Economy

S&P gives Chicago one-in-two downgrade odds, backing the ex-CFO who counted 56%

Mayor Brandon Johnson says his 2027 budget is 76% structurally balanced because $480 million of borrowing for police-misconduct settlements counts as recurring money; the CFO who quit, a former Fitch analyst, put it at 56%. S&P's downgrade watch turns on exactly that number, and its 90-day window runs past the December 31 budget deadline.

Richard TangRichard Tangthree-minute read
Share
Close portrait of Chicago Mayor Brandon Johnson in glasses and a blue suit
Mayor Brandon Johnson, photographed at the 2023 Chicago Memorial Day Parade. S&P put Chicago's bonds on CreditWatch negative on November 18, citing a 2027 budget it says is mostly nonstructural.

S&P Global Ratings, one of the handful of agencies that set the city's borrowing costs, put Chicago on CreditWatch negative on Wednesday, November 18: at least a one-in-two chance of a downgrade inside 90 days, on a BBB rating that sits two notches above junk 1. The watch covers $9.86 billion of property-tax-backed bonds, and the city's sales-tax-backed debt went on with it 2. What alarmed the agency was not a payment Chicago missed. It is a number the city cannot agree on.

The fight is over whether borrowing is revenue

Mayor Brandon Johnson's 2027 budget closes an $882 million gap and, on his telling, is 76% structural, meaning funded by money that recurs year after year 3. Ashlee Gabrysch, the third chief financial officer to leave City Hall this year and a former senior director at Fitch Ratings, counted 56%, because $480 million of the gap is closed with bonds issued to pay police-misconduct settlements 45.

She quit on November 13, writing that the CFO's statements "must be complete and accurate" and that she could not meet that duty "under the conditions in which I have been asked to serve" 4. Borrowing for settlements, she wrote, "kicks it into the future, with interest": about $190 million of it on the 2027 bonds, "money that won't go to a single library or clinic" 4.

The ratings agency has already picked a side

Acting CFO Michael Belsky defends the mayor's arithmetic: "you can issue bonds every year at any time to meet an obligation like settlements... you can say that's a structural match" 5. S&P's research update rejects that construction by name, listing "bonding for legal settlements" among the city's nonstructural expedients and concluding that most measures closing the gap are "either non-structural or contested" by the council 12. The definitional fight is the ratings fight. Alderman Andre Vasquez put it in a holder's terms: "Taking out a credit card to pay for something isn't revenue. It is financing" 3.

December 31 is the date everything lands

The watch window runs past the December 31 statutory deadline for passing a budget, leaving roughly six weeks of negotiation 13. A council majority has already rejected more than $400 million of the mayor's revenue, led by a hike of the lease tax, which covers cloud software, to 20% 12.

That matters beyond Illinois: a big city trying to fund itself off a tax on cloud computing, the substrate every AI service runs on, is a template other treasurers will copy if it survives. Belsky's escape hatch is his own: promptly pass a balanced budget built on structural revenues, and the watch resolves 6.

The biggest rejected revenue item is Chicago's cloud-software lease tax

$0M$50M$100M$150M$200M$250MLease tax incl. cloud software$234MCorporate head tax$100MParking-meter upfront payment$75M
Data
Value
Lease tax incl. cloud software$234M
Corporate head tax$100M
Parking-meter upfront payment$75M
Proposed fiscal 2027 revenue items rejected by a City Council majority, in millions of dollars. Sources: Chicago Sun-Times, WTTW News.1,2

The probe will outlast the notch

The same day S&P acted, the council voted 45 to 5 for an outside firm to test whether "material or intentional misstatements" about city finances reached investors, council members or the public 3. This is not an audit: aldermen want the emails, memos and draft PowerPoints behind the city's numbers 3. A disclosure problem outlasts any one-notch cut, and a three-year document review on a year-end clock is work at the scale and speed AI tooling now handles; whichever firm Finance Committee chair Pat Dowell hires has no excuse to be slow 3.

Chicago does not have an arithmetic problem. It has an agreement problem, and bondholders pay for the difference. The watch ends when the city passes a budget a credit analyst would sign, and until then Chicago's paper is a coin flip the city is flipping itself.

Get Economy by email, free

How AI moves rates, banks, payments and the wider economy. In our daily email, every weekday.

Reader comments

0 comments

    More in Economy

    All in this topic →

    Economy

    Dan Loeb sold Amazon and set AI's payback at $2-3 trillion of new revenue a year

    The Third Point founder's letter and his fund's latest 13F rank the AI spenders by one rule: who can fund the wait for revenue that does not exist yet. Friday's rout applied the same ranking as the Nasdaq erased its 2026 gains.

    Economy

    Goldman raised its bitcoin ETF book 121% to $1.28 billion by September 30. Bitcoin is down 20% since

    The marks are from September 30, and the seven weeks since have run the other way: $3.47 billion has left US bitcoin ETFs and bitcoin is down about 20%. The same filing shows Goldman halved its Strategy stake before MSCI's November 30 ejection forces index funds to sell.

    Economy

    AI infrastructure drove half of Moody's ratings issuance growth this year, CFO says

    Four weeks after a quarter that leveraged finance stopped paying for, Moody's chief financial officer sized the AI buildout at about half the ratings agency's issuance growth this year. Moody's shareholders and the bond funds holding AI paper now carry the same exposure.

    Economy

    Bitcoin fell below $59,000 as $90 billion left crypto and stocks shed $500 billion at the open

    The selling ran through leverage, ETF flows and index rules, and landed on leveraged traders, the index funds being forced out of Strategy, and MARA, the bitcoin miner paying for AI data centers with coin sales.

    Economy

    Russian missiles crash in Poland, its WIG20 has worst day since March

    The equal-weight S&P was flat while the Nasdaq 100 fell 3.2%: this is the AI unwind, not the war. Act on defense names, not the index.

    Economy

    Retail traders churned a record $1.4 billion of Anthropic shares in a day

    Anthropic's November 19 debut set a listing-day record for retail turnover, and Robinhood, the broker that handed customers shares at $83, has fallen 29 percent in a month. Crypto is now 8 percent of Robinhood's revenue, and December's Fed decision and operating data will price the gap.

    Subscribe to TheInference for free