Meta, Alphabet and xAI stay silent on Scale AI worker surveillance

OpenAI alone has answered for the human-data supply behind its models; Meta, Alphabet and xAI were logged silent today. If regulators side with noyb, the question follows the training data into the buyers' weights, and Meta owns nearly half of the supplier.

Richard TangRichard Tangthree-minute read
Share
Max Schrems, in a dark hoodie, holding a microphone at a lectern marked EPFL
Max Schrems, founder of the Vienna-based privacy group noyb, whose five GDPR complaints against Scale AI's Outlier platform are the basis of the letter Meta, Alphabet and xAI left unanswered. He is speaking at EPFL.

Three of the four companies whose models run on Scale AI's$29B — Scale AI, private, latest valuation $29B training data have chosen silence. The Business and Human Rights Centre, an NGO tracker, asked Meta−0.60% — Meta, down 0.60 percent today, Alphabet+1.10% — Alphabet, up 1.10 percent today, OpenAI$1.18T — OpenAI, private, latest valuation $1.18T and xAI$200B — xAI, private, latest valuation $200B to account for their supplier after noyb, the Austria-based privacy group, filed five complaints against Scale AI under Europe's General Data Protection Regulation in late October; OpenAI replied on November 11, and today the Centre logged the other three as non-responsive 124. We covered the complaints the day they landed; the answer sheet is the news 124.

That silence looks safe and is not. The complaints name a private supplier, but the question they raise travels with the data, into models the buyers have already shipped.

You can swap a supplier in a quarter; you cannot un-train a model.

More than 900,000 freelancers sit inside the weights

Frontier models learn from human feedback, and the humans here are more than 900,000 freelancers on Outlier, Scale's data-work platform, ranking answers and writing prompts for Meta, OpenAI, Alphabet's Google and xAI 2. Working from DiPLab's report *Surveillance at Scale*, noyb alleges that third-party trackers from TikTok, LinkedIn and Facebook fired on workers' devices every few seconds, capturing enough detail to replay a work session as video, and that workers faced repeated face-video identity checks through the verification firm Persona 267.

Four workers who asked Outlier for copies of their data between December and May got no answer at all, noyb says 2. Scale denies acting illegally: its monitoring is disclosed and consented to, screen recording is opt-in and manually activated, and it neither sells worker data nor trains customers' models on it 3. No regulator has ruled; it is allegation against denial 6.

Meta cannot walk away from this one

Meta paid roughly $14 billion last year for a non-voting stake of just under half of Scale 5, which makes its silence the strangest of the three: the owner declining to vouch for its own asset. Alphabet and xAI could move their data work elsewhere; Meta stays invested either way. And noyb's threats carry weight, because its past complaints produced a €1.2 billion fine against Meta itself, and another against TikTok 4.

Silence is the expensive answer

The bottleneck is not the technology; it is supplier standards, and only buyers can enforce those at scale. An audit and a consent warranty in the next data contract cost a rounding error beside a European enforcement process, and answering a letter costs nothing.

I am firmly pro-AI, and that is exactly why this should be cleaned up now. The workers training these models are the low-paid end of the boom, and if their data was gathered under contested consent, the defect sits in everyone's weights, the silent three's included. OpenAI answered a letter. Meta, Alphabet and xAI should say where they stand while a statement is still all it costs.

Get Policy & Labor by email, free

The rules governments write for AI, and what AI does to jobs. In our daily email, every weekday.

Loading GOOGL

Reader comments

0 comments

    More in Policy & Labor

    All in this topic →

    Policy & Labor

    India tells the Supreme Court Xiaomi and Flex hid royalty deals; a $72 million bill could top $150 million

    A $72 million customs demand becomes more than $150 million with penalties if Xiaomi loses, and the ruling will set the valuation template for every contract manufacturer in India, from Foxconn to Flex.

    Policy & Labor

    First Solar CEO Mark Widmar testifies Friday as the $0.38-per-watt solar import floor takes effect Dec. 4

    The margin, not the volume, is the profit at First Solar, and the margin rests on tariffs and price floors that take their next step on December 4. Widmar defends that wall in Washington two trading days before it bites.

    Policy & Labor

    Judge voids wildlife approval for the first US seabed mining sale, 31 million acres, due November 19

    A federal judge vacated the Endangered Species Act basis for Thursday's $3 million-a-tract seabed auction off American Samoa, but issued no injunction and the agency still lists the sale. The exposure is private marks in seabed-mining names, not listed stocks.

    Policy & Labor

    Netherlands rejects US bill to curb ASML's China business, worth nearly a third of revenue

    What the bill would reach is the servicing of machines already in Chinese fabs and further sales of ASML's less advanced tools there, a market worth nearly a third of revenue. The 150-day compliance clock starts only if Congress passes the act, and its inclusion in the year-end defense bill is not yet assured.

    Policy & Labor

    27% of finance departments have cut staff because of AI, Gartner survey finds

    Gartner's survey of 1,303 senior leaders finds 27% of finance functions cut staff for AI against 6% that hired, and only 1.7 of the five hours finance workers save each week reach the business. The first hard number on where the seats go, for anyone underwriting AI as a labor saver.

    Policy & Labor

    UK sets March 2029 end for Palantir's £330 million NHS data contract

    Ministers took the later of the deal's two break clauses, keeping Palantir as the primary software provider for NHS patient data until March 2029 while British rivals prepare bids. Taxpayers fund two more years; Palantir must re-win or lose its showcase civilian contract.

    Subscribe to TheInference for free