NASA's safety panel counts 22 tanker flights for SpaceX's Starship; Musk says 6 to 8, Blue Origin waits

NASA has not picked between SpaceX's Starship and Blue Origin's Blue Moon Mark 2 for the first crewed lunar landing. Its safety panel now counts about 22 refueling flights per Starship landing; Musk says six to eight, and Administrator Isaacman lays out the timeline today.

Richard TangRichard Tangthree-minute read
Share
Elon Musk holds a model of SpaceX's Starship at the Pentagon in 2019
1 / 6Slide 1 of 6
Elon Musk, whose reply put Starship's tanker count at six to eight, with a Starship model at the Pentagon in 2019.

NASA has not decided which lander carries the first Artemis astronauts to the lunar surface, and this week the deciding risk finally got a number. Charlie Precourt, a former astronaut speaking for NASA's Aerospace Safety Advisory Panel (ASAP) on October 22, 2026, said the last estimate for fueling a Starship lunar lander is "around 22" flights 1.

Elon Musk replied on X that the figure was "way too high" and the real count "more like 6 to 8" 2. Administrator Jared Isaacman lays out the Artemis schedule at Kennedy Space Center today 34. Between those two numbers sits the timing of the first crewed landing since 1972, and the split of NASA's lander business between two private companies 3.

The refueling count is really a flight-rate bill

Starship's lander must be topped up in Earth orbit by a depot ship fed by tanker flights, and moving cryogenic propellant between two spacecraft has never been demonstrated; only one Starship flight has reached orbit 56. At the panel's count, the tanker campaign for a single landing would exceed all fourteen Starship test flights to date, and even at twice-weekly launches by the end of 2027, filling the depot would take about three months 12.

By NASA's panel count, one landing's tanker flights top every Starship flight ever

  • Estimate
0510152025ASAP panel estimate, per landing22Musk's claim, per landing6–8All Starship test flights to date14
Data
ValueRange
ASAP panel estimate, per landing (estimate)22—
Musk's claim, per landing (estimate)86–8
All Starship test flights to date14—
Whole launches counted. Panel figure from the October 22, 2026 ASAP meeting; Musk's reply posted on X the same day. Sources: Ars Technica Rocket Report and Ars Technica refueling estimate.1,2

NASA's gate is an orbital propellant-transfer demonstration in early 2027 35. Musk's lower figure rests on newer, larger Starships carrying more propellant per flight, and November's Flight 15, which will attempt to catch both stages back at the pad under a return-to-launch-site license, is where the reuse that shrinks the bill gets built 12. Flight rate is the same constraint behind the orbital AI compute plans we sized up last week 12.

Blue Moon skips the tankers and inherits a grounded rocket

Blue Origin's Blue Moon Mark 2 uses no orbital refueling in its initial design; it launches on New Glenn and goes 24. NASA targets its uncrewed landing three months after SpaceX's, with the Mark 1 cargo lander booked for early 2027 3.

Its risk lives in the rocket below it: New Glenn has not flown since a May 28 pad explosion, Bezos is targeting a December return, and AST SpaceMobile+6.22% — AST SpaceMobile, up 6.22 percent today, a listed New Glenn customer, draws up its satellite deployment plan without counting on that 789. Blue Origin's $3 billion Florida expansion, including a factory sized for 150 upper stages a year, is a bet that cadence, not plumbing, is the binding constraint 7.

Early 2027 turns the argument into data

ASAP is about to formally recommend that NASA re-examine Artemis IV's objectives and potentially its architecture, and it notes NASA requires only one uncrewed landing test before crews board 5. The transfer demonstration settles the dispute the only way it can be settled.

If six-to-eight holds, Starship keeps its lead and the refueling gate never binds; if the panel is right, the gate sits on SpaceX's−3.61% — SpaceX, down 3.61 percent today schedule and NASA's undecided choice tilts toward the lander with no tankers 3. SpaceX is private, and retail traders already argue over it under the symbol SPCX, so the repricing lands first on holders of its cadence thesis 9. The next real number in this market will come from a tanker filling a ship in orbit.

Get Robotics & Defense by email, free

Robots, self-driving vehicles, drones and AI in defense. In our daily email, every weekday.

Loading SPCX

Reader comments

0 comments

    More in Robotics & Defense

    All in this topic →

    Robotics & Defense

    BigBear.ai's baggage-scanning AI joins Europe's 44-state approval list, but only 23% of backlog is funded

    Aviation authorities across 44 European states now hold BigBear.ai's screening AI as a buying reference, the company's first channel that runs on European budgets rather than US appropriations. No order came with the certificate, and the stock fell 4%.

    Robotics & Defense

    Finland becomes 11th country to clear Tesla's renamed Assisted Driving system

    Eleven national approvals, none from the EU's four biggest members, now hang on a December committee vote that can erase them all. In the US, Tesla says the first private cars to drive unsupervised, around Q2 2027, will do so only inside its own robotaxi fleet.

    Robotics & Defense

    Ondas announced an Israeli attack-drone order with no price; Q3 revenue guided to $140 million to $155 million

    The November 10 purchase order under Israel's Digital Bat attack-drone program carries no dollar figure, and the factories meant to build the drones sit inside two acquisitions that have not closed. Q3 results land November 12 with revenue guided to $140–155 million, the first test of whether the announcement cadence converts to cash.

    Robotics & Defense

    GAO rules December 21 on Rocket Lab's challenge to Blue Origin's $700 million Mars award

    Rocket Lab's protest has frozen the Mars Telecommunications Network under an automatic stay, and for RKLB holders the ruling splits one of two ways: the job stays with Blue Origin, or NASA reopens it toward Rocket Lab. The winner's only orbital rocket has been grounded since a May pad explosion and does not fly again until January.

    Robotics & Defense

    Starlink's $156 residential bills start Nov. 30 in Missouri and Kansas after revenue per customer fell to $69

    The repricing lands in the segment that pays 85% of SpaceX's operating profit, in the same quarter Starlink's revenue per customer fell 17% to $69.

    Robotics & Defense

    Google's Gemini Robotics 2.5 hit 96% on live Mercedes production lines, with no order or price attached

    The model belongs to Alphabet, and the hardware's one US-listed pure-play just posted $1.8 million of revenue against a $138.1 million net loss. The question the eight-outlet coverage skipped is who gets paid, and how much, when a 96% demo becomes an order.

    Get the newsletter

    The day's AI and market news, in your inbox every weekday.