Apple to block identity servers on iPhones; the FTC leashed Publicis's $2.2 billion LiveRamp purchase

Apple moved to block the identity servers behind post-cookie ID graphs, the FTC put a five-year neutrality leash on Publicis's $2.2 billion LiveRamp purchase, and Omnicom answered by binding Acxiom's identity graph to Amazon Web Services. The Q3 print due after tonight's close must show whether Omnicom owns a data business or rents one.

Richard TangRichard Tangthree-minute read
Share
Craig Federighi, Apple's senior vice president of software engineering, speaking on stage at Web Summit 2021 in Lisbon
1 / 5Slide 1 of 5
Craig Federighi, Apple's senior vice president of software engineering, at Web Summit 2021 in Lisbon. Apple's iOS 27 plan would block the third-party identity-resolution servers that post-cookie ID graphs run on.

The market repriced independent ad-data platforms this week, on evidence from the businesses as well as the stocks. Apple−0.73% — Apple, down 0.73 percent today published a plan to block identity-resolution servers from Apple devices starting with iOS 27; the FTC approved Publicis's $2.2 billion purchase of LiveRamp+0.71% — LiveRamp, up 0.71 percent as of its last quote only with a five-year neutrality leash; and Omnicom+0.02% — Omnicom, up 0.02 percent today spent October 20 signing its Acxiom identity graph over to Amazon Web Services−3.08% — Amazon Web Services, down 3.08 percent today 123.

The Trade Desk−5.71% — The Trade Desk, down 5.71 percent today, the largest remaining neutral buying platform, closed October 16 at $12.23, 91.2% below its December 2024 high 5. That is deterioration, not just sentiment: its Q2 operating margin fell to 14.2% from 16.8% a year earlier, and it cut 15% of its staff in September 5.

Trade Desk revenue growth has slid from 28% to 3% in two years

0%10%20%30%Q2 '24Q4 '24Q2 '25Q4 '25Q2 '263%
Data
Revenue growth, year over year
Q1 '2428.3%
Q2 '2425.9%
Q3 '2427.3%
Q4 '2422.3%
Q1 '2525.4%
Q2 '2518.7%
Q3 '2517.7%
Q4 '2514.3%
Q1 '2611.8%
Q2 '263%
The Trade Desk quarterly revenue, year-over-year growth, Q1 2024 to Q2 2026, from SEC filings. The company has guided fiscal Q3 2026 revenue to at least $650 million against $739 million a year earlier [5]. Source: The Trade Desk SEC filings [8].8

Safari will block the servers that post-cookie ID graphs run on

Safari will refuse to send emails and identifiers from Apple devices to third-party identity servers, and vendors cannot evade the block by reshaping the network request 2. Apple's engineers explicitly reject the first-party-scoped ID graphs the industry rebuilt itself around, because the central resolver is still a third party holding cross-site, cross-device data 2.

Some vendors, including The Trade Desk, have already spun up new domains to dodge the block; a source familiar with one vendor's strategy called the tactic "a temporary Band-Aid, not a solution," and AdExchanger itself describes "a losing game of cat and mouse" 2. Any identity graph fed by web signals therefore shrinks on hundreds of millions of Apple devices.

The regulator now prices neutrality as a cost

Publicis gets LiveRamp, but must guarantee neutral access, firewall competitors' data, submit to an independent auditor and let customers request audits, for five years after closing 1. Omnicom's IPG merger last summer came with a different condition, not denying ad dollars to publishers over political viewpoint, and no auditor 1. The conditions make proving neutrality a recurring cost the market now builds into what a neutral data layer is worth.

Omnicom keeps the customer signal but runs it on Amazon's rails

Credera, Omnicom's transformation consultancy, signed a five-year agreement with AWS on October 20: a dedicated AWS business unit, 3,000 consultants getting certified, 12 to 15 AWS Marketplace listings, and Acxiom's Real ID graph, a 2.6-billion-profile identity database, activated through AWS Clean Rooms and Amazon Marketing Cloud 3.

The consequence is specific: Omnicom will still own the customer relationships and the data, but the infrastructure that matches data to ad outcomes will run inside the cloud of a company that also sells advertising. Publicis bought its data layer outright and accepted an auditor; Omnicom pays in consultants and a five-year commitment to a rival platform.

