xAI asked the Ninth Circuit to block California's training-data law as judges pressed both sides

The Ninth Circuit heard xAI's bid on Nov. 18; a ruling would set how much a frontier lab that rents compute from its own parent, SpaceX, may keep hidden, just as its biggest rival, Anthropic, banked $107.3 billion.

Vincent JiangVincent Jiangthree-minute read
Share
Judge Danielle Forrest of the Ninth Circuit in judicial robes, smiling, with an American flag behind her in her official court portrait.
Judge Danielle Forrest of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, who asked California's attorney "What is the limit?" at the Nov. 18 argument over xAI's bid to block the state's training-data disclosure law.

xAI$200B — xAI, private, latest valuation $200B asked a federal appeals court on November 18 to block California's law requiring AI developers to disclose what data trained their models, and the three judges of the Ninth Circuit in San Francisco did not sound convinced 2. "Isn't it reasonable for the government to want its citizens to be able to know up front what information is being input into the AI instrument?" Judge Johnnie Rawlinson asked xAI's lawyer, per Reuters 2. The panel did press the state on scope: "What is the limit?" Judge Danielle Forrest asked California's attorney 2.

The law has been in force since January

The case, x.AI LLC v. Bonta, No. 26-1591, challenges a law Governor Gavin Newsom signed in September 2024 requiring generative AI companies to post summaries of their training datasets 2. It took effect January 1; District Judge Jesus Bernal refused to block it in March, finding xAI unlikely to win on its First Amendment and trade-secret claims 2. Since our November 10 report on Grok 4.8's late, undocumented training run, the increment is twofold: the argument has now happened, and Anthropic$350B — Anthropic, private, latest valuation $350B priced a record IPO the next day, on November 19 4.

The courtroom question is a pricing question

Last year SpaceX−6.35% — SpaceX, down 6.35 percent today folded xAI into itself, so the landlord of the lab now fighting disclosure is SpaceX, whose bull case rests on renting AI compute. SpaceX booked $18.4 billion of second-quarter capex against $7.8 billion of revenue and guided fourth-quarter capex to $35-40 billion 3. Anthropic, which raised $107.3 billion in its IPO and concurrent private placement, supplies about two-thirds of SpaceX's AI segment sales and accounted for 34.5% of third-quarter revenue, on a lease either side can end with 90 days' notice 3. That new cash makes the walk-away easier to fund, which cuts against the landlord's pricing power.

Secrecy functions as a moat for a trailing lab

On Ramp's index of more than 85,000 US businesses, xAI's adoption rose 2.2 points in October to 6.3% of firms, the largest monthly gain of any major provider, yet its share of token spend sits at 2.4% against Anthropic's 58.7% and OpenAI's$1.18T — OpenAI, private, latest valuation $1.18T 37.2% in the week ending November 15 1.

xAI wins users faster than it wins the bill

xAI reaches 6.3% of Ramp businesses but holds only 2.4% of their token spend

  • AI adoption, Oct 2026 (%)
  • Share of token spend, week ending Nov 15 (%)
0%20%40%60%AnthropicOpenAIxAI6.3%2.4%
Data
AI adoption, Oct 2026 (%)Share of token spend, week ending Nov 15 (%)
Anthropic44.8%58.7%
OpenAI40.6%37.2%
xAI6.3%2.4%
AI adoption is share of US businesses on Ramp paying for each provider, October 2026; token spend share is the week ending November 15, 2026. Source: Ramp AI Index.1

On this reading, secrecy functions as a moat for a lab converting trial users it has not yet converted to budgets, and a disclosure rule lowers it. Surge, which sells training data to Google, Anthropic and OpenAI, made $1.2 billion in 2024; a disclosure regime shifts where that money and the leverage over it sit 5.

The ruling lands on a lab whose parent needs the rent

Watch two dated events: the panel's ruling, which decides whether xAI must publish what its models learned from, and Dell's November 24 report, the next read on AI server demand, with its backlog at $95 billion as of July 31 3. Dell builds clusters for xAI by name, so its numbers arrive before the court speaks 3.

Get Policy & Labor by email, free

The rules governments write for AI, and what AI does to jobs. In our daily email, every weekday.

Loading SPCX

Reader comments

0 comments

    More in Policy & Labor

    All in this topic →

    Policy & Labor

    Accenture to cut 950 of 1,400 Meta moderation jobs in Portugal as unions strike Friday

    Accenture is cutting 950 of the 1,400 Meta content-moderation seats in Lisbon, announced on November 18, 2026, ahead of union strikes on November 21. The cut is a live read on what happens to outsourcers' revenue when their biggest clients automate the per-head work those outsourcers bill for.

    Policy & Labor

    Cursor tells House panels it may drop Chinese AI models over geopolitical risk

    A House report says the tool SpaceX bought for $60 billion is exploring a phase-out of the Chinese open-weight models its Composer 2 was built on. The bill for the substitute lands inside SpaceX's $7.56 billion AI segment, which discloses no split.

    Policy & Labor

    House Democrats set a Dec. 1 deadline for Nvidia-Megaspeed records as $1.4 trillion of AI value is gone

    House Democrats have put the Nvidia-Megaspeed inquiry on a dated calendar with answers due December 1, and the approval data released alongside it freeze the China chip pipeline; the $1.4 trillion of AI value already gone is the market pricing a political overhang that outlasts December.

    Policy & Labor

    Trump's accounts bought Palantir in September, weeks before his agencies awarded it $42.5 million

    The November 19 disclosure puts the president long a stock his own agencies pay, weeks before a Democratic Congress arrives promising scrutiny of that book. The risk to Palantir holders is scrutiny of every award, not steering of the trades.

    Policy & Labor

    Roblox CEO skips Senate child-safety hearing with 196 suits pending and a Jan. 13 arbitration ruling

    Two bipartisan bills would void the click-through terms that keep 196 grooming lawsuits in private arbitration, and a January 13 bellwether ruling may open the courthouse door first. Shareholders hold the tail risk: Roblox guides Q4 bookings down 10–15% into the GTA VI launch, with the February print three weeks behind the ruling.

    Policy & Labor

    Alibaba asked for 948,950 US AI chips; 75,000 were approved, none shipped

    License records released on November 19 shut Alibaba's overseas chip route, and a New York Times account exposed the Johor workaround it used instead. A securities suit landed the same day, and the 53% AI-cloud machine now rides on Alibaba's own Zhenwu V900.

    Subscribe to TheInference for free