Toast's FTC suit gets a viral face: one operator's rant draws 16,000 reactions after moving to Revel

A viral operator exit gives the FTC's hidden-fees suit a customer face, and rival POS firms are courting the defector. The complaint targets the contract lock-in behind the payments and loans that made up 82% of Toast's 2025 revenue, which is what investors own.

Vincent JiangVincent Jiangthree-minute read
Share
Aman Narang, Toast's co-founder and chief executive, standing at a restaurant counter with a colleague
Aman Narang, right, Toast's co-founder and chief executive, in a restaurant that runs on the company's point-of-sale system. Toast says it will "vigorously defend" the FTC's suit.

A dog walk, a phone, 16,000 reactions

Kyle Markt co-founded Green Tomato Grill in Orange, California, in 2014 and ran it on Toast−6.91% — Toast, down 6.91 percent today point-of-sale terminals from opening day 12. This month, on a cold morning dog walk, he hit record and vented about the vendor and its federal lawsuit, unscripted, in about three minutes 12.

The video has drawn close to 16,000 reactions, 652 comments and nearly 9,000 shares on his @culinarystrategist handle, with operators piling into the comments over support lines and surprise charges 12. Rivals noticed: Markt says he has received direct messages from "every POS company on the planet," including one offering its software and hardware free and charging only for card processing 12.

The complaint, lived first

Markt decided to leave in 2023, when a 99-cent per-transaction fee appeared that he could not negotiate away 12. His contract ran 10 years, and cancellation meant dead-end phone numbers, rude service and separate Google-form contracts for each of his three restaurants 12. All three have since moved to rival Revel, with support waits under five minutes 12.

The Green Tomato Grill restaurant on Tustin Street in Orange, California, with its pink awning and patio tables
A Green Tomato Grill location on Tustin Street in Orange, California, the city where Kyle Markt co-founded the chain in 2014. All three of his restaurants have since moved off Toast to rival Revel.Greentomatogrill, via Wikimedia Commons

On October 29, the FTC and eight states sued Toast, in the Northern District of California: seven state attorneys general, plus the Los Angeles County Counsel and San Francisco's city attorney for California 45. The complaint describes subscriptions averaging about $900 a month, payroll and timekeeping add-ons charged without consent, and a $150-per-month termination fee buried mid-way in a 25-page merchant agreement 345. One operator was charged $5,318.87 for leaving after four years 34.

The locked base is the business model

Toast's 2025 revenue was $6.15 billion, about 82% of it from payments and loans, according to the complaint 4. The same locked-in base the FTC calls a trap is what produces that revenue: restaurants under multi-year contracts are billed every month for software, card processing and loans 45.

Toast puts that base at nearly 200,000 locations 6; the third-quarter count was about 189,000 after 8,500 net additions 7. The quarter kept compounding, with revenue of $1.98 billion, up 21.3%, and $169 million of net income 89.

Toast's quarterly revenue nearly doubled while a $36M loss became $169M of profit

  • Revenue
  • Net income
-$1B$0B$1B$2BQ1 '24Q3 '24Q1 '25Q3 '25Q1 '26Q3 '26$1.98BFTC suit filed weeks after quarterclose
Data
RevenueNet income
Q4 '23$1.04B-$0.04B
Q1 '24$1.08B-$0.08B
Q2 '24$1.24B$0.01B
Q3 '24$1.31B$0.06B
Q4 '24$1.34B$0.03B
Q1 '25$1.34B$0.06B
Q2 '25$1.55B$0.08B
Q3 '25$1.63B$0.11B
Q4 '25$1.63B$0.1B
Q1 '26$1.63B$0.13B
Q2 '26$1.91B$0.15B
Q3 '26$1.98B$0.17B
Quarterly GAAP revenue and net income from Toast's SEC filings, Q4 2023 through Q3 2026, in billions of US dollars.9

Toast's defense is the growth itself

Toast says it will "vigorously defend" itself, arguing that no court has applied ROSCA, a consumer online-subscription statute, to negotiated business-to-business contracts, and that it cooperated with the FTC's review from mid-2025 6. The complaint leans on Toast's own internal surveys, chats and complaint logs 5.

Chief executive Aman Narang told analysts "we are all in customer success" and said Toast keeps taking share 7. Investors were less convinced: the stock fell 6% to $31.85 after the November 3 report, a $19.32 billion market cap 8. The Inference traced the add-on price hikes behind that growth on November 12 8.

What the courtroom cannot fix

If the case, or the churn a viral rant now publicizes, shortens contracts or simplifies exits, retention moves from contract law to service quality, and 82% of revenue rides on the base staying put 4. That has not happened yet. Watch net location additions, 8,500 last quarter 7, and the docket in FTC v. Toast, No. 3:26-cv-12705 5. Markt's standard is the bear case in one breath: "I will earn your business for one more month" 12.

Get Applications by email, free

How AI is changing the software people and companies use. In our daily email, every weekday.

Loading TOST

Reader comments

0 comments

    More in Applications

    All in this topic →

    Applications

    HighSage, tied to ZoomInfo's board, bought 2.6 million shares, taking the group past the founders' block

    A filing on November 18, 2026, shows HighSage Ventures and Jennifer Stier paid $3.39 to $3.46 for stock now quoting at $2.95. Their 40.1 million shares, tied to a ZoomInfo director, outweigh the founders' block at a company that has proposed a $44 million settlement of its securities suit.

    Applications

    Pegasystems CFO put its AI push and a sales reset on the record days after selling $1.42 million of stock

    Ken Stillwell presented at RBC Capital Markets' technology conference on November 18, a day after Pega closed at $30.63 on no company news and three days after he sold $1.42 million of stock. The growth he pitched runs through a free AI builder and a $419 million Army ceiling, and neither is revenue yet.

    Applications

    Roblox logs its first seven-figure game ad revenue in Steal an Egg as bookings fall 12%

    The number is a rounding error against a bookings line that fell 12% in Q3, and it was earned in front of the audience nearly 180 families are suing Roblox over. The dates that can move the stock are a mid-December court response in Arizona and a January arbitration hearing in San Francisco.

    Applications

    OpenAI puts QuickBooks inside ChatGPT one day before Intuit reports; Mailchimp is guided flat to down

    Intuit reports fiscal Q1 after the US close tonight, with revenue guided to $4.294 billion to $4.313 billion and an EPS line that will read like a collapse but is an accounting change. The stock's verdict rides on Mailchimp, the only segment guided to shrink.

    Applications

    Workday says 6,000 customers run its agents, 850 pay; Nov. 24 shows if $600 million of AI revenue is bundled

    Thousands of customers run the agents; a few hundred pay for them. The November 24 earnings report will show whether Workday's near-$600 million of AI revenue is bundled subscriptions or separately metered work.

    Applications

    Harvey hands law-firm installation to Consilio, which sells AI into the same budgets

    Consilio will implement Harvey for law firms, lend it staff and plug its own Aurora AI into Harvey's workflows, all while selling a legal-AI suite of its own. Harvey, valued at $15.5 billion, has reportedly held early IPO talks, and whoever buys that listing owns software whose adoption runs through a would-be rival.

    Subscribe to TheInference for free