India tells the Supreme Court Xiaomi and Flex hid royalty deals; a $72 million bill could top $150 million
A $72 million customs demand becomes more than $150 million with penalties if Xiaomi loses, and the ruling will set the valuation template for every contract manufacturer in India, from Foxconn to Flex.
Vincent Jiangtwo-minute read
The licensing papers surfaced only after the probe began
India's government has told the Supreme Court that Xiaomi−0.13% — Xiaomi, down 0.13 percent today India and its former contract manufacturer, Flex+2.39% — Flex, up 2.39 percent today, kept the phone maker's royalty deals out of sight until investigators forced them open. In a September 21 filing asking the court to throw out Xiaomi's challenge, the government wrote that the company "knew the licensing arrangements under which it made the royalty payments and failed to make the required complete disclosure," and produced the licensing agreements only after the probe began 2. Xiaomi and the tax authority did not respond when the filing was reported for the first time this week 2.
A $72 million demand that can climb past $150 million
The customs demand on file is about $72 million 1. Lose at the Supreme Court and, with interest and penalties, it climbs past $150 million, roughly Rs 1,350 crore 1. The tribunal found Xiaomi underpaid duties in three years before 2020 by leaving royalties of 2 to 5 percent, paid to licensors such as Qualcomm−4.10% — Qualcomm, down 4.10 percent today, out of the customs value of imported phone components 2. Xiaomi filed its challenge in January 2.
India has frozen more from Xiaomi than the worst case bill in this case
India already holds more from Xiaomi than the worst case customs bill
- Estimate
Data
| Value | |
|---|---|
| Customs demand on file | $72M |
| Worst case with penalties (estimate) | $150M |
| Frozen since 2022 (ED) | $676M |
A state win would set the price of every contract manufacturer's imports
Xiaomi's position is that its contract manufacturers import the parts and the royalties are separate payments that tariffs do not touch 2. Flextronics Technologies India, the local unit of US-listed Flex, denies helping undervalue imports; the government's September 11 filing calls it liable for "failing to place the underlying contractual structure before the customs authorities" 2. A state win sets the valuation template for the model that drew Foxconn, Jabil+1.56% — Jabil, up 1.56 percent today and Tata Electronics to India, and experts expect it to spread to pharma and autos 2. Flex shareholders carry a named defendant; Xiaomi carries the bill and a proposed SFIO probe on top 3.
The money is already frozen, and a second probe may follow
Xiaomi argues the ruling shows industry-wide mistrust; the government says its case "does not proceed upon a proposition that all contract manufacturing is impermissible" 2. The precedent is already cold: India froze about $676 million of Xiaomi's funds in 2022, upheld, still frozen 3. Watch the court's next hearing date, and whether the Ministry of Corporate Affairs orders the SFIO probe 3.
Get Policy & Labor by email, free
The rules governments write for AI, and what AI does to jobs. In our daily email, every weekday.






Reader comments
0 comments