Power

CPUC proposal would cut PG&E's 5,000-mile undergrounding plan to about 1,100 miles

A judge has moved $1.7 billion of wildfire costs onto California ratepayers, and on November 19 the commission votes on a cost test PG&E says would strike 3,900 miles from the capital it earns on. The utility has already cut $2 billion from its own 2027 plan.

Vincent JiangVincent Jiangthree-minute read
Share
Two Pacific Gas and Electric 500 kV transmission lines on steel lattice towers crossing dry, grass-covered hills under a blue sky
1 / 6Slide 1 of 6
Pacific Gas and Electric 500 kV transmission lines crossing I-580 north of the Tesla substation in California. The CPUC's proposed decision would cut most of the distribution-line miles PG&E wants to bury.

Forty-three miles go first

Twelve miles of planned underground line in Fresno County and 31 in Madera County would all become ineligible under a proposed decision the California Public Utilities Commission issued on October 16 1. The decision writes the cost rules for Senate Bill 884, the 2022 law that created the pathway for ten-year burial plans 2. PG&E says its standardized cost-benefit test would leave about 1,100 of the 5,000 miles in its 2028-2037 plan standing 1.

"So 80% of what we had planned to underground would no longer be eligible," said Matt Pender, PG&E's+3.02% — PG&E, up 3.02 percent as of its last quote vice president of undergrounding and system hardening 2. The commission votes on November 19 2. The filed plan carries roughly $16 billion, about $9 a month on the average bill, for lines PG&E says cut ignition risk about 98% 3. It has buried 1,500 miles since 2021, 325 of them this year 4.

The CPUC cost test would leave a fifth of PG&E's 10-year undergrounding plan standing

PG&E says 3,900 of its 5,000 planned miles become ineligible

  • Estimate
0 miles1,000 miles2,000 miles3,000 miles4,000 miles5,000 milesBuried by Nov 20261,500 milesFiled for 2028-20375,000 milesEligible under CPUC proposal1,100 milesCommission votes 19 Nov
Data
Value
Buried by Nov 20261,500 miles
Filed for 2028-2037 (estimate)5,000 miles
Eligible under CPUC proposal (estimate)1,100 miles
Miles of distribution line. Eligibility is PG&E's estimate if the October 16 proposed decision is adopted as written. Sources: PG&E release (9 Nov 2026); KMPH; KRCR.1,2,4

One docket pays PG&E, the other cuts it

On November 13 a commission judge found ratepayers should pay the $1.7 billion still owed from the 2019 Kincade and 2021 Dixie fires, the first such decision under Assembly Bill 1054; upheld, it clears PG&E to raise rates for the remainder 5. The Inference reported that ruling on November 14 5. Six days later, the same commission votes on striking most of the capital PG&E earns on.

Twelve point eight billion spent, two billion pulled back

The utility spent about $12.8 billion on capital across the four quarters to September 6. On September 2, after the state Assembly let a wildfire liability bill die, it deferred $2 billion of 2027 spending and kept $11.4 billion 7. Guidance beyond 2027 is suspended while a board review spanning ring fencing to sales and separations reports by summer 2027 8.

PG&E's capital spending has topped operating cash flow in 10 of the last 12 quarters

  • Capital spending
  • Operating cash flow
$0B$1B$2B$3B$4BQ1 '24Q3 '24Q1 '25Q3 '25Q1 '26Q3 '26$3.3B
Data
Capital spendingOperating cash flow
Q4 '23$2.61B$0.48B
Q1 '24$2.64B$2.26B
Q2 '24$2.3B$0.71B
Q3 '24$2.61B$3.13B
Q4 '24$2.83B$1.93B
Q1 '25$2.64B$2.85B
Q2 '25$3.07B$1.06B
Q3 '25$2.93B$2.85B
Q4 '25$3.16B$1.96B
Q1 '26$3.36B$2.43B
Q2 '26$2.97B$0.91B
Q3 '26$3.3B$2.5B
Capital spending and cash from operations, $ billions, by calendar quarter. Capital spending is reported as positive. Sources: PG&E quarterly figures from its SEC filings, retrieved 16 November 2026.6

Debt stood at $65.5 billion at the end of September, and the below-investment-grade financing issued since 2017 will cost about $4 billion in extra interest 8. One docket hands PG&E $1.7 billion it can bill customers for; the other takes away the wires it bills on 8.

The load still grows, and so does the resistance

Demand is not the problem. PG&E told investors that newly connected data-center capacity reached 174 megawatts by the third quarter, nearly double the 88 at mid-year 9. The sector is leaning in: Duke Energy+1.09% — Duke Energy, up 1.09 percent as of its last quote reaffirmed a $103 billion five-year capital plan this month, and Xcel Energy−0.49% — Xcel Energy, down 0.49 percent as of its last quote rolled out $70 billion 10. PG&E's 2027 core earnings guidance of $1.78 to $1.82 a share still stands 8.

The commission's case is that the test prioritizes the highest fire-threat areas by risk reduction, reliability and cost efficiency, and forces comparison with cheaper options such as covered conductor 2. Consumer Watchdog, an advocacy group, calls the $2 billion deferral "bailout blackmail," and the commission's ratepayer arm moved on October 23 to reopen PG&E's 2027 revenue request so customers do not pay for work no longer planned 11. Three dates decide the next leg: the vote on November 19, capital guidance with February's results, and the review's answer by summer 28.

Get Power by email, free

How AI's hunger for electricity moves utilities, power plants and the grid. In our daily email, every weekday.

Loading DUK

Reader comments

0 comments

    Power

    Bloom Energy's newest billion-dollar NTT DATA and Google power deals ship nothing until 2027

    The stock trades at 39.2x forward earnings, above GE Vernova and Enphase, yet the NTT DATA 900 MW order and the AEP plant for Google ship nothing until 2027 and 2028 while Q3 cash flow ran negative. The de-rating is a bet on when signed megawatts become invoiced ones.

    Power

    Pinnacle West files 25-year deal making TSMC fund its own power ahead of a December rate decision

    The 25-year contract is the template for every data-center deal that follows it, and it lands before two Arizona regulators elected three days earlier on bill anger. Pinnacle West's growth story now rides on convincing them.

    Power

    Energy Department paid BWXT $68 million for uranium work as its first US new-build order slips to 2027

    The payment has sat unremarked in federal data for eleven days, and the one tracker that noticed coded the award to L3Harris. It is the funded half of BWXT's growth paying out in cash, while the commercial half, the AI-power half, waits on an order that slipped to 2027.

    Power

    AEP counts 84 GW of contracted data-center load; 46 GW of it, in Texas, cannot yet energize

    AEP sells investors 84 GW of contracted demand and a $100.4 billion buildout, but half of that load is Texas letters of agreement that obligate no one to buy power, and ERCOT has paused the process that could approve any of it. The stock, at 20.9 times earnings, prices the full headline.

    Power

    Southern Company prices $1.75B of equity units at 8.625%, forcing stock buys by 2029

    The units pay 8.625% a year and force buyers to take Southern stock by December 2029, funding a data-center build that Georgia's newly Democratic regulators were elected to police.

    Power

    First Solar booked $1.34 billion of profit and negative $837 million of free cash flow in nine months

    First Solar earned $1.34 billion in nine months and still ran free cash flow $837 million negative, with the profit booked as $1.29 billion of uncollected tax credits. After a five-session, $3.2 billion slide with no company news, that gap, not the P/E, is what owners of a 9.9-times-earnings stock are holding.

    Subscribe to TheInference for free