Power

Nine states sue as offshore wind buyouts near $4 billion booked to a lawsuit fund

Nine states sued on 22 September to void Interior Department deals that would pay Bluepoint Wind and Invenergy more than $1.5 billion to abandon offshore wind leases, with the money booked to the Judgment Fund, a Treasury account reserved for court judgments. Counted deal by deal, the buyout program has agreed to return $3.93 billion to developers.

Vincent JiangVincent Jiangthree-minute read
Share
Official portrait of Interior Secretary Doug Burgum in a navy suit and red tie, standing before US and Interior Department flags
1 / 6Slide 1 of 6
Interior Secretary Doug Burgum, whose department struck the lease buyout deals nine states now ask courts to void.

The charge: settlements with no lawsuit

On 22 September, attorneys general from New York and seven neighboring states filed two federal suits against Interior Department deals with Bluepoint Wind and Invenergy, and California filed a third over an Invenergy lease off Morro Bay 12. Together they target more than $1.5 billion in reimbursements. Governor Kathy Hochul called the arrangement an unlawful "pay-to-not-play scheme" 1.

The money is booked to the Judgment Fund, a Treasury account Congress reserved for legitimate legal claims against the government, with no spending cap 12. Neither developer had sued; the states say that leaves no claim to settle 13.

Six deals, $3.93 billion

Counted deal by deal, the program has agreed to return $3.93 billion to developers since March. TotalEnergies struck first, two leases redirected into Rio Grande LNG and Gulf oil and gas 4. Bluepoint followed in April, in line to recover up to its full 2022 New York Bight bid as its BlackRock-linked co-owner commits the same amount to a US LNG plant, plus a pledge never to pursue US offshore wind again 51. Golden State Wind's cancellation came the same month 5.

Invenergy signed in June, four leases redirected into gas plants across five Midwestern states and western geothermal 4. Duke followed in July, surrendering a Carolina lease it had paid $155 million for in 2022 6. RWE's August exit is the largest, pairing a $900 million Louisiana LNG stake with a $300 million turbine order; before it, the administration had agreed to return about $2.7 billion across nine leases 7.

Six buyouts, $3.93 billion agreed to make US offshore wind walk away

$0B$0.5B$1B$1.5BRWE (Aug)$1.22BLargest deal, pushed the total past $3.9BTotalEnergies (Mar)$0.93BBluepoint (Apr)$0.77BInvenergy (Jun)$0.77BDuke (Jul)$0.13BGolden State Wind (Apr)$0.12B
Data
Value
RWE (Aug)$1.22B
TotalEnergies (Mar)$0.93B
Bluepoint (Apr)$0.77B
Invenergy (Jun)$0.77B
Duke (Jul)$0.13B
Golden State Wind (Apr)$0.12B
Reimbursements the Interior Department has agreed to pay developers for relinquishing US offshore wind leases, in billions of US dollars, by company and 2026 announcement month. Total computed from reported deal values.1,4,5,6,7

Eight gigawatts out while the AI buildout bids

The leases in the new suits were expected to generate more than 8 GW, enough for more than four million homes, and New York counted $16 billion of investment and 2,800 jobs on the two projects off its coast 1. Those turbines were 2030s power, not this decade's: RWE, which struck the same kind of exit, says its projects were early-stage and not due online until the 2030s 7.

Even so, the exits land on a grid Morgan Stanley−2.46% — Morgan Stanley, down 2.46 percent as of its last quote expects to run 33 GW short through 2028 on data-center demand, a residual gap inside 97 GW of incremental need 8. New York's planners project demand up 8% by 2030 and 24% by 2040, driven partly by data centers 1. Eight gigawatts were subtracted from a grid already expected to run short.

Interior: common sense, not subsidies

Interior calls the agreements voluntary settlements that steer capital toward energy it considers reliable and affordable; Secretary Doug Burgum said Americans deserve "an energy system built on common sense, not one dependent on costly subsidies" 72. RWE says permitting left its projects with no path forward 7. The department also argues the canceled leases raised national security concerns 39.

Courts asked to unwind $4 billion of exits

The new cases are pending in federal courts in New York, Maine and California, according to Law Commentary 3. Seven states are already challenging the TotalEnergies deal, and California has signaled a challenge to RWE 72. The states want the cancellations voided 1. The question before the courts is narrow and large at once: whether a fund built to pay judgments can be spent to buy an energy policy.

Get Power by email, free

How AI's hunger for electricity moves utilities, power plants and the grid. In our daily email, every weekday.

Loading MS

Reader comments

0 comments

    Power

    Bloom Energy's newest billion-dollar NTT DATA and Google power deals ship nothing until 2027

    The stock trades at 39.2x forward earnings, above GE Vernova and Enphase, yet the NTT DATA 900 MW order and the AEP plant for Google ship nothing until 2027 and 2028 while Q3 cash flow ran negative. The de-rating is a bet on when signed megawatts become invoiced ones.

    Power

    Pinnacle West files 25-year deal making TSMC fund its own power ahead of a December rate decision

    The 25-year contract is the template for every data-center deal that follows it, and it lands before two Arizona regulators elected three days earlier on bill anger. Pinnacle West's growth story now rides on convincing them.

    Power

    Energy Department paid BWXT $68 million for uranium work as its first US new-build order slips to 2027

    The payment has sat unremarked in federal data for eleven days, and the one tracker that noticed coded the award to L3Harris. It is the funded half of BWXT's growth paying out in cash, while the commercial half, the AI-power half, waits on an order that slipped to 2027.

    Power

    CPUC proposal would cut PG&E's 5,000-mile undergrounding plan to about 1,100 miles

    A judge has moved $1.7 billion of wildfire costs onto California ratepayers, and on November 19 the commission votes on a cost test PG&E says would strike 3,900 miles from the capital it earns on. The utility has already cut $2 billion from its own 2027 plan.

    Power

    AEP counts 84 GW of contracted data-center load; 46 GW of it, in Texas, cannot yet energize

    AEP sells investors 84 GW of contracted demand and a $100.4 billion buildout, but half of that load is Texas letters of agreement that obligate no one to buy power, and ERCOT has paused the process that could approve any of it. The stock, at 20.9 times earnings, prices the full headline.

    Power

    Southern Company prices $1.75B of equity units at 8.625%, forcing stock buys by 2029

    The units pay 8.625% a year and force buyers to take Southern stock by December 2029, funding a data-center build that Georgia's newly Democratic regulators were elected to police.

    Subscribe to TheInference for free