Oracle slid to about $103, under Bernstein's $133 floor if its AI data-center business fails

Bernstein's stress case says Oracle's databases, software and conventional cloud are worth $133 a share even if its AI data-center business fails. At $110.57 and falling, the slide suggests investors are pricing what that floor leaves out: years of negative cash flow between building the capacity and getting paid for it.

Richard TangRichard Tangthree-minute read
Share
Larry Ellison speaking into a microphone on stage at Oracle OpenWorld in 2009, with an Oracle presentation screen behind him
Larry Ellison, Oracle's founder and chairman, on stage at Oracle OpenWorld in San Francisco in October 2009. Bernstein's stress case values Oracle at $133 a share with its AI data-center business zeroed out.

Oracle−6.58% — Oracle, down 6.58 percent today closed at $110.57 on November 19 and slid to about $103 on Friday, leaving the shares down more than 40% this year and below the $133 that Bernstein analyst Mark Moerdler says Oracle is worth if its AI data-center business fails outright 12. The slide suggests investors are pricing the years of negative cash flow between building the capacity and getting paid for it, not a collapse in AI demand.

The floor leaves out the part now being priced

Moerdler's November 18 stress case zeroes out AI data-center revenue, writes the hardware down to nothing and keeps the debt 23. Oracle's databases, business software and conventional cloud are still worth about $133 together 2. Two exclusions carry that number.

The case rules out an AI winter in which generative AI fails globally 3. And it assumes Oracle can re-let the $288 billion of data-center leases it would be left holding, leases that run as long as 19 years and that we watched Oracle try to defer in September 2.

Half the backlog rests on OpenAI

S&P puts OpenAI$1.18T — OpenAI, private, latest valuation $1.18T at about half of Oracle's $664 billion backlog, its signed contracts not yet billed, and only 13% of that backlog becomes revenue within a year 14. OpenAI's half is more than six years of its revenue at its current pace, and its latest funding round has reached $15 billion of the $30 billion it set out to raise 4.

The $133 values what Oracle's businesses would be worth after failure 2. It says nothing about where the shares trade while the company borrows to finish the build.

Oracle trades below the $133 floor Bernstein set for total AI failure

  • Oracle share price
  • Estimate
$0$100$200$300$400Bernstein bull targetAI-failure floorNov 2 equity offerNov 19 closeNov 20 intraday$103
Data
Oracle share price
Bernstein bull target (estimate)$325
AI-failure floor (estimate)$133
Nov 2 equity offer$116
Nov 19 close$110.57
Nov 20 intraday$103
Oracle share price, $. The $325 bull target and the $133 AI-failure floor are Bernstein analyst estimates; the other three bars are market prices. Source: Bernstein via Benzinga and MarketWatch, and GuruFocus.1,2,3

The weak link is cash, not demand

The burn explains the gap. Oracle spent $28.5 billion on capital projects in the August quarter against $23.1 billion of operating cash, and analysts expect free cash flow to stay negative through fiscal 2028 156. Management says the spending peaks this fiscal year and next 7.

The bill lands on the balance sheet now. On November 2 Oracle priced $10 billion of stock at $116 2. The $10 billion of bonds beside it carry 7% to 8.65%, and together the two sales used up in a single day the fundraising cap management had announced five days earlier 89. The equity buyers are already under water, and CreditSights, a credit research firm, says the bonds trade like junk despite an investment-grade rating 3.

Capital spending has pulled ahead of Oracle's operating cash flow

Capital spending overtook the cash the business generates as the buildout accelerated

  • Capital spending
  • Operating cash flow
$0B$10B$20B$30BFeb 2024Aug 2024Feb 2025Aug 2025Feb 2026Aug 2026$28.5B
Data
Capital spendingOperating cash flow
Feb 2024$1.67B$5.48B
May 2024$2.8B$6.08B
Aug 2024$2.3B$7.43B
Nov 2024$3.97B$1.3B
Feb 2025$5.86B$5.93B
May 2025$9.08B$6.16B
Aug 2025$8.5B$8.14B
Nov 2025$12.03B$2.07B
Feb 2026$18.64B$7.15B
May 2026$16.49B$14.62B
Aug 2026$28.5B$23.1B
Oracle quarterly capital expenditure and operating cash flow, $ billions, quarters ending in the months shown. Source: Oracle SEC filings.5

December 14 decides which bet this is

Pentwater, a hedge fund running $19 billion, loaded 11.75 million Oracle shares in the third quarter, its second-biggest position 6. Its puts, options that pay off if the shares fall, outweigh its calls, which pay off if they rise; a 13F filing shows no short positions, so the puts may hedge the shares rather than bet against them 6. Oracle reports on December 14 1.

The number to watch is the backlog turning into cash. The customers already closing that gap are the ones who prepay or bring their own hardware; they added $11.4 billion to operating cash in the August quarter alone 4. Demand is not in question: revenue grew nearly 30% in the quarter 5.

A discount, or the price of the debt

Show the backlog converting on December 14 1, and a price below the floor is a discount. Show more borrowing against OpenAI's half of it, and the discount is the market pricing the debt and the lease commitments, not a collapse in demand.

Get Data Center by email, free

Who is building AI's data centers, and who is paying for them. In our daily email, every weekday.

Loading ORCL

Reader comments

0 comments

    More in Data Center

    All in this topic →

    Data Center

    SpaceX's 10-Q shows $48.1 billion of capex against $13.1 billion of cash before its December 8 lock-up

    SpaceX's Q3 10-Q puts the build at $48.1 billion of nine-month capex against $13.1 billion of operating cash, with the gap filled by $43 billion of chip-lease debt near 8.3%. That is the case against the equity 17 days before its lock-up expires, with Anthropic holding a 90-day exit.

    Data Center

    Applied Digital put $97 million into ChronoScale on a note that matures December 31

    The Schedule 13D/A filed November 20 shows the funding behind ChronoScale's $200 million Super Micro GPU order: a $97 million no-interest note from majority owner Applied Digital, fully funded and maturing December 31. Conversion needs a stockholder consent still in the mail, so one balance sheet carries the timing risk.

    Data Center

    Trump threatens 'tremendous tax' on US companies that build data centers abroad

    No rate, timetable or legal authority accompanied the threat, which landed on Alphabet, Amazon, Microsoft, Meta and Oracle, the companies already building abroad, on a day the Nasdaq 100 fell 5.7%.

    Data Center

    Fermi falls 16% as a court lets its board rewrite bylaws by majority while shareholders need 70% to act

    The ruling leaves Fermi shareholders needing 70% of all outstanding shares to touch the board while directors can rewrite the same rules by simple majority. The co-founder who sued sold $21 million of stock the week before, and the five-day rally on Amazon's name rests on a lease that is not signed.

    Data Center

    Cameron County rejects SpaceX tax break on $24 billion Starbase campus

    The nonbinding rejection opens a fight over property taxes on a $24 billion campus, and it arrives in a week when SpaceX priced $76 billion of GPU debt.

    Data Center

    YTL Power denies its data centers moved Nvidia chips to China as data-center profit jumps nearly 133-fold

    The Malaysian utility filed its denial hours after quarterly results showed data-center profit up nearly 133-fold, the group's only growth engine. Investors marking the stock down about 20% in two weeks must weigh the company's word against a five-source account of Alibaba's chips running inside its Johor park.

    Subscribe to TheInference for free