Lumentum's CEO admits the $115 billion Marvell deal 'hasn't worked as we expected'
Only a failed shareholder vote or a regulatory block can undo the $115 billion sale, Michael Hurlston says, and a ratio fixed at 4.5 Marvell shares has turned Marvell's 45% slide into Lumentum's problem.
Vincent Jiangtwo-minute read
Michael Hurlston, Lumentum's−11.64% — Lumentum, down 11.64 percent today chief executive since February 2025, said on November 19 what his shareholders have been saying with sell orders 1. "It's been a rough go," he told Semafor. "The deal hasn't worked as we expected, right?" 1 Hours later he told CNBC's Jim Cramer: "Shareholders are not happy ... It's been a tough couple of weeks." 2
Fixed at 4.5 shares, and hard to undo
Marvell−9.26% — Marvell, down 9.26 percent today agreed on November 2 to buy Lumentum, the maker of lasers and optical parts for AI data centers, for a fixed 4.5 Marvell shares per Lumentum share: about $115 billion including debt, closing expected in the first half of 2028, Marvell holders keeping about 67% of the combined company. 23
No collar protects the ratio, The Inference reported on November 13, so every dollar off Marvell's stock cuts $4.50 from the offer. 4 Hurlston's stated exits are narrow: a shareholder vote against the deal, or a regulatory block, with the material-adverse-change clause "very limited" and a $3.2 billion fee payable only if regulators refuse. 14 Since the October 28 close that first reported the deal, Marvell has fallen 45% and Lumentum 42%. 2
Priced at November 18 closes, the offer is 4.5 times Marvell's $145.54, about $655 a share, against Lumentum's $551.07: a premium of roughly 19%, barely narrower than the 19.7% spread a week earlier. 456
The business is not the complaint
Lumentum's revenue reached $1.26 billion in the quarter to September 26, up 136.5% year over year, and has risen every quarter for two years, more than tripling. 57 Marvell's quarter to August 1 delivered $2.74 billion, up 36.5%, and $605.5 million of operating cash flow, against roughly $5.0 billion of debt and $3.9 billion of cash. 68
Lumentum's revenue has more than tripled in two years
Data
| Quarterly revenue | |
|---|---|
| Q2 '24 | $0.31B |
| Q3 '24 | $0.34B |
| Q4 '24 | $0.4B |
| Q1 '25 | $0.43B |
| Q2 '25 | $0.48B |
| Q3 '25 | $0.53B |
| Q4 '25 | $0.67B |
| Q1 '26 | $0.81B |
| Q2 '26 | $1.01B |
| Q3 '26 | $1.26B |
Part of the damage is the sector's: The Inference's US AI 100 index is down 11% in a month. 9 Even so, Lumentum insiders sold about $86 million of stock in the three months before the announcement, and investor-rights firms are investigating whether the ratio is fair. 5
Every Wall Street target sits above Lumentum's share price
Lumentum trades at $551; the lowest target is $686
Data
| Dollars per Lumentum share | |
|---|---|
| Market price (Nov 19) | $551.07 |
| UBS | $686 |
| Bernstein SocGen | $700 |
| B. Riley | $770 |
| Stifel | $806 |
| Average target | $1,070 |
Two dated tests decide it
Hurlston's catalysts are on the calendar: Marvell's December 1 earnings report, then the S-4 merger filing, which will put Lumentum's standalone financials in front of shareholders for the first time. 2 Semafor also reports Marvell chief Matt Murphy could be tapped to run Nvidia−10.86% — Nvidia, down 10.86 percent today; Hurlston allows that "he can do the job." 1 Until those dates, the 19% gap is the market's charge for being paid in 2028 with stock nobody can reprice 1.
Get Deals by email, free
The acquisitions, rounds and contracts that move AI money. In our daily email, every weekday.






Reader comments
0 comments