Atreides and SCGE paid $423 million for Ciena shares now worth about a third less

Atreides Management and SCGE Management disclosed the stakes this week, set at Sept. 30 prices weeks before the post-election AI slide. Ciena's December 10 report is the first document that can say who was right.

Richard TangRichard Tangtwo-minute read
Share
Gary Smith, Ciena's president and chief executive, in a company headshot
Gary Smith, Ciena's president and chief executive. Smith and two other Ciena officers sold shares on November 16 under trading plans adopted between October 2025 and March.

Ciena−9.56% — Ciena, down 9.56 percent today closed at $234.37 on Friday, down almost 11% alongside Coherent−10.50% — Coherent, down 10.50 percent today and Arista in a broad AI-hardware slide 71. The stock has lost more than half its value in six months 1. And this week's filings showed two hedge funds paying quarter-end prices near $350 for $423 million of Ciena between them 23. None of those documents is news about the business. The one that could be is dated December 10 7.

The filings describe September: the argument is about December

Atreides Management, which runs $10.74 billion, added 51% to Ciena over the summer and ended September with a $365 million stake, its fifth-largest holding 2. SCGE Management, at $10.4 billion, added 85% 3. Their 13Fs, the quarterly disclosures funds file on US stocks, arrived November 13 and 16, describing positions set before the midterm election rearranged the AI trade 3.

The executives' sales say less still: chief executive Gary Smith, chief strategy officer David Rothenstein and finance chief Marc Graff sold 6,692 shares for $1.75 million on November 16, all under trading plans adopted between October 2025 and this past March 456. Plans written before the slide say nothing about December; they extend the selling we reported in October.

The fear sits one hop below Ciena

Ciena builds the optical systems that carry traffic between data centers, and AI demand shows in every number it files: record third-quarter revenue of $1.67 billion, up 37%; direct cloud-provider revenue up more than 80%; an $8.5 billion backlog with delivery dates into fiscal 2028 89. The selloff fears the hop underneath.

Ciena 6500 packet-optical shelves and Waveserver units cabled with fiber at an internet exchange
Ciena 6500 packet-optical shelves and Waveserver units carrying live traffic at the DATAIX internet exchange in 2021. Ciena sells the optical systems that move traffic between data centers.C0pMer

After the Democratic midterm sweep, the worry is that Congress slows data-center construction, and UBS puts nearly a third of new US capacity due in 2028 at risk of slipping 3. Late buildings mean late pipes. Nothing in Ciena's own numbers shows that yet: the company raised its full-year outlook with the same report 9.

Operating margin has climbed from 0.8% to 18% as the revenue ramped

  • Gross margin
  • Operating margin
-20%0%20%40%60%Q4 '23Q2 '24Q4 '24Q2 '25Q4 '25Q2 '2618%
Data
Gross marginOperating margin
Q3 '2343.1%8.1%
Q4 '2345%8.2%
Q1 '2442.7%-0.4%
Q2 '2442.9%2.8%
Q3 '2440.9%5.3%
Q4 '2444%7.5%
Q1 '2540.2%2.9%
Q2 '2541.3%6%
Q3 '2542.7%0.8%
Q4 '2543.8%13.3%
Q1 '2644%15.1%
Q2 '2645.4%18%
Gross margin and operating margin as a percent of revenue from Ciena's SEC filings: 12 quarters through the period ended August 1, 2026, labelled by calendar quarter and sourced from company filings.11

December 10 is the only witness

The fiscal fourth quarter lands before the open on December 10 7, guided to $1.75 billion of revenue, give or take $50 million 8, with backlog expected to pass $10 billion by year-end 9.

Ciena's revenue ramp now has to land a guided $1.75 billion on December 10

  • Quarterly revenue
  • Estimate
$0B$0.5B$1B$1.5B$2BQ4 '24Q1 '25Q2 '25Q3 '25Q4 '25Q1 '26Q2 '26Q3 '26$1.67BGuided; reports Dec 10
Data
Quarterly revenue
Q4 '24$1.07B
Q1 '25$1.13B
Q2 '25$1.22B
Q3 '25$1.35B
Q4 '25$1.43B
Q1 '26$1.57B
Q2 '26$1.67B
Q3 '26 (estimate)$1.75B ($1.7–1.8B)
Quarterly revenue from Ciena's SEC filings, 8 quarters through the period ended August 1, 2026, labelled by calendar quarter; the final bar is the guided fiscal fourth quarter ending October 31, 2026, midpoint $1.75 billion plus or minus $50 million, drawn as an estimate.10,9

The average analyst target still sits above $500 27. The market has cut the price by more than half while the outlook moved up, a bet on construction schedules against booked demand. On December 10 the order book testifies, and it is the only party to this argument that is not six weeks stale 27.

Get Data Center by email, free

Who is building AI's data centers, and who is paying for them. In our daily email, every weekday.

Loading CIEN

Reader comments

0 comments

    More in Data Center

    All in this topic →

    Data Center

    Everpure fell 13% after a 51% revenue quarter, trading below its insiders' $98.88 sale price

    Two sessions after a 51% revenue quarter and a third straight guidance raise, Everpure fell 13% on November 20 to near $92, under the $98.88 low of the November 10 insider sales and just above UBS's $89 Sell target. Twenty analysts average $149.53; that $58 gap is the disagreement investors are now pricing.

    Data Center

    Hut 8 fell 15% the day after Anthropic's $119.5 billion IPO; $10.7 billion of River Bend rent is unsigned

    Anthropic closed its second session at $88.30, near its $83 IPO price, and the listing pitched as fresh money for Hut 8's expansion gave back its debut gain within a day. Of River Bend's potential $17.7 billion in lease value, $10.7 billion is renewals that Google does not guarantee and Anthropic has not signed.

    Data Center

    Mutual funds hold Equinix 7 basis points light as Blackstone pays a 7% yield

    Large-cap mutual funds now hold Equinix seven basis points below its benchmark weight, three days after Blackstone's new trust paid a 7.0% cap rate for Amazon-leased data centers. Two prices for the same AI real estate, and the public REITs sit between them.

    Data Center

    Arizona's attorney general asks Cochise County to delay vote on SpaceX's $50 billion data center

    Kris Mayes wants the December 9 zoning vote held until state and federal reviews are done, three days after a Texas county rejected SpaceX's Starbase tax break. The spending those campuses must justify is already committed: $48.1 billion out the door and $44 billion of chip debt borrowed at up to 8.36%.

    Data Center

    Ulanqab's AI compute doubled in a year to 190,000 petaflops, official count shows

    The first official tally of China's fastest-growing AI hub lands days after Washington restricted remote access to US chips, one of two back doors behind nearly half the country's AI compute. Seven million contracted racks in one Inner Mongolia city now wait on a single bottleneck: Huawei's Ascend supply.

    Data Center

    SpaceX's 10-Q shows $48.1 billion of capex against $13.1 billion of cash before its December 8 lock-up

    SpaceX's Q3 10-Q puts the build at $48.1 billion of nine-month capex against $13.1 billion of operating cash, with the gap filled by $43 billion of chip-lease debt near 8.3%. That is the case against the equity 17 days before its lock-up expires, with Anthropic holding a 90-day exit.

    Subscribe to TheInference for free