Power

Five lawmakers ask FERC to kill the $33.4 billion AES buyout over its return math

Warren and four House members put the fight's number in front of FERC: buyers who underwrite at 15 to 20 percent agreed to take private a utility business that historically earns 10. The same public-interest test now sits in front of the $67 billion NextEra-Dominion merger.

Vincent JiangVincent Jiangthree-minute read
Share
Official portrait of Senator Elizabeth Warren smiling, wearing a blue jacket and glasses
1 / 7Slide 1 of 7
Senator Elizabeth Warren, lead signer of the letter asking FERC to reject the AES sale.

The letter hangs the case on a 10 point gap

Five members of Congress asked federal energy regulators on 28 September to reject the sale of AES+0.34% — AES, up 0.34 percent today, one of the largest power sector transactions in recent years 12. Senator Elizabeth Warren and Representatives André Carson, Victoria Spartz, Rashida Tlaib and Ayanna Pressley signed the letter to Federal Energy Regulatory Commission Chair Laura Swett 12. The buyers, BlackRock's−0.56% — BlackRock, down 0.56 percent today Global Infrastructure Partners, EQT−2.52% — EQT, down 2.52 percent today Infrastructure, CalPERS and the Qatar Investment Authority, agreed in March to $15 a share in cash, $10.7 billion of equity and about $33.4 billion including debt 3.

Their exhibit A is one number: Global Infrastructure Partners generally seeks internal returns of 15 to 20 percent, roughly double the 10 percent historical median earned by regulated utilities 14. A business built to earn 10 has been sold to owners who underwrite at 20. The letter asks FERC to say who pays the difference.

The letter's math: the buyers underwrite at 15 to 20 percent, utilities have earned 10

0%5%10%15%20%Regulated utility median10%GIP target, low end15%GIP target, high end20%
Data
Value
Regulated utility median10%
GIP target, low end15%
GIP target, high end20%
Internal rate of return targets for Global Infrastructure Partners versus the historical median return on equity earned by regulated utilities, percent. Figures as cited in the lawmakers' letter and reporting. Sources: Reuters; MarketScreener.1,4

The charge reaches past one deal

The lawmakers argue structure, not just yield. BlackRock owns grid infrastructure and data centers on both sides of the meter, they write, inviting cross-subsidization: network upgrades steered toward affiliated compute, with costs spread across everyone else 1. Their sharpest line is a failure case: "if a data center fails, customers may continue paying for the unnecessary upgrades via increased utility bills" 1. Data centers are pushing United States power demand to record highs, spurring a flurry of utility mergers, some taking public utilities private 1.

AES answers with the deal's structure

AES says no premium, transaction expense or other acquisition cost will reach customers of its Indiana and Ohio utilities, which stay state-regulated, and that the sale improves its access to capital 14. Shareholders endorsed the deal by nearly 98 percent, CFIUS has cleared it, and Ohio's utilities commission signed off on 17 September 35. As The Inference reported on 27 September, Ohio drew a line while Indiana kept billing.

The capital need is real either way: AES has spent more on plant and equipment than its operations generated in every quarter since late 2024 6. Consumer groups led by the Private Equity Stakeholder Project asked FERC in July, in docket EC26-99, to block the sale outright or force BlackRock to shed its utility holdings 5.

AES capex has outrun operating cash in all eight quarters since late 2024

  • Capex
  • Operating cash flow
$0.5B$1B$1.5B$2BQ3 '24Q4 '24Q1 '25Q2 '25Q3 '25Q4 '25Q1 '26Q2 '26$1.64BBuyout signed March 2026
Data
CapexOperating cash flow
Q3 '24$1.83B$0.99B
Q4 '24$1.73B$1.09B
Q1 '25$1.25B$0.55B
Q2 '25$1.33B$0.98B
Q3 '25$1.81B$1.3B
Q4 '25$1.54B$1.49B
Q1 '26$1.77B$1.2B
Q2 '26$1.64B$1.05B
Quarterly capital spending versus operating cash flow, USD billions, fiscal quarters ended September 2024 through June 2026. Sharadar quarterly fundamentals from AES's SEC filings, retrieved 1 October 2026.6

Two deals, one referee

The same week brought a second letter to the same commission. On 30 September, twelve Democrats led by Warren and Representative Suhas Subramanyam urged FERC to block the $67 billion NextEra-Dominion merger if it raises market concentration or consumer costs 7. The Connecticut and Massachusetts attorneys general are movants in that docket, which drew a FERC deficiency letter on 23 September 8. Five New England governors warned in August that one owner would hold plants generating nearly a quarter of the region's power 9.

How FERC prices a 20 percent buyer into a 10 percent business is likely to set the terms for every utility now chased by AI load, because its public-interest test is the one gate each of these deals must pass. The parties expect the AES sale to close in late 2026 or early 2027, pending FERC 13, which gives the gap between AES shares and the $15 offer its clock; docket EC26-99 is where to watch it run.

Get Power by email, free

How AI's hunger for electricity moves utilities, power plants and the grid. In our daily email, every weekday.

Loading AES

Reader comments

0 comments

    Power

    Global X funds now hold 5.08% of Oklo and 5.61% of NuScale, a bid that moves with ETF flows

    The Street's average Oklo target has collapsed from $117 to $56 while the ETF house behind the sector's theme funds quietly crossed the 5% line in both reactor names. The bid under this theme is turning mechanical, and the same channel can reverse it.

    Power

    PPL paid $9.9 million for a Lancaster farm to wire a data center; 1.5 million customers may share the bill

    A 143-acre Pequea Township purchase anchors 16.4 miles of new wires feeding the Lancaster AI Hub East project. Who pays for the shared parts, the data center's owners or the utility's 1.5 million customers, now sits with Pennsylvania regulators, and the governor has asked to join the case.

    Power

    North Carolina regulators approve Duke's $834 million rate rise and impose 15-year data-center terms

    The November 16 orders set Duke's North Carolina return at 9.8%, below the 10.1% Duke Energy Carolinas earned in its last case, and imposed 15-year minimum contracts and stranded-plant security on data centers above 100 MW. The question for DUK holders is whether a $103 billion AI-load buildout still compounds on the thinner return.

    Power

    Bloom Energy's newest billion-dollar NTT DATA and Google power deals ship nothing until 2027

    The stock trades at 39.2x forward earnings, above GE Vernova and Enphase, yet the NTT DATA 900 MW order and the AEP plant for Google ship nothing until 2027 and 2028 while Q3 cash flow ran negative. The de-rating is a bet on when signed megawatts become invoiced ones.

    Power

    Pinnacle West files 25-year deal making TSMC fund its own power ahead of a December rate decision

    The 25-year contract is the template for every data-center deal that follows it, and it lands before two Arizona regulators elected three days earlier on bill anger. Pinnacle West's growth story now rides on convincing them.

    Power

    Energy Department paid BWXT $68 million for uranium work as its first US new-build order slips to 2027

    The payment has sat unremarked in federal data for eleven days, and the one tracker that noticed coded the award to L3Harris. It is the funded half of BWXT's growth paying out in cash, while the commercial half, the AI-power half, waits on an order that slipped to 2027.

    Subscribe to TheInference for free