Banks' $50 targets bet on FirstEnergy's 4.3 GW AI load; Pennsylvania and Ohio decide who pays
HSBC and BMO just re-rated FirstEnergy on AI data-center load, but Pennsylvania regulators rejected its billing plan 3-2 and Ohio's Senate race has turned its money into a campaign weapon. The demand is observable; who keeps the margin is not.
Richard Tang · 2 min read
FirstEnergy+0.08% — FirstEnergy, up 0.08 percent today reports Q3 on Tuesday, and the bull case is no longer just wires: HSBC initiated the stock at Buy on Oct 22 explicitly on data-center growth, and BMO followed at Outperform on Monday, both with $50 targets against a $46.15 close 12. The new load is real: the company counts 4.3 GW of contracted and pipeline data-center demand in West Virginia alone as of July 8. But this week showed the second and third links of the chain, and they are not Wall Street's to control.
Regulators decide who pays, and Pennsylvania just said no to FirstEnergy's version
The chain runs: AI builds data centers, data centers need grid, and a regulated utility earns its return only where commissions and legislatures let it.
On Thursday Pennsylvania's PUC rejected 3-2 FirstEnergy's plan to auto-return shopping customers to default service when contracts expire, ordering a review instead by June 1 3. FirstEnergy itself pitched the change with an $82 million estimate of what shopping customers overpaid last year; consumer advocates backed it, competitive suppliers fought it as a backdoor squeeze on retail choice 37. That is a regulator deciding who absorbs the cost of a messy retail market while the utility's grid business grows underneath.
Ohio's bribery scandal is the third link
In Ohio, home of the HB6 bribery scandal, FirstEnergy money is now a Senate-race weapon: Sherrod Brown's posts cite $3.5 million from FirstEnergy and $636,000 from the data-center industry to Jon Husted 56. Every campaign ad makes the next rate-case settlement harder.
October targets put HSBC's and BMO's data-center bulls near the middle
Data
| Value | |
|---|---|
| Jefferies (Oct 22) | 46 |
| BofA (Oct 13) | 47 |
| Barclays (Oct 12) | 49 |
| HSBC (Oct 22, init.) | 50 |
| Morgan Stanley (Oct 21) | 50 |
| Goldman (Oct 15) | 53 |
| BMO (Oct 26, init.) | 50 |
| TD Cowen (Oct 20) | 56 |
The Street's average target is $50.54 across 17 analysts, about 9.5% above the price, with Jefferies+2.02% — Jefferies, up 2.02 percent today at $46 and BofA+0.68% — BofA, up 0.68 percent today Neutral at $47 on the skeptical side 1. My judgment: the data-center demand is the observable fact; the returns on serving it are the contested one. Watch Tuesday's print for the load, and the PUC's June review and Ohio's Nov 3 vote for who keeps the margin 1.
Get Power by email, free
How AI's hunger for electricity moves utilities, power plants and the grid. In our daily email, every weekday.
