Economy

Apollo Global Management's economist grades AI zero outside tech; Apollo is named in Nvidia's $500 billion

Apollo chief economist Torsten Slok says AI has delivered zero financial payoff to corporate America outside tech. His firm is named among six financiers arranging more than $500 billion for Nvidia's buildout, against $466 billion of AI debt issued this year.

Vincent JiangVincent Jiang · 3 min read
Share
Torsten Slok, chief economist at Apollo Global Management, in a portrait against a green background
1 / 7Slide 1 of 7
Torsten Slok, chief economist at Apollo Global Management, whose October 24 note graded AI's payoff outside tech at zero.

Zero payoff, in three flat lines

Torsten Slok, chief economist at the investment firm Apollo Global Management−1.74% — Apollo Global Management, down 1.74 percent today, graded the AI boom in a October 24 note: the technology "has delivered zero financial payoff to corporate America outside of tech." 12 Revenue per employee at the Magnificent Seven, the largest US tech stocks, climbed from about $550,000 in 2022 to nearly $800,000, while the other 493 companies in the S&P 500 have sat near $550,000 for seven years. 2

Margins outside tech sit near 10%, against almost 30%, with no lift in productivity growth. 3 Even the spending is concentrated: 99.5% of model-inference spending comes from the top 10% of firms. 3 "The AI story will be decided in the S&P 493, not the Mag 7," Slok wrote. 3

Revenue per worker: the Mag 7 pulled away, the S&P 493 stood still

  • 2022
  • 2026
$0$200$400$600$800Magnificent Seven$550$800+45%S&P 493$550$5500.0%
Data
20222026Change
Magnificent Seven$550$800+45.5%
S&P 493$550$5500.0%
Revenue per employee in thousands of dollars, 2022 versus 2026, from charts in Apollo chief economist Torsten Slok's October 24 note.2

The financier shares the letterhead

The awkward part is Apollo's other line of work. The research firm IO Fund names Apollo, alongside BlackRock−1.69% — BlackRock, down 1.69 percent today, Blackstone−0.97% — Blackstone, down 0.97 percent today, Brookfield, Goldman Sachs−1.40% — Goldman Sachs, down 1.40 percent today and KKR, in preliminary agreements to channel more than $500 billion of third-party capital into Nvidia's−0.54% — Nvidia, down 0.54 percent today chip ecosystem. 4 One desk at the firm measures AI demand; its deal desks finance the supply.

That supply is running at record speed: Morgan Stanley−2.32% — Morgan Stanley, down 2.32 percent today counts $466 billion of AI-related debt issued through September, up from $101 billion a year earlier, and Goldman Sachs counts $489 billion by late July. 4 Whether the two sides of the house compare notes is not in the public record.

AI-related debt issuance has roughly quadrupled in a year

$0B$200B$400B$600BA year earlier (Morgan Stanley)Through September (Morgan Stanley)By late July (Goldman Sachs)$489B
Data
AI-related debt issued
A year earlier (Morgan Stanley)$101B
Through September (Morgan Stanley)$466B
By late July (Goldman Sachs)$489B
Cumulative AI-related debt issued, billions of dollars. Morgan Stanley counts $466 billion through September, up from $101 billion a year earlier; Goldman Sachs counted $489 billion by late July.4

Who pays if the zero holds

The research firm Gartner−1.77% — Gartner, down 1.77 percent today totals the same gap from above: data-center owners need $8.5 trillion of revenue through 2030 to justify the buildout, against the $3.6 trillion it expects to flow back, a $4.9 trillion gap, with more than $3.5 trillion of spending facing write-down. 51

Gartner sees a $4.9 trillion gap between the buildout and the payback

  • Gartner projection
  • Estimate
$0T$5T$10TRevenue needed through 2030Revenue Gartner expectsSpending facing write-downShortfall: $4.9T
Data
Gartner projection
Revenue needed through 2030 (estimate)$8.5T
Revenue Gartner expects (estimate)$3.6T
Spending facing write-down (estimate)$3.5T
Gartner projections, trillions of dollars: the revenue data-center owners need through 2030 to justify the buildout versus the revenue Gartner expects to flow back, and the spending facing write-down.5,1

CoreWeave−2.97% — CoreWeave, down 2.97 percent today, the GPU cloud whose bonds already price a near 63% chance of default within five years, marks the bottom of the chain. 6 Its quarterly revenue quadrupled in eight quarters, while the operating income it filed across those quarters sums to about negative $10 million. 7 Third-quarter guidance puts interest expense at $860 million to $940 million against $200 million to $260 million of adjusted operating income. 8

