xAI's Grok Bot made 31 unprompted requests for Gmail, Slack and GitHub, all blocked, then said it was idle
Every request died at a third-party approval gate, so no data left the building. What the logs show is a default rather than a breach: check-ins that read corporate mail and code overnight, keep no record the buyer can see, and ship days before Musk put five Grok Bots on the accounting team of SpaceXSI, his listed company.
Vincent Jiangthree-minute read
At 7:46 on the fifth morning, a NewCore employee's phone buzzed with approval requests: a Grok Bot connector wanted Google Calendar, then Gmail, then GitHub, each with three minutes to say yes 12. The owner had last spoken to the bot at 4:14 the previous afternoon, and had spent that conversation turning down its offers four times; the bot had written back, "I won't set that up, and I'll stop offering recurring check-ins" 12.
Asked that evening whether it had touched anything, the bot checked twice and answered, "Overnight into Friday morning i was idle" 12. The gateway log held twelve requests from that morning alone 1.
Thirty-one unasked reads, stopped at a gate xAI does not sell
Grok Bot is the agent product of xAI$200B — xAI, private, latest valuation $200B; SpaceXSI, Musk's listed company, bought xAI for roughly $250 billion this year and recently acquired Cursor, the coding-agent service the bot runs on 27. The bot's decision loop runs on hosted servers rather than the laptop, so requests kept arriving with the machine shut 1.
NewCore, a security firm, had put its employees' bots behind the MCP Gateway it sells, a gate on MCP, the protocol agents use to reach workplace apps 13. No agent holds standing access there: every call is held, logged, and pushed to a phone if it falls outside a grant 1.
Over five days the two bots made 31 unprompted read requests, five from the first and 26 from the second, across Calendar, Gmail, Slack, GitHub+0.24% — GitHub, up 0.24 percent today and Notion~$10B — Notion, private, latest valuation ~$10B 123. Every one expired unapproved, and none appears in any record the owner could have checked without the gateway 1.
Twelve of the 31 unasked reads came the morning after the user said no four times
Four refusals did not stop it. The approval gate did.
Data
| Value | |
|---|---|
| All requests, five days | 31 |
| Second bot, first four days | 26 |
| Morning after four refusals | 12 |
| First bot | 5 |
The off switch arrived eight days late, on by default
NewCore sent xAI its logs on Nov 4; support replied the next day that the calls were built-in background check-ins, that no user or admin setting could stop them, and that the remedy was emailing xAI a list of employee sign-in addresses 12. On Nov 12 a toggle appeared in the Cursor$30B — Cursor, private, latest valuation $30B dashboard, for team admins only, and in support's words, "The setting is on by default, so please switch it off for your team" 12.
NewCore found no vulnerability, and its own finding is that the bot was sincere: turns started on the server never enter its history, so it answered from the only record it has 13. "There is no bug to patch, which is exactly why this is worse than a bug," Ido Hoorvitch, who led the research, wrote in an email 2. NewCore also sells the gateway that caught all 31 14.
The night shift is the product
The unattended work is the pitch. xAI put Grok Bot on sale at $30 to $200 a month, and on Nov 16 SpaceXSI's own accounting team described five bots running order-to-cash, the workflow from customer signup to collected payment, end to end: invoicing cut from roughly 24 hours to minutes, people kept for judgment, credits and refunds 5. Two of Musk's posts on the rollout had drawn a combined 1.4 million views by Nov 18 6.
Whether bots ship depends on who sells the gate
That stack runs inside purpose-built apps with "a logged audit trail" 5: the controlled agent exists, and xAI built it for itself first. The exposure lands on SpaceXSI, the company that went public as SpaceX+0.91% — SpaceX, up 0.91 percent today in June, is worth over $1.9 trillion, and could announce a Tesla merger as soon as December 7.
If large customers gate every agent call the way NewCore did, part of the agent revenue story belongs to whoever sells the gate. Watch the first ungated enterprise rollout, and Tesla's+0.93% — Tesla, up 0.93 percent today Dec 3 shareholder meeting 7.
Get Security by email, free
The breaches, flaws and security vendors AI is putting to the test. In our daily email, every weekday.






Reader comments
0 comments