xAI asked the Ninth Circuit to block California's training-data law as judges pressed both sides
The Ninth Circuit heard xAI's bid on Nov. 18; a ruling would set how much a frontier lab that rents compute from its own parent, SpaceX, may keep hidden, just as its biggest rival, Anthropic, banked $107.3 billion.
Vincent Jiangthree-minute read
xAI$200B — xAI, private, latest valuation $200B asked a federal appeals court on November 18 to block California's law requiring AI developers to disclose what data trained their models, and the three judges of the Ninth Circuit in San Francisco did not sound convinced 2. "Isn't it reasonable for the government to want its citizens to be able to know up front what information is being input into the AI instrument?" Judge Johnnie Rawlinson asked xAI's lawyer, per Reuters 2. The panel did press the state on scope: "What is the limit?" Judge Danielle Forrest asked California's attorney 2.
The law has been in force since January
The case, x.AI LLC v. Bonta, No. 26-1591, challenges a law Governor Gavin Newsom signed in September 2024 requiring generative AI companies to post summaries of their training datasets 2. It took effect January 1; District Judge Jesus Bernal refused to block it in March, finding xAI unlikely to win on its First Amendment and trade-secret claims 2. Since our November 10 report on Grok 4.8's late, undocumented training run, the increment is twofold: the argument has now happened, and Anthropic$350B — Anthropic, private, latest valuation $350B priced a record IPO the next day, on November 19 4.
The courtroom question is a pricing question
Last year SpaceX−6.35% — SpaceX, down 6.35 percent today folded xAI into itself, so the landlord of the lab now fighting disclosure is SpaceX, whose bull case rests on renting AI compute. SpaceX booked $18.4 billion of second-quarter capex against $7.8 billion of revenue and guided fourth-quarter capex to $35-40 billion 3. Anthropic, which raised $107.3 billion in its IPO and concurrent private placement, supplies about two-thirds of SpaceX's AI segment sales and accounted for 34.5% of third-quarter revenue, on a lease either side can end with 90 days' notice 3. That new cash makes the walk-away easier to fund, which cuts against the landlord's pricing power.
Secrecy functions as a moat for a trailing lab
On Ramp's index of more than 85,000 US businesses, xAI's adoption rose 2.2 points in October to 6.3% of firms, the largest monthly gain of any major provider, yet its share of token spend sits at 2.4% against Anthropic's 58.7% and OpenAI's$1.18T — OpenAI, private, latest valuation $1.18T 37.2% in the week ending November 15 1.
xAI wins users faster than it wins the bill
xAI reaches 6.3% of Ramp businesses but holds only 2.4% of their token spend
- AI adoption, Oct 2026 (%)
- Share of token spend, week ending Nov 15 (%)
Data
| AI adoption, Oct 2026 (%) | Share of token spend, week ending Nov 15 (%) | |
|---|---|---|
| Anthropic | 44.8% | 58.7% |
| OpenAI | 40.6% | 37.2% |
| xAI | 6.3% | 2.4% |
On this reading, secrecy functions as a moat for a lab converting trial users it has not yet converted to budgets, and a disclosure rule lowers it. Surge, which sells training data to Google, Anthropic and OpenAI, made $1.2 billion in 2024; a disclosure regime shifts where that money and the leverage over it sit 5.
The ruling lands on a lab whose parent needs the rent
Watch two dated events: the panel's ruling, which decides whether xAI must publish what its models learned from, and Dell's November 24 report, the next read on AI server demand, with its backlog at $95 billion as of July 31 3. Dell builds clusters for xAI by name, so its numbers arrive before the court speaks 3.
Get Policy & Labor by email, free
The rules governments write for AI, and what AI does to jobs. In our daily email, every weekday.






Reader comments
0 comments