Economy

Judge delays ruling on Visa and Mastercard's $38 billion swipe-fee deal; rejection means a 2027 trial

Final approval would lock in eight years of capped pricing and give 12 million merchants the right to refuse the networks' priciest cards. Rejection means a 2027 antitrust trial, and with the Federal Reserve's debit cap already vacated, every leg of the US card toll is under revision at once.

Vincent JiangVincent Jiangthree-minute read
Share
Visa chief executive Ryan McInerney in a studio headshot against a white background
Ryan McInerney, chief executive of Visa, one of the two networks asking Judge Brian Cogan to grant final approval to the $38 billion swipe-fee settlement.

One Brooklyn judge now holds 21 years of litigation

Visa−1.49% — Visa, down 1.49 percent today and Mastercard−1.89% — Mastercard, down 1.89 percent today asked US District Judge Brian Cogan on November 16 to grant final approval to a $38 billion settlement ending 21 years of antitrust litigation over swipe fees, the interchange charges merchants pay to accept cards 1. After a 90-minute hearing in Brooklyn, Cogan deferred, promising a ruling "as soon as possible" 2. Reject the deal, he warned, and there is no more "head-banging" toward a settlement: the case goes to trial in 2027 2.

The term sheet: a five-year haircut and an eight-year cap

The deal trims credit interchange by 10 basis points for five years and caps standard consumer card fees at 1.25% for eight years 13. It retires the honor-all-cards rule, so a merchant can refuse commercial and premium rewards cards while still taking standard Visa or Mastercard plastic, though merchants still cannot pick among the banks that issue those cards 1. More than 12 million merchants are covered; opponents count over 20 million affected businesses 1. Approval starts a 90-day clock to rewrite network acceptance rules, with steering pilots capped at 180 days a year 4.

The fee quadrupled while the case aged

Visa and Mastercard collected $25.6 billion of US swipe fees in 2009, $111.2 billion in 2024 and $118.8 billion in 2025, an average rate of 2.36%, by Merchants Payments Coalition figures 15. All networks combined took a record $198.25 billion in 2025 5. The plaintiffs' economists, Nobel laureate Joseph Stiglitz and University of Washington professor Keith Leffler, put merchant savings at $38 billion by 2031 and overall benefits at $224 billion 13. That is roughly $7 billion a year against $118.8 billion collected, and 10 basis points is about 4% off the average fee 13.

Swipe fees quadrupled while the case aged

$0B$50B$100B$150B200920242025Deal on offer trims the rate 10bp
Data
Visa and Mastercard US swipe fees
2009$25.6B
2024$111.2B
2025$118.8B
US swipe fees collected by Visa and Mastercard, by Merchants Payments Coalition figures. The deal on offer trims credit interchange by 10 basis points, about 4% off the 2.36% average rate.1,5

Twenty-one years have paid merchants 11 cents on the dollar

The only cash this case has moved is the separate $5.5 billion damages settlement reached in 2018: Epiq, the class administrator, has paid $631.7 million to 689,340 merchants, about 11 cents per promised dollar, with $5.02 billion still in the fund as of September 30 6.

That record feeds more than 1,000 objections from Walmart−0.44% — Walmart, down 0.44 percent today, the National Retail Federation, Circle K and DoorDash−1.70% — DoorDash, down 1.70 percent today 2. Mithun Mansinghani, lawyer for the convenience-store camp, told Cogan that commercial and premium cards, by his count more than 90% of the market, keep their fees, and the deal is like "building a bridge that goes a quarter of the way across the Hudson" 1.

Visa's lawyer Michael Shuster answered that the relief is "potent" and the network is not "jumping with joy"; American Express−1.14% — American Express, down 1.14 percent today and Discover sit outside the deal entirely 1.

The fork: a written cap or an unpriced injunction

Approval writes the 1.25% cap and the steering rights into a contract for eight years 12. Rejection opens a trial Cogan sized at roughly two months, an injunction phase he called a "protracted process," and an appeal to the Second Circuit 12. The debit side is already live: the Eighth Circuit vacated the Federal Reserve's 21-cent cap on October 26, and the Fed has until about December 10 to seek a rehearing, a deadline tracked on November 12 78. For the networks' investors, one path prices the cap today and the other leaves it to a court. The written ruling picks the fork.

Get Economy by email, free

How AI moves rates, banks, payments and the wider economy. In our daily email, every weekday.

Loading MA

Reader comments

0 comments

    More in Economy

    All in this topic →

    Economy

    Goldman Sachs made its own gold bear case the base case and cut its 2027 target to $4,650

    Goldman's economists made a March 2027 hike and a December 2027 first cut the base case, which turns a year of negative carry for gold holders into the official forecast. The rebound to $4,650 now rests on one buyer that does not read the Fed.

    Economy

    Morgan Stanley raises its S&P 500 target to 8,700 even as its own rates desk expects two more Fed hikes

    The bank's equity team went max overweight while its rates desk still expects two more Fed hikes, and Wilson named more hawkish policy as the main risk to his own 8,700 call. Which side of that trade your money sits on.

    Economy

    Baker Hughes' 56.7% HMH stake is worth $266 million, more than the float; Akastor holds an identical stake

    The November 16 13G is the first since HMH's IPO lock-up expired, and it shows an exchangeable stake worth roughly $266 million against a float worth about $203 million, with Akastor holding an identical right. Whether either parent converts or takes cash decides whose money moves.

    Economy

    Coinbase's desk blames the Fed, not Binance, for Bitcoin's slide as $11.5 billion of stablecoins drained

    The desk that made the attribution earns its most resilient revenue from stablecoin float, and the same rate path is draining that float: the GENIUS Act bars the tokens from paying yield, so every basis point of hike odds widens the gap a zero-yield dollar token loses to T-bills.

    Economy

    Michael Burry closed his Oracle and Caterpillar puts as too expensive after a $4.2 trillion AI selloff

    Michael Burry kept his Nvidia and semiconductor-ETF puts but shut his Oracle and Caterpillar puts, saying premiums got too rich after a $4.2 trillion AI-trade selloff. The same night, David Tepper's Appaloosa opened a $172 million Oracle stake.

    Economy

    Bitmine holds 4.97% of all ether, $59 million from the cap that ends its buying

    Bitmine Immersion marked its ether pile down $2.5 billion in a week, to $11.8 billion, and kept buying. Chairman Tom Lee says the slide into Anthropic's November 18 IPO mirrors ether's fall before SpaceX priced, and at last week's pace his 5% cap is about a month of buying away.

    Subscribe to TheInference for free