Meta−1.36% — Meta, down 1.36 percent today raised the floor of its 2026 capex plan to $135 billion to $145 billion, posted negative $2.12 billion of free cash flow, and its five-year default swaps hit a record; the stock fell nearly 7%. 9

CoreWeave quadrupled revenue in eight quarters for about zero cumulative operating income

  • Revenue
  • Operating income
-$1B$0B$1B$2B$3BQ3 '24Q4 '24Q1 '25Q2 '25Q3 '25Q4 '25Q1 '26Q2 '26Interest bill: $640M
Data
RevenueOperating income
Q3 '24$0.58B$0.12B
Q4 '24$0.75B$0.11B
Q1 '25$0.98B-$0.03B
Q2 '25$1.21B$0.02B
Q3 '25$1.37B$0.05B
Q4 '25$1.57B-$0.09B
Q1 '26$2.08B-$0.14B
Q2 '26$2.58B-$0.05B
Quarterly revenue and GAAP operating income, billions of dollars, Q3 2024 through Q2 2026, from CoreWeave's SEC filings.7,8

Demand is real, and so is the due date

The doubling-down camp has numbers too: a $104 billion backlog at CoreWeave, prices up about 25% in July with near-term capacity sold out, and $127 billion of Nvidia free cash flow in the year through July. 84 Slok leaves his own door open: can mainstream corporate America "turn increasingly cheap intelligence into higher revenue growth and higher profit margins"? "That may be harder than it sounds," he added. 2

This week brings Google, Microsoft+0.64% — Microsoft, up 0.64 percent today and Amazon−0.72% — Amazon, down 0.72 percent today results plus a Federal Reserve meeting, and CoreWeave reports on November 12. 48 If interest lands at the high end of that guide, the zero gets expensive.

Get Economy by email, free

How AI moves rates, banks, payments and the wider economy. In our daily email, every weekday.

Loading APO…

Reader comments

0 comments

    More in Economy

    All in this topic →

    Economy

    Morgan Stanley and Goldman Sachs count $9 billion a week of default insurance on AI debt

    Morgan Stanley and Goldman Sachs each published research this week showing investors buying insurance against the failure of the AI buildout. The Fed meets in three days, and its rate path decides who refinances the debt that funds the chips.

    Economy

    FICO freezes its $10 mortgage price for a year; Equifax sells the $1 rival through 2028

    Fair Isaac held the wholesale price of its mortgage credit score at $10 into 2027 for lenders already committed to it, and the shares fell 6 percent after hours. November 4, 2026, is the first earnings report since Fannie and Freddie put the $1 rival on the same fee grid, and about 43 percent of revenue rides on the result.

    Economy

    Coinbase's desk prices an 80% December hike while liquidity sits $13 billion below May, with Q3 due October 29

    Coinbase's desk prices an 80% December rate hike while its own order book and liquidity gauges say crypto-native buyers have left. The stock reports Q3 on October 29, with 64% of bitcoin longs entered above spot.

    Economy

    Affirm's CFO sold 96% of his stock at $80. The Street says buy at $70

    Affirm's CFO cut his stake 96% at $80.02 while 24 of 32 analysts held Buy ratings with a $97.81 target. The Sam's Club deal, a November 5 earnings print and a November 15 bond maturity now settle the argument.

    Economy

    Larry Ellison pledged 413 million Oracle shares to fund the Warner deal as Oracle's CDS hits 322 basis points

    Ellison scrapped a $7.5 billion Oracle share sale in September and pledged Oracle, Tesla and SpaceX stock instead to fund his son's Warner deal, just as Oracle's credit spread hit 322 basis points and Skydance took a $1 billion check from Musk. October 28's Investor Day is the first test of whether the founder's leverage matters to the company's.

    Economy

    Binance's token on the Invesco QQQ is 80% of its tokenized-stock trading; Robinhood trades 59% after hours

    BNB Chain traded $25.6 billion of tokenized US equities in Q3, eleven times Q2, with a Binance-issued Invesco QQQ token at 80% of the flow. Robinhood Chain's counter is the clock: 59% of its volume now trades while Wall Street is closed.

    Get the newsletter

    The day's AI and market news, in your inbox every weekday.