 1970s 4, repriced nothing.

Macro: no change, high confidence. Nothing here touches rates, growth or oil. The 10-year Treasury yield sits at 5.05%, down about two basis points on the day 3.

AI: no change, medium confidence. The money route runs through telecom security budgets, not the AI trade. Direction is clear: carriers pay, security vendors collect. Timing is the open variable.

A 2022 report found the networks wide open

Bloomberg News disclosed on Thursday a June 2022 report that the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA) commissioned and then buried 4. The 111-page assessment, by Enea's AdaptiveMobile Security unit and Telecom Defense, found "major structural vulnerabilities" in US telecom networks and described a "perilous and untenable situation" 4.

The review drew on up to 50 billion daily telecom events 4. It ranked the US the world's most targeted country for exploits of SS7, the protocol that routes calls and texts between networks, and counted 9,000 suspicious incidents across US phone networks in one week of May 2022 4. The Electronic Privacy Information Center (EPIC), a Washington privacy group, won a redacted copy after a two-year records fight 5.

The agency buried its own warning

CISA fought the release in court as exempt and said it never acted on the recommendations, calling them unverifiable 45. Kevin Briggs, CISA's former senior telecom-security adviser, says superiors blocked publication to protect the agency's industry relationships; he was laid off amid the Department of Government Efficiency cuts 4.

Two years after the report, Salt Typhoon, a suspected Chinese espionage group, breached at least nine providers including Verizon−1.13% — Verizon, down 1.13 percent as of its last quote, AT&T−0.46% — AT&T, down 0.46 percent as of its last quote, T-Mobile and Lumen, stole audio intercepts and call-record data, and targeted the phones of top politicians, then-candidate Donald Trump among them 46. Senator Ron Wyden of Oregon, briefed in 2023, calls the stonewalling "totally inexcusable" 4.

Carriers say SS7 is not in the 4G and 5G they run

CTIA, the carriers' trade group, says SS7 "is not used in the 4G or 5G networks that Americans rely on daily" 4. EPIC's answer: the protocol lives on in legacy networks and international roaming, interconnected with Diameter, the successor protocol behind 4G and 5G 5.

The disclosure lands days after the November 12-17 outage wave, which included a Federal Aviation Administration nationwide ground stop traced to telecom network instability; the FAA, Microsoft−1.72% — Microsoft, down 1.72 percent today, JPMorgan and United Airlines−1.79% — United Airlines, down 1.79 percent today each said they found no sign of an attack 7. It lands two weeks after an election gave Democrats the House and a 56-44 Senate edge 89.

The market knew all this in 2024

The market learned most of this in 2024, when Salt Typhoon became public 46; a redacted history lesson adds no cash flow to any ticker. The tape agrees: through Wednesday's close SPY is down 4.73%, the AI 100 down 9.34%, and the AI 100 fell another 2.12% on Thursday, a slide that began before this week 12. The VIX closed Wednesday at 24.56, set by the outage week 10.

The AI 100's slide began before this week's news

Down 9.34% from October 19 through November 18; SPY fell 4.73% over the same window

3,2003,4003,6003,80010/2010/2310/2811/0211/0511/1011/1311/183,342.3Outage week: FAA ground stop,cloud failures
Data
US AI 100
10/193,686.83
10/203,669.95
10/213,720.31
10/223,582.95
10/233,584.75
10/263,614.37
10/273,668.26
10/283,681.42
10/293,609.65
10/303,481.65
11/023,437
11/033,486.09
11/043,499.17
11/053,282.38
11/063,338.54
11/093,444.08
11/103,413.45
11/113,479.18
11/123,474.81
11/133,428.51
11/163,334.1
11/173,322.83
11/183,342.3
US AI 100 index, daily closes, October 19 to November 18, 2026. Source: The Inference.2

Rates transmit nothing: the 10-year yield at 5.05% barely moved on the day 3.

The mandate route runs through Washington

The AI call rests on Washington arithmetic. Democrats take both chambers on January 3, 2027 9, with Wyden pressing for mandatory cybersecurity standards for phone companies 4. They hold 56 Senate seats, four short of the 60 needed to break a filibuster 9. The Federal Communications Commission needs no Congress: its SS7 proceeding, which took Briggs' warning in May 2024, is the faster route 4.

Stockholm-based Enea sells signaling firewalls spanning 2G to 5G to more than 300 operators in over 100 countries 11. EPIC notes reports tying SS7 location pings to tracking US military personnel before the Iran war 5.

