Chips

Qualcomm won $2 in a Delaware jury verdict against Arm; $1.5 billion of royalties await a judge

A Delaware jury found Arm deliberately breached its license with Qualcomm and awarded two dollars. The clause that finding activates could let Qualcomm stop paying royalties for five years, and Arm reports on November 4 carrying a 232-times multiple.

Vincent JiangVincent Jiang · 3 min read
Share
Qualcomm chief executive Cristiano Amon backstage at Web Summit in Lisbon
1 / 6Slide 1 of 6
Qualcomm chief executive Cristiano Amon, who testified that Arm's proposed royalty for its next architecture ran 18,500% above current rates.

A Delaware jury has found that Arm+2.72% — Arm, up 2.72 percent today Holdings broke its own licensing agreement with Qualcomm−1.66% — Qualcomm, down 1.66 percent today, and did it deliberately 1. The award was $2, one dollar per claim 1. The exposure runs to $1.5 billion: the royalties Qualcomm may now ask a judge to stop paying for five years 2.

Two dollars for the breach, $1.5 billion still live

On October 13 the jury found Arm violated the Architectural License Agreement, the top licensing tier that lets Qualcomm, Apple−0.35% — Apple, down 0.35 percent today and Amazon−0.17% — Amazon, down 0.17 percent today design custom CPU cores instead of buying Arm's ready-made designs, and that Arm intentionally interfered with Qualcomm's chip relationship with Meta−1.09% — Meta, down 1.09 percent today Platforms after a 2024 leak of a confidential breach notice stalled a Meta deal 12. Jurors cleared Arm of Qualcomm's claims that it broke most-favored-nation pricing terms 12.

The breach finding activates the question US District Judge Maryellen Noreika must now answer: whether a clause letting Qualcomm suspend royalties for five years is enforceable 1. Analysts put those royalties near $300 million a year, within total payments of about $443 million from Qualcomm, some 9% of Arm's $4.92 billion revenue in the fiscal year ended March 31, 2026, and nearly half its $900 million operating income 2. Arm calls the clause an unenforceable penalty; closing arguments were heard on October 20, and the loser will almost certainly appeal 12.

The rate ladder the court let slip

The fight underneath is price. Qualcomm chief executive Cristiano Amon testified that Arm's proposed royalty for its next ARMv10 architecture runs 18,500% above current rates 2. Court-surfaced figures assembled by analysts put Qualcomm's current payment at a maximum of $1.88 per chip, with Arm demanding up to $28.20 through 2033 and $64.86 from 2034 to 2040, and a $250 million upfront offer from Qualcomm to lock the rate was refused 4. Qualcomm's existing license runs to 2033 2.

Arm's demanded per-chip rate on Qualcomm climbs from $1.88 to as much as $64.86

  • Estimate
$0/chip$20/chip$40/chip$60/chip$80/chipNow (maximum)$1.88/chip2027–2033 demand$28.2/chip2034–2040 demand$64.86/chip
Data
Value
Now (maximum)$1.88/chip
2027–2033 demand (estimate)$28.2/chip
2034–2040 demand (estimate)$64.86/chip
Maximum per-chip royalty, US dollars. Derived from details that surfaced in court and were reported on October 22, 2026; the 2027–2033 and 2034–2040 bars are Arm's demands, not agreed rates.4

The licensor became the competitor

The feud tracks Arm's own transformation. After SoftBank took control in 2016 and Arm began selling its own chips, it launched the AGI CPU in March 2026, a 136-core server processor co-developed with Meta and the first silicon Arm has ever sold, which made the licensor a rival of its own customers 135.

Qualcomm complained to the Federal Trade Commission, the European Commission and South Korea's regulator, and the FTC opened an investigation in May 2026 2. The verdict also flips the posture of the first trial, where a jury cleared Qualcomm over its Nuvia acquisition in December 2024; Arm's appeal there is still pending 2. The day before the latest verdict, Arm paired with Axiado, a San Jose security-chip maker, to add secure control modules to the AGI CPU server platform 6.

