Platforms

The AI buildout wiped $68 billion off IBM in a day. Now the lawyers want to know why.

IBM pitched the z17 mainframe as real-time AI iron and guided to 5-plus percent growth in April. Eighty-three days later it delivered 1 percent, and Hagens Berman is now asking what management knew as the big deals died.

Vincent JiangVincent Jiangthree-minute read
Share
IBM chief executive Arvind Krishna speaking on stage at SXSW 2025, seated and gesturing with his hands against a colorful projected backdrop.
1 / 6Slide 1 of 6
IBM CEO Arvind Krishna at SXSW 2025. Krishna's July letter to shareholders disclosed the mainframe shortfall that wiped $68 billion off IBM's market value in a day.

Ten weeks later, the lawyers arrive

Hagens Berman said on 23 September 2026 that it is investigating potential violations of U.S. securities laws by IBM−1.23% — IBM, down 1.23 percent today, centered on what the company said about its Z mainframe business between April and July 1. The stock slipped another 2.4 percent on 24 September, to about $227, leaving a $213.9 billion company 2. Partner Reed Kathrein's question is the whole case: whether and when IBM "may have had information raising the probability that large deals were unlikely to timely close" 1.

A record start, 83 days before the fall

On 22 April, IBM reported first-quarter Infrastructure revenue up 15 percent, Hybrid Infrastructure up 28 and IBM Z up 51, and guided to 5-plus percent constant-currency growth for 2026 with a second quarter "similar to the full year" 1. The z17, pitched as enterprise-grade iron for real-time AI processing at unprecedented scale, was off to a "record start" 1.

The selling never stopped. On 7 July, IBM shipped compact, rack-mount z17s aimed at on-premises AI inference 3. Seven days later came Krishna's letter: revenue up 1 percent, Infrastructure down 7, and "numerous large deals failed to close" 4. The stock lost more than 25 percent and over $68 billion of market value in its worst single day as a public company 15.

The AI boom ate the mainframe's capex dollar

The letter names the mechanism. In late June, clients "shift their quarterly capex spend toward servers, storage, and memory purchases to secure supply-constrained infrastructure ahead of expected price increases" 4. Krishna put the coming price jumps at 15 to 30 percent, and Dell, HP and Apple had already warned that AI-buildout memory costs were forcing increases 6. The redirected June budget points to the harvesters: the server and memory suppliers of the AI buildout, Dell and HP−0.17% — HP, down 0.17 percent as of its last quote among them 46.

Every dollar a bank spent hoarding memory was a dollar that did not buy a mainframe in June. Z revenue fell 42 percent, Hybrid Infrastructure fell 10 and Transaction Processing fell 8, taking with it the $3 of software IBM earns on every $1 of mainframe hardware 67.

IBM Z swung from +51% growth to a 42% decline in one quarter

  • Q1 2026
  • Q2 2026
-60%-40%-20%0%20%40%60%IBM Z-42.0%51.0%Hybrid Infrastructure-10.0%28.0%Infrastructure segment-7.0%15.0%Total revenue1.1%9.5%-88%
Data
Q1 2026Q2 2026Change
IBM Z51.0%-42.0%—
Hybrid Infrastructure28.0%-10.0%—
Infrastructure segment15.0%-7.0%—
Total revenue9.5%1.1%-88.4%
Year-over-year revenue growth, Q1 2026 versus Q2 2026. Segment growth rates as IBM stated them, Q1 in the 22 April release and Q2 in the 14 July preannouncement and the official 22 July results, rounded as reported; total revenue growth computed from IBM's SEC-filed quarterly revenue.1,6,7,8

Deferral, or destruction

Krishna's defense is arithmetic: the delayed deals numbered "in the low tens," about a third closed in the three weeks after quarter-end, and z17 is running at nearly 130 percent of z16's pace, "deferral and not destruction" 5. IBM still cut its 2026 constant-currency growth view to 4 to 5 percent, from 5-plus 7. Shares have climbed 13.1 percent since the 22 July report, but Morgan Stanley−1.26% — Morgan Stanley, down 1.26 percent today cut its target from $293 to $190, and KeyCorp downgraded on 23 June, before the crash 27.

IBM's growth accelerated through 2025, then collapsed to 1.1% in Q2 2026

0%5%10%15%Q4 '23Q2 '24Q4 '24Q2 '25Q4 '25Q2 '261.1%
Data
Revenue growth
Q3 '234.6%
Q4 '234.1%
Q1 '241.5%
Q2 '241.9%
Q3 '241.5%
Q4 '241%
Q1 '250.5%
Q2 '257.7%
Q3 '259.1%
Q4 '2512.1%
Q1 '269.5%
Q2 '261.1%
Year-over-year growth in IBM total revenue by quarter, computed from IBM's SEC-filed quarterly revenue. The Q2 2026 print of 1.1 percent is the collapse that followed the April guide of 5-plus percent.8

The tell is the next Z print

Whether the deferred deals actually close shows up in the third-quarter Z print. That number tests the deferral thesis and helps decide whether the investigation hardens into a filed class action; Hagens Berman is already advertising whistleblower rewards of up to 30 percent of any SEC recovery 1. The pitch continues regardless: on 22 September, IBM put a z17 at Marist University to provide "enormous AI computing power" 9. IBM built the z17 to run AI where the money moves. In June, the money moved to AI instead.

Get Platforms by email, free

The cloud, data and developer software AI is built on. In our daily email, every weekday.

Loading IBM

Reader comments

0 comments

    More in Platforms

    All in this topic →

    Platforms

    Dynatrace tells its largest customers to cut log costs in half while log consumption nears $250 million

    The advice comes from the vendor's own market chief, days after its CFO built an investor case on a log-consumption boom nearing $250 million. Until enterprises pay for the agent trace instead of the stored byte, the gap between those two stories sits with shareholders.

    Platforms

    Appian's first agent economics: an 80% token cut from giving agents less work

    The November 17 launch prices nothing, and the one named customer saved money by moving work off agents. That points demand at Appian's legacy process line, and APPN closed down 3.8%.

    Platforms

    Twilio opens its voice network to any AI model as OpenAI sells its own calls at $0.05 a minute

    The November 17 launch opens Twilio's network to any model or agent vendor, days after OpenAI priced direct voice calls at $0.05 a minute. For TWLO holders, the question is whether renting the toll road to whoever wins defends a growth guide that already cost the stock 15%.

    Platforms

    Workday moves to buy Honeydew, the layer that keeps AI agents' numbers honest

    Workday will fold Honeydew's semantic layer into Data Cloud so every agent computes a metric the same governed way, with the price left undisclosed for the second time in five weeks. The agent meter this defends gets priced on November 24.

    Platforms

    Replit's agent swarm rebuilt its monitoring platform in two days for $3,000

    Replit's agent swarms rebuilt licensed monitoring software for $3,000 in two days. The receipt is real, but it comes from the company's own benchmark table, and the swarm arithmetic shows the last agents bought the least.

    Platforms

    Databricks CEO says he will take the $190 billion data firm public, waiting out AI stock swings

    Ali Ghodsi has given his firmest commitment yet that the $190 billion data-and-AI company will list, and named the AI sector's stock swings as the thing to wait out. The private machinery he runs instead of an IPO, annual buybacks of employee shares, keeps going undersubscribed: staff are choosing not to sell at a record valuation, and the timing now rides on sentiment rather than results.

    Subscribe to TheInference for free