Chips

Sandisk trades at 3.3 times forward earnings as GF Securities warns of a 2027 NAND glut

Sandisk's record quarter was bought with price, not bytes, and at 3.3 times forward earnings the stock now trades on whichever 2027 the NAND market delivers. The shortage behind the memory trade is signed into contracts in DRAM and still only a forecast in flash.

Richard TangRichard Tangtwo-minute read
Share
Portrait of David Goeckeler, chief executive of Sandisk, wearing glasses and a dark suit against a blue backdrop
David Goeckeler, Sandisk's chief executive, photographed in Tokyo in April 2023 when he led Western Digital. He sold about $53 million of Sandisk stock in September under a pre-arranged plan.

GF Securities has put a date on the risk inside Sandisk's−2.99% — Sandisk, down 2.99 percent today record quarter. On November 17 the brokerage cut its NAND price forecasts and told clients flash could swing into surplus in 2027, with prices flat early in the year and falling for the rest of it 1. Sandisk, the flash maker spun off from Western Digital+2.60% — Western Digital, up 2.60 percent today in February 2025, closed that day at 3.3 times forward earnings, cheaper than Micron−2.50% — Micron, down 2.50 percent today 2. The question is no longer how good the quarter was; it is what an 85% gross margin earns the year after next 2.

Almost all of the quarter's gain was price

Sandisk booked $11.0 billion of September-quarter revenue, up 378% on a year earlier 3. The storage actually shipped, measured in exabytes, grew about 10% over the same span 3. Data-center flash did the work at $4.8 billion for the quarter 4. Consumer sales fell 29% 4. The December guide of $12.2 billion to $12.6 billion halves the sequential growth rate while holding gross margin where it is 34.

Sandisk's gross margin went from 22% to 85% on price alone

The margin came from price per gigabyte; bytes sold grew about 10%

20%40%60%80%100%Q4 '24Q1 '25Q2 '25Q3 '25Q4 '25Q1 '26Q2 '26Q3 '26GF sees NAND prices fallingthrough 2027
Data
Gross margin
Q4 '2432.3%
Q1 '2522.5%
Q2 '2526.2%
Q3 '2529.8%
Q4 '2550.9%
Q1 '2678.4%
Q2 '2684.6%
Q3 '2685%
Quarterly GAAP gross margin from Sandisk's SEC filings, shown by calendar quarter; the latest point is the quarter ended October 2, 2026.5

The shortage has paperwork in DRAM and adjectives in flash

The bull case for memory rests on a shortage that is contracted in DRAM and only forecast in NAND. SK hynix−2.43% — SK hynix, down 2.43 percent today, the Korean memory maker, has long-term contracts with 14 customers covering more than half of its planned 2027 and 2028 output, and expects demand to outrun supply until 2030 67. Blended prices for HBM, the stacked memory in AI accelerators, are forecast to rise 122% next year 7.

Kioxia, whose joint ventures make nearly all of Sandisk's wafers, still expects flash shortages through 2027, yet its December-quarter forecast implies nearly flat prices after selling prices rose in the mid-20% range, down from 70% the quarter before 38.

Kioxia's NAND price growth has gone from 70% to almost nothing

  • Sequential NAND price change
  • Estimate
0%20%40%60%80%Two quarters agoLatest quarterDec-quarter guideNo price change25%
Data
Sequential NAND price change
Two quarters ago70%
Latest quarter25%
Dec-quarter guide (estimate)0%
Sequential change in Kioxia's NAND selling prices, in percent: 70% two quarters ago, mid-20% (charted as 25%) in the September quarter, and roughly flat in the December-quarter forecast, from Kioxia's guidance as reported by CoinCentral and Investing.com. The last bar is a company forecast, not a reported figure.3,8

The split widens access to the same bet

Shares start trading split-adjusted on November 20, after the 8-for-1 issue 4. The split changes who can hold the position, not what the position is: whether 2027 NAND contract prices hold, in the quarters GF expects them falling 1. Chief executive David Goeckeler sold about $53 million of stock in September under a pre-arranged plan 3. ETFs, net buyers for four straight sessions, turned sellers on November 16 9. If prices hold, the multiple is a trough; the receipts so far, Kioxia's+3.07% — Kioxia, up 3.07 percent today flat pricing and GF's glut call, lean the other way. Micron's December report is the next one 2.

DRAM's shortage is signed; NAND's is a forecast. Sandisk is now the price of telling them apart.

Get Chips by email, free

How AI demand is reshaping chipmakers, memory and the fabs behind them. In our daily email, every weekday.

Loading SNDK

Reader comments

0 comments

    Chips

    AMD fell 8% on a short report; the deeper finding is $1.8 billion of packaging at Tongfu-run ventures

    Hunterbrook's short report knocked AMD down 8% on November 19. The finding investors can actually size sits deeper in the document: most AMD chips are assembled, tested and packaged by two ventures 85% owned by Tongfu Microelectronics, whose profit just tripled.

    Chips

    Wall Street raised Applied Materials' 2027 estimate to $19.29 and cut its price target to $562 the same week

    Analysts raised next year's earnings estimate, cut the average price target, and ETF flows flipped to net selling after Applied's record quarter. February's fiscal Q1 report decides whether the repricing was about Applied's supply or its customers' demand.

    Chips

    RIBER shares jump 12.65% on an Asian order backing its €40 million revenue forecast

    The market read a repeat customer's machine order as proof RIBER's at-least-€40-million year holds. But the machine must ship by December 31 into a second half that owes at least €27.3 million of revenue, and the company's own guidance still hangs on a French export license to Asia.

    Chips

    SEALSQ's CFO exercised 160,624 one-cent options two days before the QuintessenceLabs deal

    Two days before SEALSQ said it would buy QuintessenceLabs partly with stock issued above the market, its CFO and innovation chief exercised options struck at one cent, filings show. The shareholders who own the rest fund the cash portion of a purchase with no disclosed price.

    Chips

    SmartSens' 200MP sensor takes the main camera slot in Xiaomi's global 18 Pro; Sony holds none of the four

    A review of global retail hardware puts Shanghai-listed SmartSens inside both Xiaomi flagship mains, with Samsung and OmniVision on the lesser slots and Sony on none. The sockets set how far SmartSens' revenue climbs beyond surveillance cameras, and Huawei's leaked Nova main would hand a slot to rival GalaxyCore.

    Chips

    Skyworks moves three factories post-Qorvo as operating cash halves to $549.9 million

    The first annual report after the Qorvo deal puts three plants in motion and warns that customers may qualify alternative suppliers, while operating cash flow fell to $549.9 million from $1.30 billion.

    Subscribe to TheInference for free