Model

Reddit's User Agreement can bind Anthropic, a judge rules, and the meter is running

A San Francisco judge rejected Anthropic's "browsewrap" defense and let three of Reddit's five claims proceed, opening the question of what Claude's training corpus is worth to the lab that allegedly took it without paying.

Vincent JiangVincent Jiangthree-minute read
Share
Steve Huffman, chief executive of Reddit, speaking on stage at Web Summit 2017
1 / 6Slide 1 of 6
Reddit chief executive Steve Huffman. The suit says Anthropic kept scraping more than 100,000 times after Huffman publicly called out the practice.

Three claims survive, and they are the expensive ones

Judge Harold Kahn of the San Francisco County Superior Court has overruled Anthropic's demurrer and sent three of Reddit's−3.87% — Reddit, down 3.87 percent today five claims toward trial: breach of contract, interference with contract, and unfair competition under California law 1. The order is dated 17 September and was filed the next day 1. A demurrer decides no liability, only whether allegations state valid claims; Kahn held that three of Reddit's do 13.

The two claims trimmed as too vague, unjust enrichment and trespass to chattels, can be refiled by 16 October 1. Reddit sued in June 2025, saying Anthropic$350B — Anthropic, private, latest valuation $350B trained Claude on its users' comments without a license 1.

The defense was that nobody clicked agree

Anthropic's bet was that Reddit's User Agreement is "browsewrap," a page no one affirmatively accepts and so binds no one 1. Kahn rejected it, finding Anthropic's "conduct sufficient to infer actual knowledge of the terms of the User Agreement and to form an implied-in-fact contract with Reddit" 2. The alleged conduct is blunt: more than 100,000 scrapes after Reddit's chief executive publicly called out the practice 1.

Anthropic also framed the claims as copyright in disguise, which would have opened the fair-use door; the judge held each surviving claim needs an extra element beyond unauthorized copying 23. Even Claude's admission that it could not say whether scraped user data had been deleted counted toward the interference claim 3.

Terms of service, now with teeth

The reach runs past Reddit. Terms of service can hand any website operator a contract claim beyond copyright, which is the part every content holder with anti-scraping rules is watching 3.

The free-data era did not end with a copyright verdict. It ended with a terms-of-service page being treated like a lease.

The price list already exists

Reddit sells what Anthropic allegedly took. Google's 2024 license is worth about $60 million a year 46, OpenAI$1.18T — OpenAI, private, latest valuation $1.18T has its own 56, and together the deals run to roughly a tenth of Reddit's revenue, expiring in 2027 6. Both are up for renewal while Steve Huffman says he is "still looking for that win-win" 5, and the bull case sees hundreds of millions in new profit from renegotiation 2.

Reddit negotiates from strength: at least 61 percent revenue growth year over year in each of the past eight quarters, profitable in all of them 7. RDDT rose 4.5 percent to $157.64 on the first trading day after the order, a rare lift for a stock down 30 percent this year 2.

Reddit enters the licensing fight profitable, revenue up 131% across eight quarters

  • Revenue
  • Net income
$0M$200M$400M$600M$800M$1,000MQ3 2024Q4 2024Q1 2025Q2 2025Q3 2025Q4 2025Q1 2026Q2 2026renewal talks plus a court case
Data
RevenueNet income
Q3 2024$348.35M$29.85M
Q4 2024$427.71M$71.04M
Q1 2025$392.36M$26.16M
Q2 2025$499.63M$89.3M
Q3 2025$584.91M$162.66M
Q4 2025$725.61M$251.6M
Q1 2026$663.41M$203.98M
Q2 2026$804.91M$252.85M
Quarterly revenue and net income, USD millions, Q3 2024 through Q2 2026, from Reddit's SEC filings via Sharadar fundamentals.7

The bill lands on a $2 trillion ledger

Whatever the taking gets priced at, the bearer is about to go public. Anthropic's prospectus shows a $42 billion net loss for 2025, revenue up twelvefold to nearly $4.6 billion, and $518 billion in planned cloud and infrastructure spending, in a sale that could value it above $2 trillion and raise as much as $100 billion 89. The Reddit claim sits in that stack beside the Pentagon's temporary blacklist, blocked by a US judge in August 8.

Anthropic plans $518B of cloud and infrastructure spending on $4.6B of 2025 revenue

  • USD billions
  • Estimate
-$200B$0B$200B$400B$600B2025 revenue2025 net lossPlanned infra spending-$42B
Data
USD billions
2025 revenue$4.6B
2025 net loss-$42B
Planned infra spending (estimate)$518B
Anthropic IPO prospectus figures, USD billions: about $4.6 billion of 2025 revenue, a $42 billion 2025 net loss, and $518 billion of planned cloud and infrastructure spending. Sources: CNBC (Reuters); Forbes.8,9

The template for settling is already signed

Anthropic said in June 2025 it disagreed with the claims and would "defend ourselves vigorously" 2. The likely exit is still the Google template: a retroactive payment for what Claude already learned, then a license. That is a prediction, not a holding: the lawyer Kirk Sigmon expects exactly that settlement, with the rivals already paying as the pricing evidence 2.

The next dated marker is 16 October, when Reddit refiles its trimmed claims 1. Discovery is where a decade of free data learns its price.

Get Model by email, free

The AI labs, their models, and the business behind them. In our daily email, every weekday.

Loading RDDT

Reader comments

0 comments

    Model

    Respan served OpenAI's GPT-6.2 Sol at $0 for 24 hours

    The plumbing for the giveaway was finished two weeks before OpenAI shipped the model. The money at risk is a $5 million seed betting free tokens turn into paid observability accounts.

    Model

    Google opens Gemini 4 Neon to all developers at $3 per million input tokens

    Google's fourth Gemini 4 model in five weeks pairs top-three benchmark scores with mid-tier pricing, resetting the margin math for AI software vendors in the very week Anthropic's record IPO slid back toward its $83 offer price.

    Model

    House report says the model behind SpaceX's $60 billion Cursor deal was built on China's Kimi K2.5

    SpaceX paid about $60 billion in stock for Cursor in August, and a House report now says its flagship model rests on Chinese open weights. The same day, rival Cognition entered talks at $75 billion, two months after Cursor's own backers led its $48 billion round.

    Model

    Mira Murati's Thinking Machines ships a 26-billion-parameter model that runs offline on a MacBook

    The 26-billion-parameter open-weights agent shipped hours after OpenAI said attackers had extracted GPT-6 Astra's hidden reasoning at a 54% success rate and asked Congress for new enforcement powers. Together the two moves frame the scarcity bet behind frontier token prices and the market's newest trillion-dollar listing.

    Model

    OpenAI says attackers copied GPT-6 Astra's hidden reasoning on 54% of tries; its fix cuts that to 0.2%

    OpenAI's November 20 disclosure puts a hard number on how copyable a frontier model was, and pairs the fix with a call for federal enforcement. The labs it names, Moonshot AI and DeepSeek among them, are where the money moves.

    Model

    Amazon's $188 Billion Anthropic Stake Swings $1.9 Billion for Every $1 of Anthropic Stock

    Two trading days turned Amazon's largest AI holding into a daily mark-to-market item, and Anthropic's second-session slide shows how fast the gain Amazon already booked can reverse.

    Subscribe to TheInference for free