SAP cannot yet tie its AI spend to value, its chief AI officer says

SAP sells customers daily caps, departmental budgets and a paid gateway to govern AI agents, its chief AI officer said in an interview published Friday. The shares fell 5.0% and 3.18% this week; the first full-year read of the buildout comes January 28, 2027.

Vincent JiangVincent Jiangthree-minute read
Share
SAP illustration of its AI Agent Hub dashboard, showing a status summary of AI agents and a donut chart of 228 discovery items by review status
SAP's own illustration of the AI Agent Hub governance dashboard, where agents are inventoried and flagged for review. The story turns on whether SAP can meter and price that agent use.

In an interview with the German IT outlet Computerwoche, published Friday and carried by CIO.com, SAP−1.75% — SAP, down 1.75 percent today chief AI officer Jonathan von Rüden laid out how the company charges for AI agents 1. Joule Work, SAP's agent workspace, sets a daily usage limit per employee, budgets by department or country, and lets staff request more when the money runs out: usage-based billing joined to central cost control, across a choice of 70 language models 1.

The governance layer above it, the Enterprise AI Gateway announced at SAP's TechEd developer conference in Berlin on October 27, consolidates "policy enforcement, routing, monitoring, usage tracking and auditing," the company says 4. The basic Agent Gateway is free; the rules that matter sit in the premium tier 1.

The admission underneath the product

Inside SAP, "most people don't change the default model," von Rüden said, even though a cost-balanced default "can already reduce costs considerably," and automatic routing to cheaper models is still tested only inside SAP 1. Consumption is not yet linked to value: "a CFO rightly asks: We've spent this amount; what did it bring us?" 1. SAP itself is "investing significantly" in AI, he said, and needs to "become even more precise" in managing that investment 1. With no uniform standard for agent governance, policy "has to be implemented manually" 1.

ServiceNow already sells the meter SAP lacks

ServiceNow−0.25% — ServiceNow, down 0.25 percent today, the US workflow-software rival, announced the missing piece on October 15: AI Cost Management, due to be available later this quarter, consolidates spending across models, software and data centers, while the cost capabilities of its AI Control Tower track agent spend by user and department and connect "consumption and quality with business value" 7. The vendor selling AI budgets cannot yet read its own meter.

What the market has priced, and what it has not

The shares fell 5.0% to €191.82 on Monday November 16 and another 3.18% on Thursday November 19, when the relative strength index (RSI), a price-momentum gauge, sat at 29, a sell signal on TradingKey's technical read 23. The stock trades at roughly 28 to 29 times forward earnings 3.

TradingKey lists "generative AI margin dilution" from deploying Business AI and Joule agents among SAP's risks 3, and Reuters has reported SAP swapping costly models for cheaper ones, with finance chief Dominik Asam pointing to more than €2 billion in efficiency gains over two years 6. The reported numbers show no dilution yet: gross margin has held between 71.4% and 74.0% for twelve straight quarters 9.

Twelve quarters of AI buildout, and SAP's gross margin has not compressed

Through Q3 2026, SAP's reported gross margin shows no AI dilution

71727374Q1 '24Q3 '24Q1 '25Q3 '25Q1 '26Q3 '26Agents at scale; margin holds
Data
Gross margin
Q4 '2373.3
Q1 '2471.7
Q2 '2472.6
Q3 '2473.3
Q4 '2474
Q1 '2573.3
Q2 '2573.3
Q3 '2573.5
Q4 '2571.4
Q1 '2673
Q2 '2673.2
Q3 '2673.1
Quarterly gross margin, percent of revenue, calendar quarters Q4 2023 through Q3 2026, compiled from SAP's SEC filings.9

JPMorgan's bull case is a bet on the unfinished meter

The other side of the trade is real. JPMorgan analyst Toby Ogg upgraded SAP on November 9 to Overweight, the bank's buy rating, with a €275 target, arguing enterprise AI now turns on "context, control and cost" 5. He cites IDC, the IT research firm, on its finding that 67% of organizations running agents in production exceeded their budgets, exactly the problem Joule Work meters 5.

SAP has repurchased roughly 9.65 million shares by November 13 2 and posted its first €10 billion quarter, with cloud revenue up 26% and contracted backlog up 28% at €24.1 billion 8. The next reading lands January 28, 2027, when SAP reports full-year results 2: what matters is whether agent consumption shows up as priced revenue, and at what gross margin.

Get Applications by email, free

How AI is changing the software people and companies use. In our daily email, every weekday.

Loading SAP

Reader comments

0 comments

    More in Applications

    All in this topic →

    Applications

    Take-Two's GTA 6 opens with an estimated $2.36 billion day one

    An outside estimate, not a company number, puts GTA 6's first day at 24.6 million copies and $2.36 billion, among the largest entertainment openings ever measured. Take-Two's own figure, expected within days, is the one its December-quarter guidance, and the investors behind it, are waiting on.

    Applications

    Pinterest's AI assistant now compares prices in the app, its hedge as Reddit fell 29% on Google's AI search

    The suite, shipped November 12, aims to turn Pinterest's 80 billion monthly searches into purchases on its own surface. It is the hedge against the AI-search squeeze that cut 29 percent off Reddit in a day, and the holiday quarter is its first test.

    Applications

    Bending Spoons posts 125% growth, 3% organic, and puts ads on Eventbrite's checkout page

    The first quarterly filing since the IPO shows Eventbrite selling advertising after checkout, with subscriptions on trial and event discovery wired into ChatGPT. Every new revenue line sits in a channel that Bank of America says AI agents threaten.

    Applications

    Southeast Asia phone shipments fell 36% as memory costs pushed entry models past $100

    Memory costs pushed the entry-level phone past $100 and lifted the region's average selling price 53% in the steepest regional fall yet of the squeeze. The money moved to memory makers posting record quarters, and to the phone brands that can pass the cost on.

    Applications

    Veeva claims AI gets drugs to peak sales 10% faster, but its $6 billion 2030 target excludes AI

    Arno Sosna pitched AI agents that get a drug to peak sales 10% faster, then told a Copenhagen audience that AI's effect on a launch's mature half is unknown. Veeva's own $6 billion 2030 target excludes AI, and the December 3 earnings are the first test of both claims.

    Applications

    Capital International cut its Shopify stake 17.7% to $1.44 billion; Coatue opened $1.16 billion

    The September-quarter filings that landed November 13 to 16 show the register changing hands: three of the biggest US traditional fund managers sold while Coatue and Durable Capital built larger stakes. The quarter behind them grew revenue 32% and ended Shopify's run of beating the top of its own guidance, and about 63 times forward earnings rides on February's report.

    Subscribe to TheInference for free