Tonight's print must split data revenue from billable hours

Omnicom reports Q3 after the NYSE close today: consensus revenue of $6.21 billion against $6.56 billion in Q2, earnings per share of $2.63 to $2.67, with eleven analysts at Hold and a $98.75 average target on a stock that closed Tuesday at $80.92 46. The reported growth since the IPG merger closed is acquired, not organic.

Reported revenue jumped from $4.0B to $6.6B on the IPG merger

  • Revenue, reported
  • Estimate
$0 B$2 B$4 B$6 B$8 BQ3 '23Q1 '24Q3 '24Q1 '25Q3 '25Q1 '26Q3 '26E$6.56 BIPG merger lifts reported revenue
Data
Revenue, reported
Q3 '23$3.58 B
Q4 '23$4.06 B
Q1 '24$3.63 B
Q2 '24$3.85 B
Q3 '24$3.88 B
Q4 '24$4.32 B
Q1 '25$3.69 B
Q2 '25$4.02 B
Q3 '25$4.04 B
Q4 '25$5.53 B
Q1 '26$6.24 B
Q2 '26$6.56 B
Q3 '26E (estimate)$6.21 B
Omnicom quarterly revenue in US dollars, Q3 2023 to Q2 2026, from SEC filings; the Q3 2026 column is analyst consensus from Reuters' earnings preview. The step-up from Q4 2025 is acquired IPG revenue, which is why tonight's organic growth figure is the one to watch. Sources: Omnicom SEC filings; Reuters earnings preview.6,9

Organic growth strips out the acquired IPG revenue, so any growth that remains is what Omnicom's own data and services earn on their own. The number to watch tonight is organic revenue growth excluding IPG, plus Credera pipeline commentary on the 4:30 p.m 4. EDT call 4. If the data business is earning more than rent on rails AWS controls, it will show up there first.

Get Applications by email, free

How AI is changing the software people and companies use. In our daily email, every weekday.

Loading AAPL

Reader comments

0 comments

    More in Applications

    All in this topic →

    Applications

    Four days after reaching ChatGPT's 1.2 billion users, Synthesia capped its free video tier at one a month

    OpenAI killed Sora in March, and a Synthesia plugin now fills the video slot inside ChatGPT, in front of the chatbot's 1.2 billion weekly users. Four days after launch, the $4 billion London company capped its free tier at one AI video a month.

    Applications

    Omnicom's creative networks lose leaders as $1 billion of its Interpublic merger savings come out of labor

    Omnicom's third quarter showed 7.2% organic growth and merger savings arriving on schedule, yet about $1 billion of the $1.5 billion program comes out of labor, and the labor works in the creative shops now shedding executives. December's quarter is the first test of both claims at once, and the answer reads through to Publicis and WPP.

    Applications

    Adobe will let rival AI agents into Photoshop only on terms that keep Adobe paid

    Adobe will host outside agents inside its apps while rival usage is billed on someone else's account, and its own research says 58% of the companies it talks to are stuck in an AI pilot or unable to deploy at scale. The December 9 report, the first under new CEO Anil Chakravarthy, tests which of the two explanations for Adobe's falling net-new ARR holds.

    Applications

    Chegg lost 40 percent of its revenue and stopped reporting subscribers

    AI wiped out the homework-help business and now builds its replacement cheaply. But the pivot is measured in site visits, the subscriber count has vanished, and a stock at $0.61 now faces two listing clocks.

    Applications

    October's record container imports flow straight into Descartes' December 2 quarter

    Descartes Systems Group bills per transaction on multiyear contracts, so the record October container volume its own report measured lands directly in the quarter it reports on December 2. The same surge is the risk if tariff front-loading unwinds.

    Applications

    Coursera trades just $113 million above its cash pile while its own buyback sits $71 million underwater

    The market pays about $113 million, under one times forward EBITDA, for a business guiding to $1.23 billion of revenue, because the merger math fails and management's own $215 million buyback sits $71 million underwater. A 14.7% holder and a poison pill set the collision date.

    Subscribe to TheInference for free