CompanyTickerBetter or worseWhy
VerizonVZWorseNamed Salt Typhoon victim; a mandate puts legacy interconnect fixes on its capex 46
AT&TTWorseBreached in the 2024 Salt Typhoon campaign 6
T-Mobile USTMUSWorseNamed among the nine breached carriers 6
LumenLUMNWorseNamed victim; the same mandated fix lands on its capex 4
EneaENEA:STOBetterIts AdaptiveMobile unit wrote the report and sells the firewalls a mandate would require 411
Who pays and who collects if SS7 fixes become mandatory. Sources: Bloomberg [4], Reuters [6], Enea [11].

Capex is a small, falling slice of Verizon's cash flow

  • Operating cash flow
  • Capital spending
$0B$5B$10B$15BQ4 '24Q1 '25Q2 '25Q3 '25Q4 '25Q1 '26Q2 '26Q3 '26
Data
Operating cash flowCapital spending
Q4 '24$10.43B$5.07B
Q1 '25$7.78B$4.15B
Q2 '25$8.98B$3.81B
Q3 '25$11.27B$4.31B
Q4 '25$9.11B$4.75B
Q1 '26$7.98B$4.2B
Q2 '26$10.44B$4.01B
Q3 '26$11.52B$3.72B
Verizon, capital spending and operating cash flow, quarterly, Q4 2024 to Q3 2026, $ billions. Source: Verizon quarterly figures from its SEC filings [12].12

Three ways this call dies before 2028

Spring 2027 arrives with no telecom-security bill introduced, no hearing scheduled and the FCC's docket left to lapse; the mandate trade and the vendor upside die with it.

Carriers or regulators publish audits showing SS7 sealed off from 4G and 5G interconnects; CTIA's position then holds and the compliance case collapses 4.

Investigators attribute Salt Typhoon's entry to something other than signaling flaws; the report then reads as history, not a to-do list.

January 3 is the date that matters

January 3, 2027, when the new Congress is sworn in 9: committee assignments and any Wyden bill set the mandate's odds. The FCC's SS7 proceeding, where an order or a fine needs no Senate votes 4. January's carrier earnings calls, where capex guidance shows whether the fix has a line item.

Get Security by email, free

The breaches, flaws and security vendors AI is putting to the test. In our daily email, every weekday.

Loading VZ

Reader comments

0 comments

    More in Security

    All in this topic →

    Security

    San Diego switches off 500 Flock cameras, the largest exit yet, as cities replace them with Axon

    The largest city to quit Flock Safety's license plate readers went dark this week, and Santa Ana followed a night later. The spend survives the votes: switchers are re-leasing the same job from listed rival Axon at equal or higher rates, while one university signed fresh Flock paper and one city moved to renew.

    Security

    Rubrik jumped 9.3% for two products it cannot sell yet

    Neither Ignite release carries a price or a general-availability date, so neither can add a dollar to subscription ARR before the November 30 report. What the market moved 9.3% on was a bet on guidance, not on products.

    Security

    Fireworks AI pauses its Batch API as Uber notifies 149,346 people

    The November 17 bulletin splits October into two intrusion chains, one dating to August, and retires the product line built on storing customer data. Investors marking inference providers up on this week's praise for Fireworks' response are pricing the wrong document.

    Security

    Twenty-nine analysts cut SentinelOne's quarterly EPS estimate; none raised

    A one-day cybersecurity rally on Palo Alto Networks' results lifted SentinelOne 10.35% to $23.34, taking the stock from 46 to roughly 51 times next year's earnings estimate two weeks before the December 3 report. The price move came from Palo Alto's quarter, not from anything SentinelOne has reported since August.

    Security

    SailPoint hit a 52-week high above its $21.96 average analyst target on less than half its usual volume

    The gain was a sector bid on outage fears, not a SailPoint event, and it left the identity-software maker trading above the average analyst target three weeks before a December 8 report. Each of its three 2026 report days has closed lower.

    Security

    F5 patches five critical NGINX flaws as exploit code goes public; 8.8 million services exposed

    Five NGINX2Root flaws allow unauthenticated remote code execution on about 8.8 million internet-exposed services, disclosed one day after F5's 10-K priced its own nation-state breach at $28 million, $18 million after insurance. The count and the bill were never in the same document, and FFIV holders own both.

    Subscribe to TheInference for free