The market looked past the courtroom

Arm's counter is on the record: the company says the two-dollar award and its wins on pricing confirm it acted in good faith 1. Investors have chosen the same reading. Shares dipped about 1% on the verdict 3, yet by October 27 Arm traded at $225.75, up 6.19% on the day, a $241.1 billion market capitalization at 232 times earnings, with Qualcomm up 2.10% 78. That price leans on an analyst scenario of $15 billion from AGI CPU silicon plus $10 billion from IP licensing by fiscal 2031 7.

Arm's quarterly revenue is up about 60% in three years, to $1.29 billion

$0.8B$1B$1.2B$1.4B$1.6BQ4 '23Q2 '24Q4 '24Q2 '25Q4 '25Q2 '26$1.29BAGI CPU launched March 2026
Data
Revenue
Q3 '23$0.81B
Q4 '23$0.82B
Q1 '24$0.93B
Q2 '24$0.94B
Q3 '24$0.84B
Q4 '24$0.98B
Q1 '25$1.24B
Q2 '25$1.05B
Q3 '25$1.14B
Q4 '25$1.24B
Q1 '26$1.49B
Q2 '26$1.29B
Quarterly revenue, US dollar billions, from Arm's SEC filings, calendar quarters; Arm's fiscal year ends March 31. Next reading: fiscal Q2 2027, reported November 4, 2026.9,5

What the November 4 print has to carry

Arm reports fiscal second-quarter results on November 4, after a June quarter of $1.29 billion in revenue, up 22% year on year, with $715 million of it royalties 89. Susquehanna's Christopher Rolland still carries a Buy and a $320 target, 41.7% above the tape 8. Judge Noreika has set no date for her ruling 2. The jury priced the insult at two dollars; the contract prices the breach at $1.5 billion 2.

Get Chips by email, free

How AI demand is reshaping chipmakers, memory and the fabs behind them. In our daily email, every weekday.

Loading ARM

Reader comments

0 comments

    Chips

    UMC missed consensus at 92% utilization and added $3.2 billion of capex, with the stock up 147.5%

    The mature-node foundry missed consensus and asked its board for another US$3.2 billion of capex, while 45% of its nine-month pre-tax profit came from outside operations. The 2027 price rise management promised is still only a negotiation.

    Chips

    Motorola locked in decade-long prices, then the memory bill tripled

    Louisiana locked in a $192.6 million no-bid deal and the Bureau of Prisons obligated $139.6 million, while Motorola's memory bill tripled to $150 million. The November 4 print decides who eats the difference.

    Chips

    Zhongji Innolight reports Thursday down 50% with full 2027 orders and a reported US import ban

    Zhongji Innolight, the world's largest optical transceiver maker, reports Q3 on October 29 down more than 50 percent from its record high, with full 2027 order books on one side and Nvidia's Taiwan-only partner list plus a possible US import ban on the other.

    Chips

    Amkor's AI customers prepay $1.9 billion while its 2027 capex above $2 billion stays on its balance sheet

    Amkor's new 10-Q shows about $1.9 billion of customer advance payments due within 12 months, set against a 2027 capital budget framed above $2 billion. Until that cash lands, the AI packaging build sits on Amkor's own balance sheet.

    Chips

    Ultra Clean Holdings posts a record $759 million quarter as Lam Research says parts cap the AI chip boom

    Ultra Clean's record $759 million quarter, up 49% with guidance above estimates, is the first supplier-level evidence of the chip-tool shortage Lam Research flagged last week. The bill sits with the supplier: negative operating cash flow, $723 million of hoarded inventory and fresh share sales.

    Chips

    Shorts left Skyworks at the fastest rate on FINRA's list as the Qorvo deal closed

    FINRA's October 15 report shows Skyworks short interest down 3.74 points to 14.9% of float, the largest fall on its list, in the window that spans the October 5 close of the $22 billion Qorvo combination. On November 3 the combined company gives its first guidance.

    Get the newsletter

    The day's AI and market news, in your inbox every weekday.