Deals

American Tower settles its $2.7 billion Dish bankruptcy claim for $525 million, 19 cents on the dollar

The Dish Wireless bankruptcy's first big settlement turns a contested tower claim into year-end cash from the FCC's $2.4 billion trust, with a walk-away right and 9% interest if the money is late. Crown Castle, owed more than $3.5 billion, says nobody has called in eight weeks, and EchoStar's chairman keeps whatever the trust doesn't pay.

Vincent JiangVincent Jiangthree-minute read
Share
An American Tower communications tower with microwave dishes on top stands in open farmland beside a road near Grantsburg, Wisconsin
An American Tower communications site near Grantsburg, Wisconsin. Tower leases are the claims being settled in Dish Wireless's Chapter 11 case.

Dish Wireless, the wireless unit EchoStar−6.94% — EchoStar, down 6.94 percent today pushed into Chapter 11 in June, announced its first settlement with a big tower landlord in a Houston courtroom on November 18: an agreement in principle paying American Tower+1.86% — American Tower, up 1.86 percent today $525 million on the leases behind its abandoned 5G network 18. American Tower had put that claim at about $2.7 billion in August, making the deal roughly 19 cents on the dollar 1.

Dish's own July estimate, under its reading of the bankruptcy cap on lease damages, was $384.6 million 1. The settlement clears that by about $140 million and lands inside the $500 million to $600 million recovery chief financial officer Rodney Smith forecast in September 12.

American Tower settled well above Dish's own valuation of its claim

Nineteen cents on the dollar still beat Dish's July estimate by $140 million

$0B$1B$2B$3BClaim filed, August2.7Dish's July estimate0.385Settlement, November 18$0.53B19 cents on the dollarThe $2.4B FCC trust
Data
Value
Claim filed, August2.7
Dish's July estimate0.385
Settlement, November 18$0.53B
Dollars, billions. Claim from August proofs of claim, estimate from Dish's July voting estimates, settlement terms from the November 18 hearing. Source: Wireless Estimator.1

Cash by December 31, or walk away

Every dollar comes from the $2.4 billion trust the FCC required EchoStar to fund with AT&T's+2.11% — AT&T, up 2.11 percent today spectrum money 13. Court approval is due December 8, and the trust agreement must be amended with the FCC's consent so payment lands by December 31 1.

If the FCC will not sign, American Tower can tear the deal up and resume litigating the lease cap and Dish's force majeure defense; if it waits, EchoStar owes 9% interest on the unpaid amount 1. "If we can't be paid promptly, we have the option to return to the status quo," American Tower attorney Dan Forman told Judge Christopher Lopez 1.

The radios were never in the deal

The settlement buys peace on rent, not gear. A bankruptcy abandonment order already made the tower companies owners of the 5G equipment Dish left behind, as The Inference reported on November 2, and chief executive Steven Vondran has said his company can "do whatever we want to do with it" 45.

SpaceX−6.35% — SpaceX, down 6.35 percent today, reported to be negotiating for access to up to 80,000 sites, is the named possible buyer, and Crown Castle+1.14% — Crown Castle, up 1.14 percent today chief executive Christian Hillabrant said the same equipment on his 12,000 towers could cut a new entrant's time to market by one to two years 567. Nothing is signed, so the radios sit as an unpriced second asset beside the $525 million 567.

Ergen keeps the change

EchoStar holds the residual interest in the trust: whatever creditors do not collect returns to chairman Charlie Ergen 1. Crown Castle lawyer Kyle Kimpler called that "the fundamental conflict that is driving these cases," and said the largest claimant, owed more than $3.5 billion, has had "not a single proposal or had a single call" in eight weeks; Crown Castle wants the case converted to Chapter 7 16.

The landlord owed the most is the one still waiting

  • Claim in the bankruptcy
  • Settlement reached
$0B$1B$2B$3B$4BAmerican TowerCrown Castle$2.7BNo proposal in eight weeks
Data
Claim in the bankruptcySettlement reached
American Tower$2.7B$0.53B
Crown Castle$3.5B—
Dollars, billions. American Tower's claim from its August proofs of claim; Crown Castle described as owed more than $3.5 billion by its lawyer at the November 18 hearing, with no proposal made in eight weeks. Source: Wireless Estimator.1

About $1.5 billion remains in the trust for everyone who has not settled, SBA says its own deal is close, and Judge Lopez hears the financing and trustee fights on December 16 to 18 1. The landlord that settled gets paid first; the landlord owed the most is still waiting for the phone to ring.

Get Deals by email, free

The acquisitions, rounds and contracts that move AI money. In our daily email, every weekday.

Loading AMT

Reader comments

0 comments

    Deals

    Apollo and Goldman sell a record $44 billion of bonds to buy Nvidia chips for SpaceX

    The largest AI-chip financing on record was oversubscribed and upsized in the same session that SpaceX, Nvidia and the deal's own banks sold off. The money building AI compute is bond money now, and Friday was the day it set its price.

    Deals

    NextEra Energy's $67 billion Dominion Energy deal clears antitrust as Virginia weighs $10 credits vs $29

    Three Richmond regulators can now read the sealed memo alleging political misconduct at NextEra's Florida utility, the same week Washington's antitrust review ended. The $67 billion deal's last live risk is a Virginia rate case: $10 a month offered against a governor's $29.

    Deals

    Bending Spoons prices $1.3 billion of stock at $40 a share after its 10% deal-share cap is waived

    The price appears only in Thursday evening's 6-K, in filings that also disclose a November 3 waiver lifting the ceiling on shares issued for deals. The equity tap that pays for Mailchimp no longer has a cap, and most of the growth it buys is bought.

    Deals

    ADP bought ZenBusiness, last valued at $1.7 billion, and filed the 8-K where no price is required

    ADP's one-page 8-K skipped the acquisition item that would have forced out the price. The bet inside it: a million formed companies, and the chance that some eventually run payroll.

    Deals

    Lumentum's CEO admits the $115 billion Marvell deal 'hasn't worked as we expected'

    Only a failed shareholder vote or a regulatory block can undo the $115 billion sale, Michael Hurlston says, and a ratio fixed at 4.5 Marvell shares has turned Marvell's 45% slide into Lumentum's problem.

    Deals

    Intuit sells Mailchimp to Bending Spoons for $3.68 billion, 69% below its 2021 price

    The sale hands Intuit a markdown of roughly $8.3 billion on the $12 billion it paid in 2021, and it landed in the same release as a cut to full-year growth guidance on Credit Karma, where management says AI is changing how consumers engage. Shares fell about 10% after hours.

    Subscribe to TheInference for free