Card, auto and student loan delinquency hit cycle highs as Upstart, Affirm and PayPal pitch growth
Card delinquency is near its 2011 high, auto delinquency is the worst on record since 2003 and student delinquency the highest since 2019, all in the New York Fed's Q3 tables. The lenders funding that consumer, Upstart, Affirm and PayPal, spent the autumn promising growth.
Vincent Jiangthree-minute read
Every major line of consumer credit sits at a cycle high
American households fell behind on their cards, cars and student loans at cycle-high rates in the same quarter. The New York Fed's Q3 Household Debt and Credit report shows 12.9% of credit card balances 90 or more days late, close to the highest since 2011, and 5.7% of auto loan balances that late, the worst reading in records going back to 2003, on a record $1.73 trillion of auto debt 12.
Student-loan delinquency, near zero during the pandemic payment pause, climbed to 10.9%, the highest since 2019, on $1.66 trillion of debt 34. Total household debt reached $19.1 trillion, up $334 billion in the quarter, and 5.0% of it is in some stage of delinquency, up 0.3 percentage points from Q2 4.
All three consumer credit lines sit at cycle-high delinquency at once
Card near its 2011 high, student at its 2019 high, auto the worst since 2003
Data
| Value | |
|---|---|
| Credit cards | 12.9% |
| Student loans | 10.9% |
| Auto loans | 5.7% |
The lenders spent the autumn selling growth
That backdrop did not slow the growth pitch. Upstart−6.62% — Upstart, down 6.62 percent today, the AI-lending marketplace, grew revenue 34% to $371 million and originations 44% to $4.1 billion, and chief executive Paul Gu says funding is no constraint: "buyers want more loans than we can produce" 5. Affirm−3.71% — Affirm, down 3.71 percent today, the buy-now-pay-later lender that splits shoppers' purchases into installments, grew revenue 35% to $1.26 billion, and chief executive Max Levchin wants manufacturers to fund interest-free loans on about a million products today, eventually hundreds of millions of products 6.
Revenue at Upstart and Affirm has climbed through the whole delinquency run
- Upstart
- Affirm
Data
| Upstart | Affirm | |
|---|---|---|
| Q2 '24 | $127.63M | $659M |
| Q3 '24 | $162.14M | $698M |
| Q4 '24 | $218.96M | $866M |
| Q1 '25 | $213.37M | $783M |
| Q2 '25 | $257.29M | $876M |
| Q3 '25 | $277.11M | $933M |
| Q4 '25 | $296.09M | $1,123M |
| Q1 '26 | $308.21M | $1,039M |
| Q2 '26 | $364.71M | $1,166M |
| Q3 '26 | $370.52M | $1,262M |
PayPal−5.30% — PayPal, down 5.30 percent today leaned on Pay Later, its own buy-now-pay-later offering, with volume up 25% in the quarter 7. Markets have already repriced some of this: Affirm fell 10.4% on its report, and Upstart is down roughly 60% this year 85.
A late balance is a loss for whoever bought the loan
The link between those growth pitches and the Fed's tables is loss rates. A balance 90 days late is a loss waiting to be booked, and the lenders keep little of that risk: Affirm funds its installment loans through warehouse facilities, asset-backed securitizations and forward-flow sales to institutional buyers 9.
Upstart ran that chain once. Worsening credit in 2022 and 2023 prompted banks and institutional investors to sharply cut purchases of its loans and froze the business 5. Rising losses can chill the same buyers Gu says are queuing now. Borrowers pay first, in damaged credit; then the institutions holding the loans pay. Debt collectors are the one party whose business grows with the shortfall.
Two softer readings, then the holiday test
Two Fed readings soften the tables: transitions into serious delinquency improved slightly for cards and student loans, and newly originated auto loans held largely steady credit quality 4. Gu counters that Upstart's models "separate risk better than anyone else" 5. A calmer flow into a record stock of delinquent debt suggests the stress has stopped worsening without yet easing.
The holiday quarter decides the next leg. Affirm forecasts $17.9 billion to $18.2 billion of purchases processed this quarter, against Adobe's−1.43% — Adobe, down 1.43 percent today forecast of $21.3 billion in holiday buy-now-pay-later spending 6. The Fed's Q4 tables follow in February and will show whether the holidays added to the pile or began clearing it 6.
Get Economy by email, free
How AI moves rates, banks, payments and the wider economy. In our daily email, every weekday.






Reader comments
0 comments