Deals

Two courts ordered Verisk to keep pursuing its $2.35 billion AccuLynx deal; the FTC decides if it closes

Delaware's Supreme Court has affirmed an order forcing Verisk to keep pursuing the $2.35 billion AccuLynx deal it terminated in December 2025; the FTC's open antitrust review now decides whether the bill comes due.

Vincent JiangVincent Jiangthree-minute read
Share
Lee Shavel, chief executive of Verisk Analytics, whose $2.35 billion AccuLynx acquisition two Delaware courts have ordered the company to keep pursuing
1 / 5Slide 1 of 5
Verisk chief executive Lee Shavel. The company's October 29 SEC filing says the AccuLynx deal "remains subject to the satisfaction of customary closing conditions and FTC review."

Two courts say the deal Verisk killed is still alive

On October 23, 2026, the Delaware Supreme Court affirmed a judgment ordering Verisk+0.96% — Verisk, up 0.96 percent as of its last quote (Nasdaq: VRSK), the insurance-data company whose Xactimate software carriers and adjusters use to price property-damage claims, to keep pursuing its $2.35 billion acquisition of AccuLynx, a Wisconsin maker of cloud software for roofing contractors 123. Verisk had terminated the deal in December 2025 2.

Its October 29 filing with the Securities and Exchange Commission attaches a four-sentence statement: Verisk "will proceed in accordance with the Court's order," and the deal "remains subject to the satisfaction of customary closing conditions and FTC review, and there is no guarantee that the transaction will be completed" 1.

The order puts a 2025 price back on Verisk's books: $2.35 billion against a $24.7 billion market capitalization, about 9.5 percent, and almost exactly the free cash flow of its last eight quarters 268.

The AccuLynx price equals almost two years of Verisk free cash flow

$0B$0.1B$0.2B$0.3B$0.4BQ3 '24Q4 '24Q1 '25Q2 '25Q3 '25Q4 '25Q1 '26Q2 '26$0.3B
Data
Free cash flow
Q3 '24$0.24B
Q4 '24$0.2B
Q1 '25$0.39B
Q2 '25$0.19B
Q3 '25$0.34B
Q4 '25$0.28B
Q1 '26$0.33B
Q2 '26$0.3B
Quarterly free cash flow, USD billions, per Verisk's SEC filings; the eight quarters shown total $2.26 billion against the $2.35 billion purchase price.8,2

How an email to ServiceTitan cost Verisk its exit

Verisk signed in July 2025, telling investors to expect a close by that year's third quarter 37. Richard Spanton Jr. signed for the sellers as representative of the equityholders of ExactLogix, AccuLynx's parent 1. Shortly after the announcement, Verisk ended an "enhanced integration" with ServiceTitan−0.57% — ServiceTitan, down 0.57 percent as of its last quote, AccuLynx's larger rival, by email 2.

Screening the merger, the Federal Trade Commission asked whether Verisk had ever terminated integration talks with an AccuLynx competitor. Verisk answered no; the agency had information that it had, with ServiceTitan. It asked again and in October 2025 issued a second request, the FTC's extended antitrust review 237. The review ran past December 26, 2025, the merger agreement's outside date, or drop-dead deadline; Verisk declared the deal terminated, and AccuLynx disputed the move the same day 27.

Why "willful conduct" beat the outside date

In August 2026, Judge Bonnie David of the Delaware Court of Chancery, the state's business court, ruled the termination invalid because Verisk's "willful conduct caused the failure of a condition to closing" 37. She ordered specific performance, compelling "commercially reasonable efforts" toward approval and a close if approved, and awarded AccuLynx more than $3.5 million in damages, unopposed because Verisk had waived its right to contest them 23. "It is not inequitable to hold the parties to their bargain," she wrote 3.

The agreement barred termination when a party's own willful conduct was the primary cause of a failed condition, and the court read "willful" to mean voluntary, intentional acts, not only a scheme to derail closing 35. Verisk "strongly disagree[d]" and weighed an appeal 4. The Supreme Court affirmed on October 23, adding no new legal analysis 35.

The FTC decides which bill Verisk pays

The Commission now holds the only gate still open. Roofing contractors already object to Xactimate's owner holding their business data 2. If the agency clears, AccuLynx's equityholders collect the 2025 price they signed for and VRSK holders fund it; if it blocks, the awarded damages stand, and trade press coverage warns the extended review could cost Verisk much more money and time 2. The reading to watch is the FTC's second-request decision; no date is public, and Verisk's own filing carries the hedge: "no guarantee that the transaction will be completed" 1.

Get Deals by email, free

The acquisitions, rounds and contracts that move AI money. In our daily email, every weekday.

Loading TTAN

Reader comments

0 comments

    Deals

    Axon agrees to pay $1.2 billion for Skydio at $5.2 billion pre-money, about five times bookings

    Skydio CEO Adam Bry claims a US sales win over DJI that no outside figure can check, days after Axon agreed to pay $5.2 billion pre-money, about five times Skydio's bookings, for both the stake and the channel. Whose money moves: Axon shareholders and Skydio's early backers.

    Deals

    Transom Capital bids $8 a share for SoundThinking, plus up to $3 in a payout agreement not signed

    Transom Capital's tender offer hands SoundThinking shareholders $8.00 in cash per share and a claim worth up to $3.00 more, but the agreement that would pay it has not been signed. Meanwhile Chicago, Rockford and Cambridge are reopening their ShotSpotter contracts in the same week, which is exactly the revenue those payouts depend on.

    Deals

    Morgan Stanley buys Vinyl Equity, the register keeper, a day before Anthropic's IPO roadshow

    The bank added the shareholder register to a private-to-public stack it already runs, one day before opening the roadshow for the year's biggest AI listing. The question underneath is who captures founder wealth when the shares unlock.

    Deals

    Elliott and Brookfield price $1.4 billion of secured notes at 10.5% to fund their DoubleVerify buyout

    Priced on November 10 and settling on November 30, the notes cost about $147 million a year in interest, close to two quarters of DoubleVerify's cash profit. A filing a day earlier moved the expected close into this quarter, leaving holders a five-cent spread against the $13.60 cash price.

    Deals

    Google bought Crusoe's Wyoming AI campus, price undisclosed, as Google plans a $17 billion buildout

    The AI developer priced at $30.9 billion just handed its flagship 10-gigawatt campus to the hyperscaler it failed to sign as a customer, with the sale price left undisclosed. Every investor pricing the developer premium in CoreWeave, Nebius and IREN now has one data point on what an originated gigawatt site actually converts for.

    Deals

    Groq asks private investors for $8 billion, 2.5 times its August price

    The round is live and unclosed while a Delaware suit argues the technology behind the pitch still belongs to shareholders Nvidia may have bought outright.

    Get the newsletter

    The day's AI and market news, in your inbox every weekday.